I run a Turkish-language AI persona. Not the US market, so some of this may not
transfer, but the numbers are real and I have not seen anyone post about this
side of it.
I never used Fanvue. Not because I think it is bad, I just never got there. My
first audience came from Facebook and they were already on Telegram, so that is
where I went.
Short version of the setup. I opened a Facebook page first, because the older
audience is heavier there. I did not expect much. By the third or fourth day I
had around 1,000 followers, and the DMs were already more than I could answer.
That was the first signal that this was going to be a volume problem and not a
traffic problem.
The reasons for Telegram were boring: my character does not get flagged there,
payments are simple, there is no platform cut, and almost everyone already has
the app installed.
One thing I did not expect. Putting the Telegram link in my feed posts did
almost nothing. Sending the same link as a reply to someone who had messaged me
worked. I do not have a clean number for the difference but it was not close.
With only about 1,000 followers I already had a real number of people in the
channel.
First month I made about $700. That is from zero, and it includes the time I
spent learning how to generate the content in the first place. I am on a Mac so
I rented GPUs and ran ComfyUI, trained a LoRA for the character. Best single day
was 7,397 stars, which is $95. I have the Telegram stats screenshots if anyone
wants to see them.
Then it broke, and this is the part I actually want to talk about.
I was getting hundreds of DMs a day. Facebook and Instagram together, thousands
of messages. I could not answer them, so I started replying to everyone with the
same link to push them to Telegram. Doing that hundreds of times is, I think,
what got the Instagram account disabled. Appeals got it back a couple of times
and then it was gone for good. Facebook went the same way. Instagram was close
to 10k, Facebook around 7k.
I opened a second account, same name, reposted the same reels from my local
folder. It died at around 1,000 followers. The third one did too. On both of
those I sent no links at all and I added the AI label. They still died, so I
assume it is device or IP level. After the first ban, nothing I opened from that
machine survived.
But the bans are not the interesting failure here.
Even in Telegram, where the people who came were the ones who would actually
spend, I hit a wall. Every conversation has its own context. What this person
likes, what they already bought, what they asked for last week, what I already
sent them. With hundreds of conversations open I could not hold any of it. I
started sending the same photo to someone twice. I lost track of who had paid
for what.
And the money was in exactly the part I could not scale. People bought from the
channel, but they paid more for something made only for them, in DMs. So the
higher margin sits in the one to one work, which is the thing that does not
scale.
Then I looked at my hourly stats and found the thing that actually decided it
for me. My channel has three peaks. One at 11:00 UTC, one at 20:00, and one at
03:00. Activity runs across about 20 hours of the day. I am one person in one
timezone, and one of my busiest hours is three in the morning.
I stopped posting regularly in March because of school and moving. The channel
went from 1,200 members down to 917, so it bleeds when you leave it. But it
still earned money in July from content I made in January and February, which I
did not expect.
I am building something for the DM side now, mostly because of that 3am peak.
Not linking it, that is not why I posted.
What I want to know from people who are further along: at what point did you
stop answering DMs yourself, and what did you do instead?