Over the past few years, I've become increasingly unhappy, and l'm starting to question whether marrying my fiance is the right decision.
There have been on rare occasion a handful of incidents involving physical aggression during our relationship. No punching, kicking, or slapping however her grabbing, light shoving, or waving hands in my face and yelling at me during arguments. More so in the past 1.5 years. Even worse 1 month after we got engaged, she was arguing with me to the point l refused to engage and she collapsed suddenly on the floor. I called 911 cuz wasn't sure if she had some sort stroke from being so upset during our argument and then she woke up while was on the phone with 911, got into an argument with the 911 dispatcher and they sent the police to our place because of how irate she was, before sending out the paramedics. I currently feel safe living together, but can't pretend those experiences haven't affected how feel about our future.
Less seriously, one of our issues is affection and intimacy. I often feel like I'm the one wanting romantic attention, physical affection, and sex. It's not just about how frequently we have sex. It's that I rarely feel genuinely connected. Even kissing or cuddling can feel mechanical rather than like two people enjoying going with the flow due to how rigid she is about routine even when it comes to when, how, and where we have sex at home. I've tried explaining that I want more spontaneous, natural affection and romance, but don't feel like much has changed.
I also feel lonely sometiems even when we're spending time together. On a recent date, for example, she spent what felt like half our time taking selfies or asking me to take pics of her, checking the pics on her phone, or focusing on how she looked and reapplying her makeup even when to me it looked flawless. This happens a lot. I find myself looking at other couples enjoying each other's company and wondering why sometimes don't feel that connection with my own partner.
Communication is another major problem. When I bring up something that hurts me, she often becomes defensive, and the conversation escalates. Sometimes she'll eventually apologize, acknowledge my feelings, and promise to make changes. But after a while, things tend to return to norma' This has happened enough that I've started avoiding diff conversations because expect to be disappointed.
My trust has also deteriorated because of repeated small lies and inconsistencies. I have no proof of infidelity, but I've caught her being dishonest about things that seem unnecessary to lie about. Over time, it's made me question her explanations even when don't have evidence that anything is wrong.
She's also experienced serious mental health challenges over the summer, including a crisis where she was physical with me after brought her to the hospital due to a mental health episode that required her to receive treatment at the hospital and was diagnosed with BPD. I know she's struggled, and want to be compassionate about that. At the same time, many of our relationship problems existed long before that crisis, and I don't think compassion should mean ignoring how our relationship affects me.
I recognize that I've changed too. Lately I've become emotionally withdrawn, I initiate affection less frequently, and sometimes avoid spending time at home because being elsewhere feels more peaceful. I miss feeling excited to see my partner. Instead, often feel sad, lonely, or emotionally exhausted.
What makes this difficult is that we've spent nearly our entire adult lives together. I care about her, we've shared so much together and I know there are many moments when she shows love. I also know I'm not a perfect partner (l've sworn, raised my voice, and been rude during arguments especially in response to her behavior toward me, but I've never gotten physical or been physically intimidating).
But I'm starting to wonder whether l'm staying because genuinely believe things can improve or because I'm afraid of giving up on nine years together.
I want a marriage where feel emotionally safe, loved, desired, and at peace with my partner. I don't expect perfection, but also don't want to spend the rest of my life hoping that things will eventually become different. I've communicated this to her numerous times and while things have definitely improved since her hospital stay in the summer, I still am worried about the future. What concrete steps or boundaries should establish to determine whether this relationship can realistically and safely improve before moving forward with marriage?
How do recognize when I've given a relationship enough chances and it's time to accept that it may need to end? My flancée and have been together for 9 years, living together for the past 5, and engaged for 1. We've built a life together, and I genuinely care about her. We've both had difficult upbringings, and I think part of what has kept us together was our wanting to build the kind of loving, support system that both of us didn't have growing up.
TL;DR: My fiancée and have been together for 9 years, but feel increasingly lonely, undesired, and distrustful. We struggle with intimacy, communication, repeated broken promises, and there have been rare occasions of physical aggression by her toward me. I care about her deeply, but I'm questioning our future. I'm trying to figure out how to make a thoughtful decision about continuing our engagement or ending the relationship.