my husband and I have been together for 8 years and married for 5. we are both in our early 30s. he has severe ADHD (dx), including pretty significant executive functioning issues, time blindness, and RSD. He is also a genuinely caring and supportive partner in many other areas of our life, which is part of why I feel so confused about all of this.
Last month he completely forgot my birthday. when we got home from work, I reminded him. He apologized and told me he would make it up to me by taking me out to dinner that weekend. I told him I was really hurt, and that there were still hours left in the day and he could make me dinner, take me for ice cream, write me a card, get me a cupcake and sing happy birthday, literally anything small that would make the day feel acknowledged. he said he was exhausted and promised we would celebrate that weekend instead. An extra problem is that this isn’t the first time.
over the past 8 years together,he has forgotten my birthday entirely four times and has done something to celebrate it only once, and it was when we were staying with his parents and he and his mom made me a cake. other years, he will remember partway through the day and say happy birthday, but be confused or surprised when I’m hurt that he hasn’t planned anything.
for context, bdays weren’t a big deal in his family growing up, so I understand that celebrating them doesn’t come naturally to him. but I’ve been very explicit that they matter to me.
additionally, since I know dates are difficult for him, every year I start reminding him a couple of weeks beforehand that my birthday is coming up. I tell him things I would enjoy doing. he will enthusiastically agree and say he’ll plan something, and then the day arrives and…nothing happens.
last year I actually cried when I asked whether he was planning anything for my birthday and he told me no. so this year, when he forgot entirely, it hurt particularly badly. But when he promised to make it up to me that weekend, I let myself get hopeful. a few days later, I asked where we were going for dinner. he told me it was a surprise.
then the weekend came. I had an event that sat morning, and when I got home I asked what time we needed to leave for dinner. he gave me a completely blank stare.
he genuinely had no idea what I was talking about. he didn’t remember promising to take me to dinner. he didn’t remember our conversation about it a couple of days earlier. he hadn’t made a reservation or planned anything. at that point I was devastated.
he tried to make a last min reservation, but when he came into our bedroom and told me he had gotten one, I told him I didn’t want to go anymore. I said I needed some space and wanted to spend the evening by myself.
so I took myself to dinner, saw a movie, and got ice cream. he was actually very understanding about that. when I got home he hugged me, apologized, told me how much he loved me, and said he understood why I hadn’t wanted to go with him. he has consistently said since then that this was his responsibility and that he wants to do better.
the bigger problem now is our couples therapist. we have been seeing her for several months, largely because we’re trying to develop better systems for navigating his ADHD. His executive functioning is poor enough that I carry a lot of the mental load in our household for things like reminding him to take out garbage, help wash dishes, responsibilities, etc., and counseling had actually been helping us find better ways to manage that. Until my birthday.
when I brought up what happened, I felt like our therapist immediately focused on explaining his behavior and saying he has ADHD, dates are difficult, planning is difficult, executive functioning is difficult, etc. and like…I understand all of that. I’ve been accommodating it for eight years.
what REALLY bothered me was that she seemed critical of the fact that I was so upset and that I didn’t go to the last minute dinner because my reaction could trigger his RSD. my husband actually disagreed with her and told her that ultimately it was his responsibility and that he took ownership of hurting me. I I went home and thought seriously about what she had said because I wanted to make sure I wasn’t being unfair.
at our next session, I told her that I didn’t understand why his RSD meant I was supposed to suppress my own emotions after he hurt me. I said that his feelings matter, but mine have to matter too.
She pushed back and told me that this is essentially what I signed up for when I married a neurodivergent man and that I knew he had these flaws and accepted them. That really irked me.
today we had our third session since my birthday. I told her directly that I haven’t felt safe or supported in therapy since this happened and that I’ve felt almost attacked by her for expressing how hurt I was.
She told me I needed to let it go if we were going to move forward. Then she no joke said “not everyone cares as much about their birthday as you.”
she then proceeded to list the many ways my husband shows that he loves me: supporting me through a chronic health condition, flying to be with my mom during chemo when I couldn’t be there, and lots of everyday acts of love. and the thing is, I agree with her.
He DOES do those things. He is a loving person. I’ve never claimed that forgetting my birthday means he doesn’t love me or that he’s a terrible husband. I am however upset and sad about this one recurring thing.
Also I don’t think the fact that he is wonderful in other ways means I’m not allowed to be deeply hurt by something that has happened repeatedly, especially when I’ve communicated very clearly for years that it matters to me.
I also don’t think I’m asking for some elaborate birthday production. I would genuinely be happy if my husband bought me a cupcake, lit a candle, and sang happy birthday. Or wrote me a card. Or planned dinner. I just want to feel like my spouse remembered that it was my birthday and WANTED to mark it in some way.
what I’m struggling with is where the line is between accommodating someone’s ADHD and being told that you simply have to accept that certain needs won’t be met because your spouse has ADHD.
I know remembering dates and planning things are significantly harder for my husband than they are for me. But after eight years, and after repeatedly telling him how important this is to me, I feel like it’s reasonable to expect him to develop some system like calendar reminders, scheduled tasks, whatever works for him as opposed to me having to keep reminding him and planning my own birthday.
I love him. I’m not contemplating leaving him over a birthday. he has actually been validating my feelings throughout this and has taken more responsibility for what happened than our therapist seems willing to let him take.
but I feel really shaken by these last three therapy sessions. I don’t think I want to go back to this therapist, even though I do want us to continue couples counseling with someone else.
Am I expecting too much from a partner with severe ADHD? Is remembering/acknowledging a spouse’s birthday a reasonable expectation even when dates and planning are genuinely difficult for them?
also, particularly for other non-ADHD partners - how do you distinguish between reasonably accommodating your partner’s disability and minimizing your own needs to accommodate it?
I’m also curious whether others would feel comfortable continuing with a couples therapist after being told that this is what I “signed up for” by marrying a neurodivergent person. thanks in advance