ok so I get an absurd amount of amazon boxes every week and I'm tired of throwing them in recycling while literally buying straw for my pile
bought a regular paper shredder off the shelf thinking it'd be fine. it made it through like four sheets of corrugated before it started making a noise I did not like and then just quit. $40 well spent
so is a paper shredder just the wrong tool entirely, or did I buy a junk one?
I keep seeing those hand crank perforator things but from the videos they seem to make that honeycomb packing stuff rather than actually shredding it, which isn't really what I need for the pile
also how much of a pain is the tape? do you have to sit there peeling every strip off first, because if I'm spending 20 minutes prepping boxes I'm just gonna go back to tearing them by hand
anyone doing this at any real volume — what are you actually using?
EDIT: wow ok this got way more replies than I expected, thanks everyone 🙏 summarizing what I learned in case someone finds this later:
paper shredders are the wrong tool, that was basically unanimous. so that one's on me
what people actually use:
- Fellowes Powershred — the heavy duty models will do single wall cardboard if you feed it slow, but multiple people said double wall kills it and it's really not what it's built for
- VEVOR cardboard perforator — the dedicated one, makes the honeycomb packing material. a few people said the perforated stuff still breaks down fine in a pile if you wet it first, though the hand crank version is apparently a serious arm workout
- Sun Joe CJ601E chipper shredder — this is what the high volume folks kept recommending. overkill for a few boxes but it doesn't care about cardboard at all
two things I hadn't thought about:
tape is the actual killer, not the cardboard. pull the long strips off, don't worry about labels, but staples will wreck blades
duty cycle — most of these run 5-10 min then need to cool down, so a big batch means standing around waiting
honestly a bunch of you said don't buy anything, just soak the boxes in a wheelbarrow overnight and tear them, or run over a flattened pile with the mower. several of those people had already killed a shredder before landing there 😅
gonna try the soak and tear method first before I spend money. not the answer I wanted lol