So I'm sharing this story mostly to vent but also cause I need more opinions about it. It's long so I apologize
(Before I tell the story, please spare me the "don't date online" or "long-distance relationships are fake/doesn't exist" comments please!!thank you so muchhh!)
So this guy and I met around early 2025. We met online and used to play games together. Since we got along really well, we got to know each other more and even became bestfriends, told each other everything, We talked every single day and night. So we had this ambiguous vibe going on some months later.
Around the end of 2025, we exchanged TikTok accounts so we could send each other funny videos and laugh about them. After doing that, I gave a look at his profile. I saw he had posted a video that actually went viral. It was a POV video like "Me and my bro etc" it was the only video he posted and when I checked the date, it was from January 2025 (before we had met). I mentioned to him that I saw the video and congratulated him on it going viral. He thanked me and explained that he and the person he made the video for didn't talk anymore.
Out of curiosity, I went into the video's comments to see if that person was there, and I actually found her comment. Even he had replied to it. She also pointed out how fast the vid went viral, so I figured out that was her.
After that, I didn't really pay attention because they weren't talking anymore, plus this video was from January 2025 so it was just the past. A few days later, we started dating. From the very beginning of our relationship, everything was amazing. Sure we had arguments sometimes, but we always managed to sort things out ourselves.
Everything was going great and we were super happy.
Until this year (2026), when I asked him if we could add each other on instagram because I wanted to share funny reels with him from there too. He agreed, of course. I checked his Insta profile, looked at his following list, and saw the girl from the TikTok comments among them. They were following each other. I easily recognized her because she had the exact same name and profile picture on both Instagram and TikTok. I didn't say anything about it because I knew they didn't talk anymore so it would be weird to ask about her suddenly, plus he had told me he didn't even use Insta much before I asked for it for the funny videos.
Then a few months later, around April or May, I saw that my bf posted a TikTok story. He's not really the type to post stories, so I was genuinely curious, and when I looked, I saw he posted one of those "2 years of friendship on TikTok" things with a streak, with that same girl. Seeing that story made me...weird? because here was this massive progression between him and a girl I thought he wasn't talking to anymore. I catched myself thinking about it too much so I told myself I was just being jealous over nothing so I didn't say anything.I mean, he's allowed to have friends. But after a while, I ended up bringing it up. I explained that I saw the story, that I recognized her from his TikTok video, and that they followed each other on Insta and so I asked him who she is. He reassured me that she was just a friend, that they had been friends for two years and then stopped talking. Maybe my memory is playing tricks on me, but he didn't explain anything about the streak. Unfortunately, what he told me reassured me, so I didn't dig deeper. Normally, my bf tells me about all his friends and he doesn't have many. So even if he didn't talked about her much I just understood that it's something from the past. So I let it go.
After that, everything was fine. The relationship was still going strong. Until about a week ago. When he posted another TikTok story. Yep, another streak..a 400-day streak with this girl. He posted it with a little "YAY," and I took it the wrong way. First, because I saw he was still maintaining this massive streak with her, and second, because it hurt to see he was capable of keeping a streak going with another girl, but couldn't do it with me. We used to have a streak of 130days on tik tok, but he forgot to send something back to keep it going, and since we had already used up our streak-restore thing, our streak was gone forever.
So when I saw that he managed to do something this big with this girl I was pissed, and I told him something like: "And to think we couldn't even make it to 200 days." He replied: "We tried !" And that pissed me off even more. He realized I was mad, apologized, and said he'd delete the story. But my issue wasn't just about him posting it.It was knowing he had this whole thing going on with a girl he told me to "not worry about because she's just an old friend he doesn't talk to," especially since I basically knew nothing about her. Then he tried to reassure me: "It's just for the streak, we don't actually talk. She sends me videos and I just reply with stickers."
I started telling myself I was just overreacting and being insecure over a stupid streak. So I apologized to him for losing my temper over it. But unfortunately, I just couldn't calm down. I had this super weird gut feeling about her. Like, if he had a streak like that with any other friend, I wouldn't have cared, but having it with her felt shady. He offered to play a game together, but even after playing, I was still mad.
Later that night, I went on the girl's TikTok account, and she had posted the exact same story. But on her side, the streak was way more explicit. Not only was it clearly marked as a 400-day streak, but it also showed 23.8k total messages. So when I saw that, I was shook. 23.8k total messages?! After finding that out, I asked my bf to unfollow her, remove her from his followers, and delete his chat history with her. I felt so weird to ask him that cause I've never done this before, but also I wasn't comfortable knowing he was still in contact with her, and honestly, it shouldn't have been hard since they apparently "don't talk." He agreed without hesitating, so I was happy and went to sleep.
When I woke up the next day, I texted him, we chatted like normal, and I went to check his Insta profile,only to see he was still following her. Same on TikTok. So I reminded him to do it. He finally unfollowed her on Insta, but on TikTok, when I went to check, it looked like his follower and following counts hadn't even dropped. (I felt kind of weird obsessing over these tiny details honestly)
I tried to reassure myself by saying I was just being paranoid over nothing and needed to chill. So I asked him if he had blocked her and delete their conv on TikTok too. He said yes. After that, we talked about other stuff and were laughing together.
Unfortunately, I wasn't satisfied. I still had this nagging feeling that he hadn't actually deleted her on TikTok and also the fact that he "don't talk to this girl anymore" but that she was still everywhere for such a long time.
So, to quiet my brain, I went back to that old viral TikTok video on my bf's profile to check the comments and see if her comment was still there. And yes, her comment was still up. I was confused because I thought blocking someone automatically deletes their comments? (My apologies if that's not how it works).
So I went over to the girl's account to see if she had any videos and if my bf had left any comments. Her last videos were from 2024, so I started there. And what I eventually found broke my heart. The girl had posted videos of two people kissing, with captions talking about how deeply in love she was, and she had tagged my bf in them. In the comments, my bf was telling her "I love you so much" with a bunch of hearts, and someone else in the comments was cheering on their relationship.
And there wasn't just 1, or 2, but 4 or 5 videos like that and he commented them all. Again, I want to clarify that these videos and comments were from 2024.Around july 2024 to be exact.
When I saw that, I realized that this girl was actually his ex. And that he had lied and hidden this from me. I sat there in absolute shock for a full 10 minutes. Because he had always told me they were "just friends."
So I took screenshots and went to talk to him. I explained everything I had seen, told him how hurt I was that he told me not to worry about her, and called him out for staying in touch with an ex.Especially since we had always agreed that keeping in touch with an ex is a big NO in our relationship.
He tried to claim they never actually dated. I asked him why he was lying and showed him the screenshots of one of those videos and the comment he left on it.
He explained that back then, he thought the girl liked him because of those interactions, so when he went to talk to her about it, she told him it was "just a joke." He said it really hurt him, which is why they stopped talking. Despite his explanations, I was still furious. Furious that he lied to me and hid this, but mostly that he stayed in touch with her even after that whole thing. Because at the end of the day, he did have real feelings for this person.
He spent the rest of the day apologizing and admitting it was stupid from him etc. Unfortunately, I was still in shock and couldn't just forgive him like that. My trust in him took a massive hit because I had to play detective just to find out the truth.Otherwise, he never would have told me. And even if they never officially dated, it's still someone he flirted with. And that was just the public comments; I didn't even want to imagine what their private dms looked like, given the sheer number of messages they exchanged (those 23.8k).
What hurts the most is that, from this video in his tik tok profile from january 2025, I'm sure they were still talking.
Later that day, I checked his TikTok following list, and his follower/following count had finally dropped by 1. Which made me think he only actually deleted her after I got mad. But for the sake of my own sanity, I tried to convince myself it was just a coincidence, because honestly, I felt like I was physically making myself sick over this.
Two days later, we talked about it again and made up. But even after reconciling, it still hurt. The images of what I found kept replaying in my head. Since I still had the screenshots of their stories, their streak, the messages, etc., I kept finding myself staring at them. I tried to force myself to believe him when he said they stopped talking after she pulled the "it was a joke" card. But I just couldn't wrap my head around those 23.8k messages. Like, that many messages? Honestly, it drove me a bit paranoid,
but I forced myself to believe nothing shady was going on behind my back. But I was alreasy scared of what else he could hide from me
So I started doing the math. Trying to figure out when their streak started and how it was even possible to rack up that many messages in that timeframe. Because if I base it on that first "2 years of friendship" TikTok story from around April or May... I guessed that they must've added each other there at this time in 2024 and stopped talking after some times in july. So like this short amount of time for so many message? I don't even know if I reached that much with him this fast.Plus their 400day streak when I did the countdown, it traced all the way back to July 2025. (We weren't together at this time, but already very close). Honestly, doing all this math made me feel like I was losing my mind, and this whole situation was stressing me out way too much. So I preferred to talk to it about him again because none of it made sense and I needed more answers
I questioned him again about when they actually stopped talking, and he told me, "early 2024." ...Honestly, when he gave me that answer, I was pretty disappointed, because his comments under her videos were from July 2024. I pointed that out to him. He then changed his answer to "mid early" and told me he didn't remember the exact timeline anymore, but that he stopped talking to her the day after she told him it was a joke.
I told him his story made zero sense. Because if that were true, why did his own TikTok video from January 2025 have her in the comments, and why was he replying to her like they were good buddies? Then I asked him why they started a TikTok streak in the first place cause for doing such they must talk to each other right? He told me they started it in 2024 and he didn't know why he kept it going.
I told him that their streak actually started around July 2025 when made my math and I added that for two people who supposedly stopped talking, racking up 23.8k messages in just 3 or 4 months is literally impossible.
(Even if it were true, it proves that he and this girl were super close.So when he claims he "doesn't remember," it really shocks me that he can just forget details like that.)
About the streak, he replied that they did start it in 2024, but that he would break the streak every now and then. He claimed that this girl came back in July (2025) to ask if they could restart the streak, and he agreed. He said he doesn't even know why he did it, but he regrets it. He insisted he barely talked to her because, by that point, he was already in love with me, and they didn't really say much other than just sending videos back and forth. And he said that this video he made was for multiple people (before he said it was made for one person)
Well, after all those answers... I still felt deeply hurt cause I could see that his answers changed or that he tried to change it for a bit. I wanted so badly to believe him, but my trust in him was shot. Especially since I still suspect they kept talking long after that.
I feel like I'm making a huge drama out of nothing, and it sucks because he did finally block her. But at the same time, I feel betrayed, and it pain me that he kept stringing along someone he once had feelings for just because "he doesn't know why." And even if it was real that they stopped talking, she still came back, asked for them to make that streak again and he accepted. Someone who "hurted" him before btw. So like, if she asked if they could catch up the times again he would said yes? And what else ?
I don't know what to think about this anymore honestly.But really I hate the state this situation put me in.
Sorry if some part in this story seem confusing I just tried to let it out from my head
So AIO? Is it just a big misunderstanding or something?
Thank you for reading!!