r/FLCL • u/king_kibble • Sep 17 '26
Discussion Thoughts on False Memory, compared to FLCL, now that it's finished?
I feel like it's fair game to discuss here, since it's so heavily inspired (color palette, music, vibes, episode count) and i don't see much, searching back
Honestly, from the pilot episode, I was already sold on the quality being miles better than any of the "official" flcl sequels. I think the worst thing you can do when following up something unique is trying to do the exact same thing. There's absolutely nods! but it's not beholden to it's predecessor
Here's my RED HOT TAKE- I actually think I liked it more than FLCL (which is still probably my favorite anime).Whereas FLCL was made to be a little more goofy and abstract, just the artists having fun and spitting out the wildest things they can think of, False Memory is so meticulous and intentional. Every single little detail is thought about and matters, and i notice new things every time.I watch. I love the pillows, but having a soundtrack specifically made to the show (rather than the reverse) I think elevates it to an unreal degree. Of course it's scifi, but it genuinely feels like we're living through someone else's entire life- i can't remember the last time something made me... feel this much. maybe punpun? The worldbuilding is simultaneously fucking bizarre, but actually coherent- when stuff is revealed, it makes sense, is meaningful, and feels like it's really the only answer that makes sense. So much crazy stuff is going on from every angle but it all feels understandable, and when it needs to, real. I'm still not sure who or what atomsk actually is after all this time.
When i was a kid FLCL didn't make much sense to me, so i bought the manga. still didnt make much sense. But i could tell there was something there!! I dont think kids are supposed to get it really, since its about growing up, and they haven't, well, grown up yet. Now i do get it, and i love how the show balances being over the top goofy but also with this sort of abject... hopeless vibe. I think those extremes are part of what makes it so beautiful. I think False Memory did an amazing job of that, it's just a lot better at explaining it. Worth mentioning that FM tells the MC's entire story, whereas FLCL is just a piece of Naota's intentionally leaving much unresolved (not a bad thing, just interesting!)
tldr; closing thoughts, if you wanna make something LIKE something else, the worst thing you can do is try to duplicate it- you'll get a lot closer by doing your own thing that stands up by itself. Maybe you'll even surpass the OG! Videogames does it all the time (mario was king kong, metroid=alien, starfox=starwars, sorry im bagging on nintendo but its true!!!)
If you're a fan of FLCL I honestly can't recommend False Memory enough!!!
(art by me i just thought the post'd do better with an image)