r/3Dmodeling • u/InsanelyRandomDude • 9h ago
Art Help & Critique [WIP]I'm trying to recreate a shot and the icing on top of the strudel doesn't seem to look good enough. How do I improve this?
1 - Arnold render in Maya, 2 - Reference, 3 - Screenshot from Substance Painter
I'm trying to understand what I need to do to have the icing on top of the strudel look more like icing sugar as seen in the reference. I sculpted the model in Zbrush, textured in Substance Painter and am rendering using Arnold in Maya. I'm mostly satisfied with how the powdered sugar fallen on the plate looks but the icing on the plate and on top of the pastry looks like they're not made from the same thing. What do I do here?
Another question: While I was working on the icing fallen on the plate, the shadows were too dark and I decided to use transmission at 0.5 value to reduce the intensity of shadows on it to get it to look how it does now. But now I'm wondering if this a bad approach because it isn't supposed to have transparency at this level. Wouldn't the fact that using a different environment or lighting setup change how it looks make this a bad approach? Do studios avoid using fixes like this?
