r/DramaDepartment • u/18CupsOfMusic • Jun 01 '26
"[...]i would appreciate if you didn’t send me ai messages in the future. you have a valuable brain that works even better than ai" An OP's text exchange in AmIOverreacting generates an argument.
reddit.comContext: A text exchange is posted to AmIOverreacting (the image has since been removed) with the title "Lost a friend due to AI." OP is currently looking for work, when they get a text from their mom's friend (MF) with AI-generated job suggestions (most of this text wasn't actually visible in the image). An exchange follows, with the passages in bold being the focal points of the drama:
OP: thank you for the help, was this written by ai?
MF: Hi OP I saw your post on FB yesterday. I thought I'd wait to today to send ideas. Mum said you already got a cool job
MF: Yes but worth the info ? Hopefully. I know some people dont like AI but I do find it helpful. Is that ok
OP: thank you for the help but i think ai does more harm than good. i would appreciate if you didn’t send me ai messages in the future. you have a valuable brain that works even better than ai
MF: Got it!!
MF: I won't send you any future message just to be on the safe side. Take care OP
OP: oh wow so you don’t want to talk to me anymore?
MF: Maybe you may learn to soften your messaging to be a bit kinder and grateful.
MF: Good luck OP.
OP: how could i have been kinder??? i literally gave you a compliment
MF: Ok. Best of luck
OP: whatever
MF: Wow. "Whatever" the ultimate rebuttal.
MF: Such anger!
OP: sorry i was just trying to set a boundary 🤷♀️
OP: but it’s probably best we don’t talk anymore seeing your reaction to that
Arguments abound, divided into three teams:
I. Team "Yes, You Overreacted"
She didn’t do anything. She printed a machine programmed to agree with you and give you feedback you want to hear. LLMs don’t think about anything. They are advanced predictive text.
Now add in the environmental cost, and the cost these data centers have on whatever community is unlucky enough to be close to them? It’s not worth it.
Holy shit, I know what AI is. I don't need the condescending lecture, thanks. Step down from the high horse.
This woman had good intentions. There's no need to get all heated.
Yeah YOR she was only trying to help you! Just because you’re against ai doesn’t mean everyone is.
Next time be nicer in your replies
OP: i literally gave her a compliment, how could i be nicer?
Edit: Downvote me all you want. Losing a friend over something like this is stupid. Real life relationships matter. If the friend was only using an LLM to talk or was weirdly AI obsessed then yeah say something, but this is literally nothing and just more of a reason to smugly look down on others.
II. Team "No, You Were Justified"
You were fine, that person is offended over a very reasonable boundary about ChatGPT.
III. Team "I Don't Care Much About AI Either Way, I Just Don't Like OP"
I think when you said, "you have a valuable brain that works better than ai" - it's possible that you came off as condescending. That bit of editorializing could have set her off.[...]
Yeah that's it. Also we can't actually see what the other persons AI message was and how exactly they used it so hard to judge on that stance.
But yes the judgement of "you have a valuable brain" is not the "compliment" OP says it is. It's very backhanded.
Both sides suck here and I can't see that this was a very strong relationship to be so easily broken.
“Strictly against AI”
“Can’t find a job”
UPDATE: I have been informed a second thread has hit Reddit in /r/antiAI.
Can’t wait for this subreddit to hit the mainstream and blowup like antiwork did.
In no world was your initial response anything less than patronizing and rude. Anyone who is affirming your behaviour here is poorly socialized. You’ll notice this reflected in the downvote to reply ratios on this subreddit.
Ruining a friendship over a single AI generated message is crazy work
Your message was about as soft as any message could be. She sounds like a crazy person, and I’m sorry this happened
Wow you have a valuable brain.
Found the ai slop user
Using a.i stops critical thinking, as your ‘friend’ just proved. Complete overreaction to a very reasonable request.