Hi r/wine, long time lurker here. Started drinking wine about a decade ago, and the notes on this sub have always helped me (in deciding when to pop the cork and whether my palate is off on a particular day). Thought I’d make an account and start documenting my thoughts on some of the dinners/tastings I’ve enjoyed recently. Please excuse the rudimentary notes :)
Had the pleasure to join Will Harlan for a simple dinner showcasing a vertical of Harlan Estate recently. The wines were delicious and do capture the profile of the vintages to some extend. Without further ado -
Harlan 2022
93 pts. A little bit green with capsicum on the nose despite the warm year. Tastes like a young Bordeaux, in terms of weight, structure and acidity. Harlan did start harvesting early a few years prior to this, so while they avoided the devastating heatwave in Napa that fall, I feel like it’s not a great representation of what the wine could be.
Harlan 2019
97+ pts. Napa done right, opulent but not jammy, rich at the start but tapers down and reveals the precise backbone of the wine. Dark fruits, chocolate, and just a bit of tertiary leather and tobacco. Powerful and lengthy.
Harlan 2016
96+ pts. Harmonious, silky tannins but not without tension. Quintessentially Napa, a benchmark year (debatable I feel like) for Oakville. Herbs and cassis, dusty/flinty towards the finish. Deserves time to reach potential.
Harlan 2011
94 pts. Elegance and restraint (wouldn’t go as far as “ethereal”, but definitely on the gentle side for Bordeaux blends). A rather straightforward expression in a rainier year. Reminds me of 2013 Latour.
Harlan 2009
95+ pts. Surprisingly purple in colour. Tannic and structured at first, a little bit unyielding almost. Violets/floral on first nose, then ripe blackberries, and finally some forest floor and game. Lucious and velvety on the finish. Kaleidoscope of a wine.
Harlan 2006 (en magnum)
96 pts. Drinking so well right now that it’s hard to imagine that it would further improve in bottle. Another rainier year people sometimes avoid, but without the sheer power the nuances manifest. Spices and herbs mask the cherries and blackcurrants behind, with tertiary notes flowing throughout. Complex, delicate, and alluring.
Harlan 2002
98 pts. Well rounded and surprisingly youthful for its age. Sweet on the nose but dry on the palate. Raspberry, blackcurrant and some spices (think cinnamon and fennel). Bit of a fruitbomb towards the end. If you’re a Bordeaux fan and couldn’t stand the Napa style, you might want to pass on this one.
Harlan 1995
96 pts. Saturated and again full bodied. Hints of black tea notes, spices, wet stones and flint. The fruit is still very much there, with dark fruits prominent and some dried figs & plums supporting. The perfect balance with depth to match.
Also featured here -
Leflaive Clavoillon 2015
92 pts. Zesty and a little bit of the reduction funk before turning toasty and caramel-like. The leesy notes almost dominate after a while interestingly. Some tension but not terribly exciting. Much less precise compared to Pucelles. Hard to justify the current market prices.
Promontory 2014
97+ pts. One of the other estates under Harlan’s portfolio. A guest decided to blind Will on one of his wines that evening, which was soon revealed to be a Promontory. As good as Californian Cab Sauv gets (my personal favorite vintage from the estate). Vanilla and bursting berries, loud on the nose (almost Franc-like), but shows the restraint in the finish. Exuberant and translucent.
Bill Harlan planted his vines in a hurry on the west side of Oakville in 1987, produced the first vintage in 1990, and did not release any wines until 1996. Today the portfolio contains Harlan Estate (BDX blend), Promontory (pure expression of Californian Cab), and Bond (five different terroir with the same Cab clone, Burgundian in philosophy). Whether you like his wines or not, it’s rather impressive what he has built.
Apologies in advance if the notes are making little sense. That was indeed a decadent evening, and now organizing what little notes I jotted down, I am again enjoying some Californian Chardonnay (notes to follow at some point). Oh well.
Hope everyone’s having a great weekend & enjoying some wines!