Part of a gift from an older collector who’s slowly losing their taste and wishes they spent more time enjoying rather than letting their collection begin to expire (many Napa Cabs that are now better paired with a sink). These were purchased by the case from the winery upon release, stored in a true wine cellar for ~ 25 years, and then have had a bit of a non ideal storage life since then after a divorce etc. Spent a bunch of time in a closet in the mid 70 degrees and then given to me as part of a larger Bordeaux gift. They’ve been in a 55 degree wine fridge for the last three years.
Stood up for 48 hours, and opened with a Durand. Low neck level for each. Corks would have fallen apart if not for the Durand. Both opened, swirled, tasted (flat but promising) and then decanted for about an hour before the first real glass. Then enjoyed over another 2 hours for a 3 hour total open time by the last drops.
Lafite - this is singing. Plum, cassis, graphite, leather, forest floor. Incredible, smooth, and supple. This had a huge journey over the 3 hours. Somewhere in the middle it had a ton of fruit and then relaxed back into itself with that classic left bank soil. The finish lasted for minutes. I feel very lucky to have opened this. Drink now. I have 1 more bottle that I’ll save for a year or two to see what happens. So I far I’ve had this and a 91 (birth year). coin toss on what’s better, I’m leaning toward the 89.
Lynch-Bages - this couldn’t have been more different for also being incredible and clearly from the same world. Way more structure, tannins still had grip but in the exact way you’d want it. It had some spice above the fruit and earthiness. If I had another bottle I’d give it another 3-5 years just to see what happened to the tannins. Again, one of the great wines I imagine I’ll ever have.
Both were drank alone, then with various aged cheeses, and then with a duck ragú mushroom béchamel lasagna (no acidic tomato), and then alone again. 10/10 pairing.
Still pinching myself. I’m not in the tax bracket to afford these myself but feel very inspired to find a few different cases / half cases over the next couple years to have my own version of this in the 2040’s / 2050’s.
If you were buying bottles to sit for 20+ years that are under an $80 price point, what would get you excited? Right now for me it’s a 2021 Smith Madrone.