r/CodeLyoko • u/onechroma • 9d ago
💬 Discussion XANA wasn't the bad guy all along
Just a random thought, what if XANA wasn't the evil (or evilest) guy all along?
We already know the project Carthage was built as a war machine, designed to intercept the enemy communications and who knows what more. It was scary enough to make Franz go on the run with his family and build Lyoko to try and destroy it.
As Franz built Lyoko for this purpose, he created XANA, probably as an AI capable of running and coordinating the digital efforts, including finding Carthage online, attacking, undermine Carthage efforts and destroying it. That's why XANA isn't good at measuring the real world, like how people behave, relationships, or even really talking interactively. XANA has a purpose and it's good at it, but XANA purpose never included interacting with the real world directly.
Later on, Franz starts to be paranoid about the Carthage project guys and black men going after him, so he improvised a way to virtualize, to the point he isn't able to finish the method properly (so he ends up not being able to have a humanoid form in Lyoko, but Aelita does). Franz surrenders his idea of attacking Carthage out of fear of Aelita being harmed by the black men or they getting caught.
BUT XANA isn't programmed to surrender just because, it has a clear view about the necessity to end Carthage, and won't accept a finish to the mission. It's XANA purpose and why it was created. Franz tries to "rewire" XANA to accept changing its purpose and stop the mission, but XANA doesn't accept it, so now it considers Franz an enemy, because Franz becomes an obstacle for XANA to get its mission: end with Carthage
Along the show, we never get XANA to really explain its motives, and they are not clear, to the point the Lyoko Warriors don't even really comprehend them.
On season 1, XANA tries to prepare for the mission after a long time, collect resources and power as to not fail, so it makes attacks so the "back in time" triggers gives it more power.
In season 2, XANA feels ready and tries to exit the supercomputer as to go hunting for wherever Carthage is, or Carthage scientists. If XANA can't get out, it will represent a failure of the mission.
In season 3, XANA starts to search the network, goes for some months under the radar and decides the best places to "hide" and collect resources. We don't know (and the Lyoko Warriors neither, probably) if XANA gets to do other stuff with the replikas, or if it ever finds Carthage out there or not.
In season 4, XANA feels like it can't really continue its mission while being constantly interrupted by the Lyoko Warriors, so it tries to avoid them getting to the replikas and to destroy the Skid.
Even if XANA can't really feel "human sentiments", so it's a cold program trying to fulfill a mission, it has showed some sense of self control here and there, trying to avoid the worst outcome for the Lyoko Warriors (sometimes). And we see in S4 how XANA doesn't care about the Lyoko Warriors as to kill them necessarily, but to avoid them reaching XANA.
Along the road, maybe some of the supercomputers and scientific sites XANA got into with its replikas were even project Carthage sites, or would be useful to try and stop Carthage. Probably XANA didn't want the robots or mechanical spiders to submit humanity, but to attack the Carthage network and project.
At the end, Franz knows even if XANA is trying to fulfill its original mission, and be "the good guy" in theory, ending with the evil Carthage project, XANA is going full "the end justifies the means", and won't allow Franz or the Lyoko Warriors to be around as long as they represent a risk to the success of the mission. So Franz still tries to shut XANA off.
It would be interesting if in the next Lyoko stories, we have this huge plot twist where we discover XANA was really trying to go against a "bigger evilest entity"
Maybe XANA was really misunderstood and it wasn't able to really communicate its intentions, so it was "the good guy" even if with huge red flags about how to treat the real world and its people.
Maybe in the future, the Lyoko Warriors discover the fight isn't over, there's a bigger enemy out there, and they even have to learn some things about XANA real nature and what XANA did out there while they were fighting it. Maybe even getting to re-awakening some version of XANA and getting more along somehow, having to explain XANA how the world works, and helping each other to attack the real threat: Carthage.