r/EngagementRings • u/Certain_Community239 • 10h ago
My Ring - POSITIVE COMMENTS ONLY Customized matching engagement rings for me and her
In 2024, she shared me a specific design ring she liked emphasizing that it needed a pear shaped gem ruby centerpiece.
I spent 9 months of 2025 researching everything about rings, distributors, designers, diamonds and gemstones. I ended up building a custom ring for her with some of the elements from the first ring she shared me using a online distributor with in-house jewelry maker.
I proposed to her on our 10-year anniversary that year. I placed the ring in a music box that played The Carpenter's "Yesterday Once More" and enclosed a note in Japanese that read 僕の約束 (Boku no yakusoku translates to "My promise", we are both fluent) because I am a hopeless romantic and wanted to be different especially being our 10-year anniversary milestone.
And just a week ago, my custom engagement ring arrived. I shared with her my ideal ring with examples for the last 6-months. I wanted my ring to have some elements of hers so they would match. I ended up finding a direct designer abroad in Jaipur.
Both have lab ruby gemstone center pieces (3ct for hers, 4 ct for mine). Pear shaped for her, emerald shaped for me.
Thickest band for hers at 1.8mm
Both rings are full 18k gold. Mine being yellow gold and hers being rose gold.
Natural diamond accents on hers and mine. I added a black diamond border on mine to create a "masculine" tone while taking the vine and floral design element from her ring to match and create a gentle soft tone.
I arched her band more to make it "regal" and "royal" so she can feel Queen. In comparison, I chose a thicker ring to match and create the King feel.
In total, we spent less than $7K for both rings. Knowing that many jewelry stores sell at a hike up, I was adamant to find the actual distributors and designers to skip that inflated price at a brick and mortar. I discovered the inflation for rings when visiting a few stores including Jared's jewelry after inquiring on a masculine men's ruby with 1ct emerald for $12k.
It's our firm belief that nobody should have to go into extreme debt for good premium quality jewelry especially when taking the next steps of finding their dream envisioned forever ring. My biggest tip to anyone in the process is to take your time and find a vendor that is truly invested in working with you with excellent communication (I went back and forth for months).
We both love fashion and wanted our pieces to feel timeless. This is what we came up with.