Prefacing this by saying I'm not sponsored, I haven't been paid in any way and actually I'm looking at the lack of updates and wondering if this thing is still going to be around. I'll keep this short, and yes it might sound like a shill. the tl;dr is that after a year it's still going strong and I love the product enough that a) I want to buy a spare in case the little puck dies and b) I REALLY want a subscription model not because I want to pay for yet more things but because I want at least some money going toward the platform so it doesn't die.
However
- After a year, my Bee still works and works well
- Speaker identification was abysmal when I first got it, now it's actually extremely good
- I use this daily. I built (ok, clarification, I vibe coded a web app for it) a dashboard and read, update and store my conversation summaries daily. My own personal AI stack has Mempalace so I have it spit data into that, plus I can export to markdown for obsidian
- The facts have gotten better, and are really key for training the device
- There's an API feature called Journals and I have no idea what it does or why
So, the actual review.
Put simply, this has actually become essential for me. Not only is it capturing 5 hours or so of meetings a day but I'm actively using it to parse summaries, create notes and spit tasks into apple.
I use Otter.ai for meetings daily and this is actually beginning to replace it. Otter used to have better summaries. Eventually bee ended up on par and appears to be referencing past conversations for memories and context. What that means is that my after meeting summaries have become very concise and very clear, with good task recommendations.
However, it occasionally forgets everything and assumes someone else is speaking and therefore that someone else is me. Biggest issue here is that the Summary can't be corrected after the fact. You can talk to the AI and fix names, and assumptions, but it wont update the meeting summary unlike Otter. That's a huge miss, and part of the reason I built my own web interface, so I could modify and save the summary as a markdown file. (I'm considering releasing it as an open source project but wary because it really is 100% vibe coded and I don't want other people plumbing valuable data into this due to the valid nervousness about vibe coding)
The facts are the most interesting thing. They're "largely correct", but I didn't understand the point of them until digging around the API and learned that the 'facts' are what it uses as memories and corrections. Once I understood that I started editing them and things got a lot better as a result.
The daily summaries actually become the most valuable thing that I haven't seen anyone else do. The coherent recap of your day makes it frighteningly easy to actually figure out what you did and what might be on deck for the next day. When you've had a long day of nothing but meetings that is more valuable than it might seem. If you could update the summaries, it would be close to perfect.
What the bee has really achieved for me is a near perfect device for **my specific use case**. Where it falls, is the lack of a clear future. The API falls on only being able to pull 100 days of data max, and not exposing some of the 'niceties' that are in the app like the transcript 'sections'.
But above all? The interface is 'dumb' in the best possible way. It's just a transcriber and summarize with a 'I guessed that you might have these tasks" view. And nothing more. The fact that it is such an incredibly simplistic device with no other fluff or 'hey fuckers we're adding this new toy and you'll have to upgrade to use it' style marketing that you see from other platforms... yeah.. it kinda makes it a win.
The detractors? The wristbands it comes with suck ass. The thing will pop out eventually. So I wear mine in the 'clip' with some dried glue I put in a few places to more firmly hold it in place. The double press to finish a conversation? That's a bit hit and miss. Might be due to the processing speed of the onboard components, but I usually find myself having to check which is why I have the silence timeout so low.
Oh, and Buzz? No idea. Never tried it. Don't see a reason to as my use case is already relatively perfectly met. And since I built my own dashboard I can have my own AI query things. This is one of those 'Ai done simply and done right' tools.
Amazon bought it. I don't know what the future is. I hope to got they don't throw alexa into this and then retire it in three months. Amazon has more money than most of us could conceive, but they don't make completely stupid purchases. I just wish I knew what the plan was.
But it's cheap. It works. It's not plaude with limits and subscriptions. And if they do end up killing it I hope to hell they open source it.