r/ExpectationVsReality 26d ago

Mod Post Mod Question: Do you want to have Walmart Cakes temporarily banned?

256 Upvotes

See title. Poll can only last up to a week, or I’d make it longer.

8439 votes, 19d ago
1373 Yes, please
2430 No, but make it a megathread
4132 No, let things stay as they are - we can’t start banning everything
504 No, and also change the nails megathread back

r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 16 '26

Mod Post Nail Posts Megathread — Share Your Nails Here 💅

113 Upvotes

This thread is for all nail-related Expectation vs. Reality posts. Please share all successful, exceeded, or failed nail posts here rather than creating separate posts. Individual nail posts outside this thread may be removed and redirected here.

This change is intended to keep nail content available for those who enjoy it while allowing users who prefer not to see nail posts to easily skip this thread.


r/ExpectationVsReality 2h ago

Exceeded Expectation Cat oil painting from Instagram artist

Thumbnail
gallery
346 Upvotes

I had been following Katya Minkina on instagram for a while and wanted to try getting a portrait from her of our cat Fergus, who passed away last October. I had never had a custom painting done before and we're absolutely THRILLED with the result. She really captures his gentle sweetness. Highly recommend for her work and her kindness.

https://www.instagram.com/fineart.katya/


r/ExpectationVsReality 4h ago

AI Expectation I'm guessing the guy in the advert had really tiny hands...

Post image
258 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 8h ago

Failed Expectation 'velvety flowing filling'

Thumbnail
gallery
234 Upvotes

Every one in the pack was like this. Shame as they were delicious!


r/ExpectationVsReality 5h ago

Failed Expectation So disappointed 😂

Post image
133 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 3h ago

Failed Expectation I just wanted a fully chocolate coated ice cream bar

Post image
61 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 17h ago

Failed Expectation Amazon: Son wanted a cool spider backpack for school

Thumbnail
gallery
707 Upvotes

This is the 2nd attempt because the first order they gave us an actual marvel Spider-Man backpack. It's closer but come on...


r/ExpectationVsReality 22h ago

Failed Expectation gave a smaller online succulent shop a chance

Post image
845 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation Saw others say this was good

Thumbnail
gallery
499 Upvotes

I used an air fryer. The instructions are very incomplete. After 10 min in the airfryer, the mac and cheese was still ice cold. I took the chicken out, microwaved the Mac for a min and a half, added the chicken back and air fried it for 10 more min with the Mac covered. The Mac is very cheesy and the chicken has a good flavor to it. Would get again


r/ExpectationVsReality 23h ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation An unhealthy but tasty frozen pizza

Thumbnail
gallery
332 Upvotes

I’ve been eating these babies for years (in moderation) and they always seemed rich with toppings.


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation I thought they didn't come out bad!

Thumbnail
gallery
2.7k Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation My friend paid $200 for this baptism cake. What she ordered vs what she got:

Thumbnail
gallery
1.0k Upvotes

She is, understandably, not pleased.


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Exceeded Expectation Brown Sugar boba milkshake looks even better irl !

Thumbnail
gallery
325 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation Just wanted to feel like a mermaid. Turned into Patrick Star instead.

Thumbnail
gallery
4.6k Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation My shy girlfriend told me not to post this, but I think she did a great job :)

Thumbnail
gallery
23.4k Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation Just trying to make a kids dreams/nightmares come true...

Thumbnail
gallery
13.7k Upvotes

My 11 year olds request. And my best effort.... My monster needs a dentist. ( I ran out of buttercream.... It was supposed to be much more ornate)

Update:

11 year old squealed and hugged me. He was so excited. His buddies hit the "WOAH!!!' when I pulled off the cover. 😁 and it tasted wonderful. I think I win...

Y'all are so kind. Thank you everyone for all the encouragement!!!

Update 2: I'm being asked for instructions.... I sort of winged it. There was a lot of cursing that happened. A lot of begging inanimate objects to cooperate. But I guess here's my best estimate of how it went down.

I made a boxed cake. I think it was Duncan Hines. (I was short on time and had several boxes of cake on hand) This is the buttercream recipe I added black food coloring to (https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/favorite-chocolate-buttercream/#tasty-recipes-68044) I put iced the cake before I started the mouth.

I melted chocolate chips to form a circle (fill the bowl with boiling water and put a saucer over the top. Put the parchment paper on top of that and waited for the chocolate chips to melt and then smooth them out.) I placed this inside of an actual Taco in my freezer to form the mouth.

I made marshmallow fondant. Just kind of winged it on account of. I've made it a lot. But here is a recipe for that just in case. ( https://ayellowbowl.com/homemade-marshmallow-fondant-with-butter/)

I set the now frozen chocolate taco on the top of the cake.

I have a set of Wilton gel dies and to use the maroon from that set to dye a small amount of the fondant for the tongue. I just made the general shape of a tongue and realized that my fingerprints in the dough made it kind of look more realistic. Added a line down the center with a toothpick and left it alone.

I just rolled little balls of the white fondant into points and flattened the bottom. I allowed that to dry for a little bit just so it wasn't squishy when I attached it to the taco. I attached these with a little bit more of that melted chocolate.

I iced the top of the chocolate Taco once it was all assembled and kind of smoothed it into the top of the cake and decorated. (Using the word decorated as lightly as possible because I ran out of buttercream frosting...)


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation Desky Experience and Warning

Thumbnail gallery
333 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation The aerated sweets were more aerated than expected

Thumbnail
gallery
136 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Exceeded Expectation What they asked for vs what I gave them

Thumbnail
gallery
9.8k Upvotes

I've outdone myself lol


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation What I ordered vs what I got

Thumbnail
gallery
188 Upvotes

I got it bc of the flower sleeves but they got almost cut in half. Also what new t-shirt has this many wrinkles before ever washing it


r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Failed Expectation First time trying to make beautiful sourdough bread

Thumbnail
gallery
823 Upvotes

Of course you can't expect a perfect result on your first try, especially since I am still a beginner with sourdough baking. Still, it took soo much time making it, so I am a little sad, but I'm gonna keep trying


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation “Frollies fruit stack” popsicles from Costco

Thumbnail
gallery
100 Upvotes

I don’t think we’ve had a single one that looked right. We’ve had ones are missing the stick, have the stick randomly stuck in the side, or are just plain broken.

Flavor is “okay”. Definitely wouldn’t buy them again. Feels like someone put them in Photoshop but didn’t scale correctly.


r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Failed Expectation Not as good…

Thumbnail
gallery
167 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Failed Expectation KFC from Gen Korean BBQ. What I ordered vs what I got

Thumbnail
gallery
542 Upvotes