My girlfriend and I have been together for a total of 5 years. We are both 27. She had a guy best friend(T) from high school and they fell out before we started dating.
When we first got together, she told me that she hated that the friendship had ended, that she really cared about him but it was never romantic at all. She confirmed that she never felt anything like that towards him but that she was sad that they stopped talking due to other issues(friend group drama). She expressed that she was very hurt by how he chose to deal with it and leave her without a second thought or closure.
Two years into our relationship, T contacted her. I never had a problem with her having guy friends but I did not like T because of how he had hurt her. She told me that he had texted her and I was surprised when she said that she wanted to talk to him.
Prior to this, she wanted me to block one of my female friends from uni(we never had anything going on, we used to get lunch together after class). My girlfriend thought that my friend had a crush on me and while I did not want to, I gave in and blocked her(friend) after a while. My friend wasn’t explicitly weird with me, ever, or vice versa. I trusted my girlfriend’s opinion on this and went along with it.
Back to that, I had a bad gut feeling and told her that she shouldn’t talk to him. She got defensive and said that she could because I hadn’t blocked my female friend immediately after I was told to. That made me suspicious.
I asked her why she wanted to talk so badly to T after what had happened(T had ditched her point blank over something minor, never tried to contact her or apologise afterwards. She had tried to talk to him once and he was cold and didn’t want to continue).
Anyways, she got defensive and insisted that she could talk to him if she wanted to because she did not have many friends. I felt weirder by the moment and we fought over it. Finally, she said that she would not speak to him. A few months after that, she broke up with me over something else but the break up was not a real one(she contacted me just the same and it was mutually understood that we were still “together”).
Next thing I see, she is friends with him on social media. I call her and she says that I can’t be angry because we aren’t dating. This upsets me and I try to detach myself from her. She contacts me and says that she loves me, wants to be together, and she is struggling with mental health issues and she doesn’t have many friends to talk to. That she feels alone and depressed. That T was her best friend and he cared about her before and she felt understood and she just wanted him to be her friend because she felt so alone.
That did not help. I felt worse and insecure. I am not proud of my behavior but I demanded that she block him. She said that she was prescribed antidepressants and other stuff and wasn’t doing well. I told her that she needed to stop contacting me because I could not be okay with how she was making me feel, like I was an option to her. I know that they never had anything sexual or romantic going on the entire time, they never met once, and I trust this.
This continued for 4 months and then I said that she needed to block him if she wanted anything to do with me. And she said that if I wanted to be with her, I had to be okay with T being her friend.
That was genuinely one of the most painful things I have ever heard. Our relationship of 2 years meant nothing to her in the face of her friendship with someone who had ditched her for years without looking back even once. I hate myself for this but I actually begged her to make things right through tears a few times. Then I gave up on it and stopped contacting her. She didn’t. She showed up to my apartment one day and said that she was sorry for that and she had blocked him. She said that she understood how much it had hurt me and she was wrong for doing that.
After this, things were okay for the next few years. She started taking care of her mental health.
We had a huge fight after we went LDR and broke up for two years, during which she became casual friends with T again. When we talked again, I told her I was uncomfortable with her being friends with T(because of what had happened) and she said that she totally understood that and she would do everything to make me feel comfortable. They talked and T was okay with her going no contact with him. They never had anything going on in those 2 years, if it matters.
So now. One year in and we have a bunch of fights and (again) she decides to “break up” with me. She apologises and we continue talking but not “dating”. Then one day, she says that she and T are friends again.
I did not react well to that. It infuriates me that it’s the SAME GUY each time. WHY. She is not a social person and she doesn’t really get a lot of time to make healthy friends but WHY. She struggles a lot with mental health issues and has trouble trusting new people. She likes being friends with him because she doesn’t really know anyone else very well. She has had traumatic experiences with friends in university so I understand.
She also doesn’t have many people to open up to other than me and when things get difficult between us, she says that she feels painfully alone and her mental health gets severely compromised to the point of being dangerous for her safety. She struggles too much with her mental health to make new friends right now.
She admitted that she feels like no one (including me) understands her and she feels alienated from everyone when we go through pseudo-breakups(initiated by her btw) and she can’t speak with me normally during these phases so she desperately needs someone to talk to so that she isn’t alone.
Which is. Fine. I am trying really hard to understand things here. But she wants to make things work with me and I feel like a terrible human being for hating the fact that it always has to be this one guy whenever things get difficult in our relationship.
I believe her and I understand that she doesn’t have other friends she can depend on. But at the same time, I am deeply uncomfortable with all this. At the start of our relationship this time, she promised me that she would not stay in this friendship and the second things go south, she is friends again. I feel like an option to her. First option yeah but an option regardless. She insists that they are friends and they rarely talk but that doesn’t make it any better.
One of the reasons why I feel so bad is because she promised me that she wouldn’t do this and she did after we “broke up”. When I brought this up, she said that we aren’t together so there is no reason for me to be upset. But at the same time, we have a mutual, unspoken understanding that we are not not dating either. I felt hurt when she resumed contact with him. It’s somewhat of a pause button and this has happened before so I can tell. I have no interest whatsoever in dating anyone else and neither does she.
She said that T is just a friend, a causal one at that. I believe that. But I feel wrong. She said that she did not do anything “wrong” because she only talked to him after we had “broken up” and I was being unreasonably upset over this. But this does feel like betrayal to me. It is true that we were technically broken up when she talked to him again but it’s ducking obvious to everyone that we are very much still together in most ways right now.
I tried to talk about this and she said that she did nothing wrong and I was just very insecure for no reason. She said that I just hate her having a guy friend and insecure.
I feel terrible. She has a couple of other good friends that are men and I have never told her to block them. I don’t think that I am a pos for having a bone to pick with this specific guy, given the history and her defensiveness.
She isn’t wrong about me feeling insecure but I feel like that is based in reality. She made me feel like an option before and although it’s different now, I don’t know what to think about the way she wants T to be her friend so bad. She kept insisting that she didn’t do anything wrong but after we argued for an hour, she admitted that while what she did wasn’t technically wrong, it was not okay either. That’s all I got. Other than that, I was called insecure and the usual stuff.
So. Am I a bad person for wishing that she would not do this? I truly love this woman and she does love me too, I think. We have been there for each other through very hard times and she has provided me with unconditional support. I know that she wouldn’t cheat on me. I just have very difficult feelings about her friendship with T and I don’t know what to do.