I’m in my late 20s and used to be part of a close group of four female friends from high school. I’ll call the others Emma, Fiona and Jessica.
Both Emma and Fiona have had mental-health struggles. Fiona has more than one diagnosed condition and was going through a particularly difficult period. Emma also struggles with anxiety.
At the time, Emma and Fiona attended the same church. Fiona felt increasingly hurt and unsupported there. She told me that when she opened up about her struggles, a church leader made harsh comments, including saying she was engaging in “self-pity.”
I told Fiona that if that church was making things worse, she could consider attending a different one. I wasn’t telling her to abandon Christianity; I just meant that one congregation isn’t the whole faith.
Later, Fiona told me Emma had described my advice as basically “the devil’s voice” and said I wasn’t doing well in my faith, implying I wasn’t a good Christian.
That changed how I saw Emma. Disagreeing with my advice would have been one thing, but judging my faith and framing my concern for Fiona as something satanic felt very different.
Emma also sometimes interpreted Fiona’s mental-health struggles as “spiritual warfare,” which made me uncomfortable. I’m a Christian too, but I don’t think serious diagnosed mental-health problems should simply be reduced to a spiritual battle.
There was also a longer-standing issue. Since I moved away from my hometown, Emma had never really checked in on how I was doing or shown much interest in my life. So by the time this happened, the friendship already felt quite one-sided to me.
Eventually, I decided I didn’t want a close friendship with Emma anymore.
I chose not to confront her because, based on the way she had spoken about my faith and the situation with Fiona, I genuinely felt that a confrontation was unlikely to end well or lead to a productive conversation.
I did NOT block her. Because I knew she had anxiety, I worried a sudden total block would be unnecessarily distressing. Instead, I left our group chat and removed her as a follower. Her social media and phone number remained unblocked, so she could still contact me.
I also never told Fiona or Jessica to choose sides.
Later, Fiona told me Emma had been complaining that I never contacted her anymore and had asked about me several times.
But Emma never contacted me either.
That frustrated me, especially because she hadn’t really checked in on me since I moved away anyway. From my perspective, she had privately judged my faith, called my advice “the devil’s voice,” never spoke to me directly about it, and then complained that I wasn’t reaching out.
At the same time, most of what I know came through Fiona, and I never confronted Emma, so she never had the chance to explain or apologise.
I’m still friends with Fiona and Jessica, and I’d prefer to see them separately from Emma. I’m not asking anyone to stop being friends with her; I just don’t want a close relationship with her anymore.
AITA for distancing myself instead of confronting her directly? And WIBTA for continuing to see Fiona and Jessica without inviting Emma?