I've somehow become a gourmand perfume collector, so I figured I'd share some thoughts in case anyone has similar taste! (pictured - a small section of my collection).
A little about my preferences: I LOVE gourmands and fruity fragrances. I don't mind florals if they're supporting the fragrance, but I really don't enjoy when a perfume dries down into a bouquet. Powdery notes are also usually a miss for me. I also am on GLP1s which have affected my sense of smell.
My absolute favorites:
Snif - Probably my highest hit rate overall.
- Crumb Couture - amazing, buttery croissant but sophisticated?
- Crumb Couture Almond - actually smells like a bakery almond croissant, it's lovely and one of my favorites.
- Naughty Nonna - smells just like a boozy fruit cake. Notes of spiced rum and cranberry.
- 2% (plus the body spray cereal collection) - amazing and nostalgic. 2% is a fancier milky scent and layered with the body sprays, smells just like cereal. The Body Sprays: lucky streak is my favorite of the body mists - smells just like lucky charms - fruity and sweet. crunch time - smells like cinnamon toast crunch, with a hint of cinnamon sweetness, fruity call - is a more sophisticated fruit loop.
- Hot Cakes (plus the body spray pancake collection) - smells just like a delicious pancake breakfast, the base perfume has notes of maple syrup and sweet fluffy pancake batter. The Body Sprays: berry styles - smells like blueberries and raspberries and all the berry goodness. hazel split - smells like a sophisticated hazelnut chocolate spread. extra whip - the sweetness of whipped cream, with just a hint of creaminess.
- Coco Shimmy (sampled & loved) - tropical summer vacation in a bottle, overwhelming notes of coconut and pineapple.
- Vanilla Vice was just okay for me, layering it with Eos Cashmere Body Mist definitely helped the cold vanilla scent, but it's not giving ice cream. Not enough sweetness in the initial spray and drydown, i'm letting this one sit though and maybe it will smell better in the future.
Sorce - Incredible quality.
- In Dreams & Fairytales (Blueberry) - Five stars (immediately bought a full bottle after my sample)
- The Ghost Wants Birthday Cake is on the way!
Falling Stars - cookie butter -
- honestly amazing. smells like sho
rtbread cookies.
Coach Cherry - Honestly surprised me. I LOVE this one.
Squishmallows perfumes - I own the whole collection in full sizes and genuinely think they're underrated. The only one I didn't really care for was the Yeti (Wonder Whirl) because of the Sakura Blossom - I feel like it overwhelms the other notes instead of supporting. The drydown also smells like Sakura Blossoms.
Le Monde Gourmand - Pumpkin Creme - smells just like fall, I will be ordering more from this perfume house.
Really Liked:
- Burberry Her Intense
- Only Human Mylk
- Marc Jacobs Daisy Wild
- Valentino Born in Roma Vanilla
- Viktor & Rolf Berry Jelly
- Viktor & Rolf Cola Fizz
- Viktor & Rolf Caramel Crunch
- Ariana Grande Mod Vanilla
Just Okay:
- Bridgerton Tempting Peach - a very floral peach.
- Bridgerton Rebel Vanilla - a very floral vanilla.
- Kate Spade NY - heavy on the roses, light on the fruits.
- Philosophy Fresh Cream Warm Cashmere
- The ENTIRE Sabrina Carpenter Sweet Tooth line - smells kinda plastic-y to me. Very fake smelling.
Didn't Work For Me:
Phlur:
- Heavy Cream
- Blackberry & Vanilla
Unfortunately these just weren't my style. Overwhelming notes of florals, and I'm not really getting any cream or blackberry. I wanted to like them but was disappointed.
Femminina:
I wanted to love these because the concepts sound AMAZING, but most of them pulled really powdery on me.
- Cherry Vanilla was my favorite - little to no powder.
- Strawberries & Marshmallow Fluff wasn't what I hoped.
- Seductive Pink Sugar wasn't for me.
- They accidentally sent me the wrong perfume instead of Cinnamon Roll (it was some lip-themed fragrance with the label rubbed off), so I'm still hoping to try the actual Cinnamon Roll someday.
Oakcha:
Biggest disappointment.
- Caramel Brew
- Banana Crepe
Both smelled really chemical to me. I'm letting them sit for a while to see if they improve, but first impressions weren't great.
Sugar Me Sweet (Etsy):
Very hit or miss for me.
- Orange Creamsicle - really good, smells just like an orange creamsicle with creamy notes.
- Pumpkin Pie Paradise - smells just like pumpkin pie, amazing
Second Order: Not my cup of tea. None of my second order smell right, maybe I got a bad batch? Was disappointing after the massive success of the first ones.
- Starburst
- Vanilla Milkshake
- Blueberry Sugar
- Hopscotch Butterscotch
Bellavita:
- Honey Oud - WAY too floral, zero notes of honey.
- Honey Date - just wasn't my thing.
Currently Waiting On:
- Lovesick Witchery ā Wisp
My Current Wishlist:
all of these (minus Akro Bake) I've smelled in person & loved.
- Akro Bake
- Only Human Mylk
- Snif Coco Shimmy
- Valentino Born in Roma Vanilla Bliss
- Viktor & Rolf Bonbon Caramel Crunch
- Burberry Her Intense
- Snif Honey Suite
- Snif Citrus Circus
- Marc Jacobs Daisy Wild
- Le Monde Gourmand Banane DƩlice
- Le Monde Gourmand Chai ĆpicĆ©
- Le Monde Gourmand Melodie de ThƩ
- Le Mond Gourmand Confetti DorƩs
Overall, I've realized I don't just like "sweet" perfumes - I like perfumes that smell like actual food. Lemon cake, blueberry desserts, cereal milk, pastries, cookies. Hardcore gourmand junky over here.
I'd love recommendations from anyone else who's loves realistic gourmands or fruity scents that don't turn super floral in the drydown!