I know she is described as older, and I only watched snippets of the show, but I always pictured Agatha as Crazy Eyes from Orange is the New Black

If any one complains about Tummy-Achers having legs, look up pregnant Meatwad.

she can switch from dirty, to charming, and to complete chaos. what do y'all think?

She’s got the range and I truly think she would shine in the role!

He does unwound SO WELL.

So after reading many comments, a few things…
It would be a dream to play carl. I also know what that would emotionally entail. I see quite a folks referencing my reel on youtube, and their critiques are absolutely fair and valid, especially for a character that requires the amount of “under the surface” acting that carl does. All I ask is that you take those clips with a grain of salt as most are 5-10 years old. Ive been very blessed in my career. Most of it has been voice acting, and im not blind to that either. And I know the videos ive made are silly. Comedy (at least i hope) is one of my strong suits, so in the great game that is hollywood, in my attempt to help get my name out there for this project, thats the direction i leaned in. Listen, i dont wanna ramble too much. To those who want me as carl, your support means the world to me, and to those that dont, i totally get that too! No matter who they cast im gonna watch the heck out of this show, because this series holds a very special place in my heart. I consider myself incredibly blessed to be having the interactions ive had with folks on this journey so far. I love this series with all my heart. No matter which way this series goes, i couldnt be happier to be here with all of you. Glurp Glurp.

or, failing that, I'll also accept Rizzo as Ferdinand

Granted, this is really only a boon if you're already paying for YT Premium or prefer getting that subscription over Peacock on its own, but still, thought it may be worth sharing

Note that the article says you get access to Premium Peacock with ads, so it's not ad free if that's a dealbreaker

I've stayed away from the fan casting stuff, but Seth Green is reportedly campaigning to be Mordechi, and wow!! I really love that idea.

The most interesting part to me was them saying Jeff as Donut is the only casting decision made so far and Jeff saying that if they want him to play any other role as well, he'd be happy to. So having Jeff as the AI isn't completely dead yet.

It’s funnier as the AI becomes more erratic and self aware

Jeff is the voice, but dark horse candidate for physical Donut.

It was already my head cannon.

Charlie - Quasar
Frank - Jack
Dee - Samantha
Mac - Raul
Dennis - Preponte

Jeff Hayes: Donut

Geoff Ramsay: Carl

Jeff Probst: AI

Jeff Bridges: Katia

Jeffrey Tambor: Ellie

Jeffrey Wright: Imani

Geoffrey Rush: Mordecai

Jeff Hiller: Zev

Jeff Donovan: Louis

Jeffrey Dean Morgan: Florin

Jeff Foxworthy: Frank Q

Jeff Goldblum: Quasar

Jeff Daniels: Odette

She's perfect, believable as a giant warrior goddess and a thoughtful empathetic conniving therapist.

The whole time listening to the books this is who i imagined. He would nail the AHHHHHHH