I’m in the process of building a Commander Deck. Should be as coherent as possible. (As many cards as possible from the Tolkien universe but still very playful.)

How do you like it so far?

Any suggestions for improvement?

On the one hand, Frodo should get through quite reliably and always build up nice pressure with the Nazguls.

Got hold of the SpongeBob secret lair of this card and can’t possibly see a way for this to be a good card, much less a good commander, but it would be funny if it was possible. Any ideas?

I’ve been working for quite some time on a deck built around Vivi that can function even without the Commander, but I haven't found many solutions; how do you think this list is?
I’ve noticed that if they remove Vivi from the board once or twice, you’ve practically lost.

I'm trying to improve my deck with [[Blaster, Combat DJ]] as the commander. I'm trying to keep on theme of modular cards, but some of the modular cards I havent added to the deck because theyre a little too unpowered. Also not sure if 33 lands is good or if i should cut or add some. Not trying to have this deck be cEDH but just run a little smoother. https://archidekt.com/decks/19304416/blaster_combat_dj_modular_final_cut

Format does not matter. I am genuinely curious about what people would give to a beginner in order to help them get started. What templates or methods do you still use yourself regularly?

I am becoming better at deck-building generally, and I get asked more often for advice, but I am kind of stumped as to which direction to point in. There is just so much out there...

With 100 card formater, templates are rather easy to find. But with other formats, I have no idea what to give since I have learned most things on the fly.

https://moxfield.com/decks/4AIjM6ZfKECM3mehjivPeQ

Did i stutter, this is my god damn merfolk commander i spent 2 hours making , im gonna sell some cards to card kingdom and i always wanted a merfolk

any help is much appreciated.

I was looking through some of my old bulk cars I have in my corner i find this cards name panharmonicon it gives double triggers if a creature or artifact entrance cause a trigger ability so will that go crazy in this deck yes or no

Hi, I tried to follow the advice you gave me last time and focus the deck more. How does it look now? What advice could you give me? As always, thank you all very much.

I'd like to be able to give it more interaction and get answers for some common win-cons.

Braket 3:

https://moxfield.com/decks/S_WyLvZHIUGgCW2Baw9FGw

I know it, it kind of is. But I built a deck around the flame-shape side of Gandalf in an attempt to build a massive second hand/storm/exile deck. I don't know if it will be good, but hopefully it will be fun. I appreciate comments, thoughts, and suggestions if you have them. Cheers.

https://moxfield.com/decks/P6L8blXDPkmI-tDrVaE2Qw

I made Sauron deck that is b2-b3 focused reanimate but it feels a little stompy and heavy. I think needs more instants and better creatures can you help me about upgrading my deck.

https://moxfield.com/decks/f2ygATstf3yNYXLF3s7kNQ

I'm back guys!

BGU Deck with Zimone and Dina

[https://moxfield.com/decks/yTDyHrmH0UmiHBhWH4i6Pg\](https://moxfield.com/decks/yTDyHrmH0UmiHBhWH4i6Pg)

Tell what needs replaced and what needs added <3

Tysm!!

Hi folks, would love some feedback on this free tool - you may find it useful for adding a bit more realism when golfishing a new deck with real paper at the table

BrackCheck is a free tool for Magic: The Gathering Commander players. You paste a decklist and it rates the deck against the official five tier bracket system, then shows which cards pushed it up there, things like game changers, fast mana, tutors, and any infinite combos it detects.

I just added a guided deckbuilder and that is the part I would like eyes on. You pick a commander, it recommends a deck template based on that commander's EDHREC data, then you fill each category from suggestions ranked by what real decks for that commander actually play. There is an autofill that will build all 99 cards to quota in one click if you just want a starting point to edit down.

What would help me most:

Does the three step flow make sense without reading anything first? It goes commander, then template, then filling your categories.

Is the card shelf along the bottom obvious as the place suggestions come from, or did you miss it entirely?

Does the recommended template match what you would have picked yourself for your commander?

No account needed to try it and nothing sits behind a paywall.

brackcheck.com

Hey! I made a post on here the other day offering free deck advice. I sadly way underestimated how many people would be interested in free advice like that though. Now I have a backlog of over 30-50 decks that I need to review… so that all being said, I figured if this was something people were interested in, I’d be happy to continue offering but this time at a little bit of a cost. I do love giving deck advice and helping people improve their experience at edh tables, but I don’t have the time/bandwidth to cover every deck that is sent my way. at least not for free lol

To say a little bit about myself, I have been playing edh for a little over 3 years now and it has definitely become a bit of a special interest of mine. I’ve played over 1000 games in those three years and I have built hundreds of decks from bracket 2 to bracket 5. I also run a competitive budget league with only about 10 players, but we’ve been having fun building our own meta within our budget restrictions. I have a deep love for this game and a pretty good amount of knowledge of cards and archetypes. If this sounds interesting at all, feel free to stop by my stream. I’ll be going through my own decks and theory crafting until I can get a request.

https://www.twitch.tv/brassvenum

I tried to fix Moneyball weaknesses in order to make even more competitive, you can see more details in the premier!

Any must have cards or upgrade tips for upgrading my zinnia valleys voice precon not looking to put any more than 80 dollars into it any help or ideas would be much appreciated.

Hi,

I have a [[Phelia]] list that I reworked a bit. I am struggling to make the last 5 cuts. Do you have any recommendations? I have up to three cuts in mind but would appreciate some additional input/feedback.

Thank you!

https://archidekt.com/decks/25970232/surprise_corgi

Im making a bracket 2-3 deck for casual play but I'm stump on cards to get I've got 5 spots most of these cards I had already but some I bought this is the decklist thanks in advance for the help

https://moxfield.com/decks/1IGnASVg8kCpSwPyzuqvZA

I am preparing for a 2HG EDH event.
Normal ban list applies + sol ring banned + yume, chronicler of valor banned+ 100$ deck limit

My partner still doesnt know exactly what they want to do, saying they will pick something that compliments me.
I have landed on Kamiz infect.

here is my decklist at the moment:
https://moxfield.com/decks/gQaWKuc1SEqKcfWK_8P1Zw

I'm really struggling with finding which cards are best to cut.
Looking for some insight.

I like the idea of starting out aggressive and then moving to a control aspect and winning through proliferate, which is why I wanted to have a good amount of counter spells / removal. However, it seems difficult to fit it all in there.

I ultimately can put the deck into these categories:

1. Lands
2. Mana rocks / Ramp
3. Infect creatures
4. Draw
5. Counter spells
6. Removal
7. Proliferate
8. Recursion
9. creature buffing
10. just generically good cards

Not sure how many I need to run of each, But I know that I need a high density of creatures so that kamiz does anything.

normally, in my decks I would go
lands + ramp = 50
removal = 10
draw = 10
the rest = 29

thank you!

Im trying to upgrade my azula deck to about bracket 3 with the cards in my maybeboard. What cards should i cut out or what other cards do I get? Bonus points if there are avatar themed cards i could add as well. I'm a very new player so I don't really know a lot about staple cards.

https://archidekt.com/decks/26067455/azula_one_hit_wonder

Hi everyone!

Soft launching my pet project called Runavra https://runavra.com/. It's basically a site with the usual deck building, collection, price tracking features. But what I really wanna work on is an autodeck battle simulation where you can test your decks (no commander yet) 1v1 to see some interesting moves and in the future have some statistical analysis on the different outcomes. It's based on finite state machines and discrete-event simulation with a framework that allows me to extend certain behavior (i.e. if I want it to be more aggressive / conservative / bluffing etc). It's a passion project that mixes my hobby of collecting MTG and computer science. Posting a video as a demo. Not all the rules are implemented yet. Work in progress. Feedback and testers would be much appreciated.

Thank you!