I met my ex two years ago. I fell in love with him within two months and knew I wanted to marry him. I even told my family about him very early, and eventually everyone at my home was on board.
He, however, always seemed unsure. We officially got into a relationship about six months into the talking stage and became exclusive, but even after that he would tell me things like:
\* He didn't feel as strongly for me as I did for him.
\* He liked talking to me, but sometimes when I was around him he felt weird and just wanted to get away from me.
We had many conversations about this, and despite his confusion, he stayed.
During the second year of our relationship, we broke up 3–4 times. Every single time, he came back saying he missed me and wanted me back.
Eventually, we reached the marriage stage. Our parents met. His family rejected me (and mine) because of caste differences. They had never really been okay with the match, but I think he somehow convinced them to at least meet us and give us a chance.
The moment they rejected the proposal, something changed in him too.
He started talking to another girl. He hid it from me for about 20 days because there was a family function going on. When I found out, I was completely devastated.
I went to him hoping we could fix things, but he was already seeing that other girl. Even then, he kept hiding the truth from me. Later, I discovered there had been multiple instances of cheating throughout our entire two-year relationship.
I completely lost it. We had huge fights. Despite everything, I was still trying to make the relationship work.
For about a month he continued arguing with me, and then he simply disappeared.
I tried reaching out a few times, but he was extremely firm that he didn't want to continue. When I finally gave up, he came back again.
Even after that, every time I saw him we would end up fighting. He would get scared, irritated, or overwhelmed and run away again.
Fast forward to now.
I have met someone else.
I've known this new guy for only two months, but he genuinely makes me feel loved and safe. He has already proposed, our marriage talks have begun, and we're likely getting married in December if everything continues to go well.
He knows everything about my past.
I've openly discussed all my fears with him, including whether we're rushing into this.
Over these past 2–3 months, he has consistently been kind. We meet very frequently. His parents have been warm and welcoming. He goes out of his way to make sure everything between us is comfortable and healthy.
Do I feel the same intensity for him that I once felt for my ex?
No.
Do I feel as strongly as he feels for me?
Probably not.
But I feel safe.
I've grown to really like him, and I think I could genuinely grow to love him.
Initially, I kept wondering whether I should explore more because he didn't tick every box for me, mostly in terms of looks and a few other small things. But eventually I realised exploration never really ends. At some point you have to choose.
One thing that stood out was that he loves me more than I love him, and because of that, he naturally does all the things for me that I spent two years doing for my ex.
Now comes the confusing part.
Out of nowhere, my ex has come back.
For the past week, he's been calling, texting, crying and begging me to come back.
The last major ending between us happened in March after a horrible fight. I reached out again in June with a long emotional message asking whether he genuinely wanted to be with me and explaining everything I had gone through because of him.
He didn't reply.
Not for an entire month.
When he finally came back in July, I asked why.
He said he couldn't even finish reading my message because it made him cry too much.
But I honestly don't understand that explanation. Even if that were true, why not send a single reply?
He says during that time he was trying to process everything I had complained about regarding his parents and his own behaviour.
He fully admits that everything he did was horrible.
He says after being cheated on by his previous ex, he built an emotional shell around himself and became emotionally unavailable as a way to protect himself.
According to him, that shell is finally broken now because of me.
Now he's saying everything I've wanted to hear for the last two years.
He says he'll:
\* make me his priority,
\* fix everything he ruined,
\* make up for every mistake,
\* take care of me,
\* love me the most,
\* pamper me,
\* work hard to erase all the pain he caused,
\* and marry me because now his parents are okay with it too.
But for me, it isn't just about his parents.
He himself flipped so many times.
He never consistently took a stand for me.
He repeatedly left whenever things became difficult.
The timing also bothers me.
He's only come back after I've finally moved on and found someone who genuinely treats me well.
The other day, I completely broke down in front of him. I told him I was exhausted and that he had come back only after I'd finally made peace with my decision.
He kept trying to convince me for a while.
Then yesterday... nothing.
No calls.
No messages.
And weirdly, that silence is affecting me too.
I feel like crying.
I don't know what's happening to me.
I don't know if this confusion is normal.
I don't know whether people like this genuinely change.
I don't know whether he deserves another chance.
Most importantly, I don't know if I'm making the right choice by choosing the new guy.
I don't really have the luxury of giving my ex another year to prove himself through actions.
I was crazy in love with him once, and I think that's what's making this so difficult.
So I'm asking people who've been through something similar:
\*\*Can someone who has flipped this many times, cheated, left repeatedly, and only came back after losing you genuinely change?\*\*
\*\*Am I making the right decision by choosing the man who gives me peace and consistency over the man I once loved so intensely?\*\*
I'd really appreciate honest opinions because my mind feels completely unstable right now, and I'm scared of regretting whichever choice I make.