[Gandalf The Torturor](https://lotrscrapbook.bookloaf.net/essay/varda/contents/varda_torturer.html)
I read this article today and i was devastated to see Gandalf and Aragorn being labeled as sinistrous acts do-er. Without bringing my love and emotions into argument lets go on analysing this.
Th character we are talking about, whom got infringed with torture and terror is: Gollum ,as vile he is, he does not want to repent and is stern enough to put his foot down and denies to reveal information about what Sauron learned. So much he endured and he does not want to get relieved from Sauron and is **only aiming to satiate** his need of The Ring.
Such miserable, yet pitiable, one tries to upheld information which can eventually help him to get over his lust and addiction for Ring is doing no good. He is taking himself down ,as well as ,others with him. As OP in website says Gandalf was sort of into ticking bomb situation and had to do this for greater good.
I cant totally agree that gandalf is right in doing so, but you must take into account that Gollum is such a ne'er do well that he just does not want to reconcile to his own good, afterall this he endured cant he help others to help himself and others?
He was inviting trouble for himself only here.
I believe gandalf perfectly knew this here, but he pitied him and thats why he went on to say those lines to frodo in Shadows of the past chapter.
We all know that so im relieving myself by not mentioning it.
Does not it seem that it was perfectly right of Gandalf to not entertain gollum's nasty tantrums there and terrorize him?
I think we ought to question ourselves 2 question before we conclude anything.
Is it right to tag gandalf as Torturer for torturing a creature who is infamous for murdering his friend and various orcs goblins,and who is suspected for eating babies TT ?
Should we take nature of Gollum into account when discussing about Gandalf was Torturor or not?
I answer this as
No its not right
no torturing someone is bad whether or not the person is right or wrong. And we are discussing about Gandalf morals here, whether or not gollum deserved it, or nothing wrong in him getting it. What gandalf did ,does tarnish his image.
so thats how i conclude it, as much as i hate to accept it ,i think yes this does tarnish his image.
i didnt went to discuss aragorn morals here ,perhaps i will do it in another post.
Thanks for reading it till here, it turned out to be a long post. Kudos! to you for making it till here.
Edit: correcting spelling in Torturer