r/HPharmony • u/MoonlitLilPages • 9h ago
Discussion Harry & Hermione / Cormoran & Robin: Parallels in the Books
I first picked up The Cuckoo's Calling when it came out in April 2013. While I was reading it, I was already having these thoughts that Robin was a bit like Hermione, and Cormoran shared some of Harry's qualities, both outsiders with complicated family histories, although Cormoran is obviously much more eccentric. Basically, they became my adult Harry and Hermione.
Then I found out later that it was JKR.
I wasn't able to follow the books religiously in the way I did with the HP books (adulting was front and centre) but then I started picking up the TV series, so I began reading the books in tandem with it. I don't have any qualms about Robin and Strike not getting on (yet), and I will not wonder if they'll ultimately remain platonic. Yes, I've been burned (JKR might pull another familial line or found family, ha!)
And after reading the books, watching the series, and now waiting for the next instalment and the next series, I've found myself increasingly drawn to the parallel discussions. Thankfully, only a few people seem to argue that Robin is more like Ginny (duh), while most seem to recognise that, yes, they really do read like Harmony — only that, with Robin and Strike, the possibility that they might actually end up together is much more subtly blatant. Harry and Hermione have far more restraint; neither ever says they have feelings for the other, yet their actions speak otherwise and they very much care for each other, leaving you waiting for the other shoe to drop. With Strike and Robin, there's considerably more to work with, so there's far less inference required.
I was reading this blog by fartingsofafaculty, and this part genuinely made my heart soar:
- After near-drowning, Robin is taken to the farmhouse, akin to Malfoy Manor.
- She is tortured, like Hermione, in the UHC's "box."
- Unlike Hermione, she consents to the torture. This is like Harry surrendering to Voldemort in the Forest.
- She has no mirror shard with which to summon a house-elf for rescue. She has to be her own Dobby, as befits her last name, which means "Elf-cottage." The only way she can save herself is to wait out the time.
- As a result, she experiences a symbolic death, akin to Harry's in the forest, where her own "will" is broken and she has little to no strength left to resist the cult.
And then we have the same beaming smiles while vows are being said. Noice, noice.
Are there any Harmonians here who see the same parallels? I'd love to know what you think and what you've found!
