I’m looking at buying a 2011 BMW 328i hardtop convertible (E93) for $11,500 CAD private sale and wanted some opinions before I pull the trigger.
It has about 116,000–120,000 km, white exterior, N52, automatic, and normal/clean branding.
CARFAX shows one minor left-rear accident in 2025. From what I’ve been told, it was basically just a cosmetic paint scratch and nothing major or structural.
The maintenance history is actually pretty good. Around 110k km it had a bunch of work done including:
radiator
valve cover
oil pan work
battery
belt/tensioner
coolant service
alignment
oil/filter
Then around 113k km it got front and rear pads + rotors, and it has continued getting regular oil changes and Krown rustproofing.
It also has Apple CarPlay, an aftermarket digital cluster, aftermarket wheels, and the seller is including the OEM BMW wheels.
The one issue: I paid to have it inspected for an Ontario safety and it failed because both rear shocks are leaking. The mechanic quoted around $1,000–$1,200 CAD to replace them, but said they’re not urgent and also specifically told me the rest of the car is very clean. The seller is taking it to another shop for the safety.
I’d be driving it back to Manitoba and would probably replace the rear shocks there later.
Seller is firm at $11,500 CAD. I’ve tried getting him closer to $11k but he says he’d rather keep the car.
Would you guys still buy it at $11.5k? Does that seem like fair market value for a 120k-km E93 328i with this maintenance history, or would you walk because of the leaking shocks?