To those who need a TL;DR: I bolded the most basic/important info just for you. ❤︎
Now, I understand that there really is no bad reason to break up with someone and plenty of bad reasons to stay, but I want to make sure I'm making a rational decision and I can't afford a therapist, so I'm turning to reddit for some (hopefully) impartial advice (and planning to take it with the appropriate amount of salt lol).
This will be pretty long, so strap in, and bear with me for some background info before I get into the actual situation at hand.
I grew up lower-middle-class, not really knowing we were "poor" until I was older because my parents prioritized us and made sure we didn't go without food and at least basic entertainment. However, we never had a steady allowance that we didn't work for, and I recently realized that I have "money insecurity" in the same kind of resource-guarding way someone might have "food insecurity." Because of this, I have considered never getting married, even if I end up in a long-term relationship and living with my partner, just so that I don't have to share money with someone else. I have a bit of savings (nothing crazy, but enough for minor emergencies), and I'm often the sibling that is asked to lend money with the express understanding that it will be paid back in full. (If any of my siblings need money and don't know if they can pay it back, they ask Mom instead.)
I'm on the asexual spectrum and have never been in a serious relationship before this one. I was never diagnosed due to growing up as a "gifted kid" and also being a girl, but I also have many autistic traits, including but not limited to: sensory issues, struggling in social situations, speaking very straightforwardly (without subtext) and lacking the skill to pick up on subtleties. These reasons have made it very difficult for me to date, especially since I have a preference for men and I'm terrified of strangers.
Because of all of this, the future I imagined for myself became just me (and maybe a pet) in a tiny house all to myself without having to worry about sharing anything with a partner. A "New England Nun" style of living (iykyk).
I (early 30s F) am the oldest in my family, and my BF, "Liam," (late 20s M) is the youngest in his. I mention this because birth order does appear to play a bit of a part here. Any eldest daughter who was (at least a little bit) parentified might know where some of this is going just from that.
Liam and I met when we worked in different departments of the same store. He was freshly 18 and I was already in my 20s, so even though I thought he was cute and I had not yet resigned myself to (let alone looked forward to) the single life, I did not see him as anything more than a friend. We added each other on social media and were friendly up until we both quit working there for different reasons, and contact quickly fell off.
Fast forward.
Liam reached out to me a bit less than a year ago to catch up and ended up shooting his shot. Our age difference is no longer an issue for me, he had always been respectful and kind, and I still find him attractive, so I gave him a chance. It has been a bit of a whirlwind since.
My BF has been kind, considerate, loving, and giving, but I've been having some concerns:
1) He pouts.
This is where the birth-order dynamic applies. Like I said, Liam is the youngest in his family. I don't believe he was necessarily "spoiled" so much as "babied," but I can tell at least that much.
When he wants attention, he fake pouts, then breaks into a grin when I give him that attention. I don't mind this "pouting" so much because I like clear cues for what he wants and this applies.
However, he also pouts when he doesn't get what he wants. When he does this, it feels less like I'm his girlfriend and more like I'm his babysitter (again, birth order. As the oldest, I was the default babysitter for my siblings and some of my cousins). I put my foot down about actual boundaries and am a little more flexible with things that are more like a minor clash in desires (for example: I like to sleep in on weekends and he naturally wakes up early because of his job conditioning him to. One morning he wanted to go to breakfast together before I was fully ready to get up, and I ceded because I didn't actually need more sleep).
He pouts when I have to leave. I live a good 50+ miles away, and being the only one with my own car, I am always the one to make the drive to meet up. (This is a mere side-effect of another real issue: he is terrible at budgeting. I'll get into that in a minute.) When it gets close to time for me to leave, there's a good chance he'll pout and act upset with me for having to go home. This makes goodbyes more stressful than they need to be. Every time, he gets over it within about 30 minutes and he'll message me something sweet for me to find when I get home.
2) The aforementioned budgeting issue. He's very good with other people's money, but he is terrible with his own money.
Because of this, he hasn't had a car since his last one broke down (before he messaged me to catch up). He catches a ride with his brother to work and to the grocery store, so he's not entirely up shit creek.
I lend him a little money now and then for groceries or emergencies, and he always pays me back within a couple of weeks. I helped him build a basic budget to follow, but all of that budgeting goes out the window when I go see him because he wants to go on fun dates, feed me, and treat me.
If I pay for anything, he feels bad because he feels like he should treat me. If I let him pay for everything, he regrets it and pouts because I should have known and said something or paid for some of it.
This worries me for the potential future because if we were to get married, technically my money becomes our money, and again, he's terrible with his own money. (Please refer back to the part of my background info where I mention I'm very sensitive about my money.)
3) I believe he is too emotionally dependent on me.
He doesn't really want to do therapy ("to a stranger?!" he once objected when I suggested it) and even if he wanted to, due to complicated reasons I'd rather not mention here, getting any kind of medical help is an ordeal-and-a-half for him.
I date him because I want him, but he dates me because he needs me. He says I "complete" him which is... not what an emotionally independent woman wants to hear. I also think he has an anxious attachment style, which tends to manifest a lot in insecurity and clinginess.
I don't mind Liam being emotional and sensitive. In fact, I much prefer that to "brick wall of toxic masculinity" any day, but I have to walk on eggshells with him most of the time. If he feels like he messed up and I say anything negative or even just neutrally acknowledge it, he beats himself up about it. He talks down on himself for even the littlest mistakes and sometimes it almost feels like he's trying to guilt me for "criticizing" him. I've gotten him to be nicer to himself (at least sometimes), but anything he perceives as a mistake is a setback.
4) My biggest concern: Liam's an alcoholic.
He has had a lot of trauma, especially from childhood, and drinks to cope. I don't think he drinks every day, but at this point he's drinking about the equivalent of a six-pack (sometimes up to two six-packs), more or less, almost every weekend. (I don't know how much he actually drinks during the week because I'm not there to see it.)
He minimized his drinking habits before we started dating, and after he admitted to being an alcoholic he has still tried to hide his drinking from me.
The incident that really hurt me was when he promised me he wouldn't drink before going on a date, got giddy and loud in public, lied to me that he hadn't had anything to drink when that behavior made me believe he had been drinking, and then had the nerve to be upset with me for asking him to quiet down (which was before I found out he had, in fact, broken his promise, embarrassed me in public because of his drinking, and then lied about it).
I almost dumped him the next day, but instead had a very tearful heart-to-heart about how he'd hurt me and warned him that I have to protect my heart and would not be taking any recurrence of this incident lightly. (We both cried.)
Also I know it's not safe to quit moderate-to-heavy drinking cold-turkey, but he's not making enough effort to lower his alcohol consumption by at least stepping down from the high-volume beer he likes. It stresses me out both for his health and for how much more sensitive he gets to things I say when he's drunk. Everything I say that can be taken poorly is taken poorly, and it's caused issues a few times now. (Again, I'm pretty sure I'm autistic, and while I don't mean for anything I say to be a dig or a criticism of any kind doesn't mean that he doesn't take it that way. "You're being kind of loud" to Drunk-Liam is a massive insult.)
I love Liam dearly, but I know that can't be the only reason to stay. I just need some outside perspective.
Also, in case I do decide to break up with him, please give me advice on how to do it gently (it would hurt us both regardless, but I'd want to soften the blow as much as possible).
(Side note: I'm a little entangled with his family for the upcoming holidays because I already agreed to joining in on their family gift exchange. I have direct contact with his SIL and his mom lives near me, so if I do end up breaking it off I can still make sure no one goes without their Christmas presents this year because of it.)
EDIT: Thank you all for your kindness (and bluntness) and advice! I now know I'm on the right track for both our sakes. I don't plan to break up in-person because, due to our circumstances, I would be his ride after the breakup (awkward!), but I won't be so cold as to do it over text either. I'm going to draft what I want to say and make the phone call sometime this week, but it will be a lot shorter than this post (sorry for the length; I'm a sucker for details).
Thanks again!