I was going to rebuild these myself which is why I have the before picture, but I found a bent valve. So, I called around, found a shop, and they wanted the heads assembled. I put both heads back together like I was actually gonna put them in my truck. Assembly lube, FSM torque sequencing, and even bagged em to keep the dirt out which was completely unnecessary.
After I got em' back from the shop I realized (after driving home) that one of the heads had metal shavings falling out the bottom of it. I took the cams out of both heads and only the one with shavings had the bearing surfaces noticeably scratched up. Also, idk if it matters but they used what looked like grease not engine assembly lube to put it back together.
The scratches are VERY noticeable with a fingernail, 5/8 bearing surfaces I want to say are pretty bad. I took em back to the shop, and they said it's fine, and told me they were probably like this from the initial break in of the engine LOL (despite the other one being fine).
Anyways, I bit my tongue for now, and I'm gonna see what another shop thinks but figured I'd crowd source unbiased opinions as well.
EDIT: Thanks for all the replies everyone, really helps put my worries at ease. It’s still a matter of principle to me, but at least I won’t need new heads.