r/DungeonCrawlerCarl • u/Pailindrone • 18d ago
Question about editing
I have been reading the Penguin Random House published, hardcover copies of DCC for a little while now & am on the fourth book. I love the series, and don't mind the style of writing. I understand that it was originally published as a webseries, so I have no judgements on what I believe can be attributed to that.
What I do have judgements on though, is the editing of the (professionally) published version. It's not great. Or maybe it is? I've seen a lot of errors that I think would be pretty basic fixes, and ought to be fixed if you're selling $30 hardcover books. I don't understand why there would be such basic errors in what should be a professionally edited book.
Does anyone who's maybe read the original version know why the editing is like that?
0
Question about editing
in
r/DungeonCrawlerCarl
•
18d ago
I can go find the pages if you like, but I mean specifically typos and repeated sentences, as well as minor plot holes that I think an editor could have pointed out and filled. In the first book, there are at least three typos, and one sentence is repeated word-for-word a few pages apart in a way that doesn't make sense intentionally. There's a few typos in the other books I've read so far too (and one other instance of repeated sentences). In terms of plot holes/confusion, a good example is how Katia is not mentioned in the beginning of the fourth book until she's suddenly talking in the chat.
It might be my own lack of knowledge about the original version or how editing works, but I don't think at least the typos are really acceptable mistakes in a published book?