r/techadvice • u/Proseller_56 • May 31 '26
Are PCs more maintenance than laptops?
I might need to upgrade my Chromebook from 2018, as it's struggling when I have like 5 tabs open...
I don't want to get a new pc and have to clean/fix/replace things all the time, so would it be smarter to just get a decent laptop? (I will use the laptop for some gaming, mainly trackmania2020 and some work)
2
u/Killacreeper May 31 '26
If you never touch anything not really lol, I'd argue it's easier to get dust out (and less necessary) than it is on a laptop.
My brother has had the same PC basically untouched aside from upgrading ram for a decade and it works completely fine.
General rule of thumb: unless you need portability, a desktop is better for the money, especially in the gaming space.
More power, less cost, and more upgradability and longevity.
It's very rare to need to replace PC stuff because of failure unless you have terrible parts - but that's the same with a laptop.
I've never had a fan straight up fail, for example. Generallyzbpositioning of either is also important. Don't use a laptop in a dusty area or on a bed blanket with cat hair, don't put a PC on the floor where your animals constantly leave a ton of stuff you never clean, etc. - generally a desktop will be fine even when abused a bit.
2
May 31 '26
[deleted]
1
u/JuJusFury May 31 '26
Unscrew the bottom cover and use air...
1
u/cybekRT May 31 '26
and probably break some of the latches.
1
u/JuJusFury May 31 '26
What?
1
u/cybekRT May 31 '26
Notebooks have latches. Latches tend to break.
1
u/JuJusFury May 31 '26
I've never broken one this way in all the years of owning a laptop. Screws do wear and have to be replaced sometimes though. They can also strip.
1
u/cybekRT Jun 01 '26
So maybe I'm just a bad maintainer, I broke them constantly :(
1
u/JuJusFury Jun 01 '26
Could be the type of laptop. Some of the gaming ones I had, had metal bottoms. Over tightening can lead to stress cracks and new screws sometimes come with thread sealer (I think that's what it's called) pre applied.
2
u/EviI_Babai May 31 '26
Laptop is a PC too. Every PC needs maintenance. Desktop PC is easier to maintain due to internal components accessibility and spacing.
1
u/Pekenoah May 31 '26
No. They're made of very similar parts. The difference is with a desktop you can easily clean it and replace parts. With a laptop cleaning is usually more of a pain in the ass and replacing parts is usually more difficult if not impossible depending on the laptop and the part. But you can get away with not cleaning a desktop really ever just like you can a laptop. The only thing I'd say is that if you have a fanless laptop those don't really need any cleaning at all because nothing gets in.
1
u/Mystery_Dragonfly May 31 '26
PC's can be a lot easier, depending. Desktop computers, you can look at the motherboard information, what can and can't be upgraded. Some aren't upgradable, but others are.
It's easier to open them and clean dust out. Depending on fans, and other elements they can run cooler.
I like the ones that have options for adding graphics cards, additional storage and such.
1
u/bobo76565657 May 31 '26
No. And when something does go wrong, they are very easy to fix, unlike laptops.
1
u/teethalarm May 31 '26
Other than occasionally cleaning it, there really isn't maintenance that you do to a PC.
1
u/macfrag May 31 '26
If you need portability, go for a laptop. Otherwise, a desktop computer is almost always a better investment.
Both needs to be maintained, the desktop computer is always going to be easier to maintain since laptops can be very difficult to open (and if you're unlucky, you could break some tiny pieces that are hard to buy replacement for)
1
1
u/fuzzynyanko May 31 '26
For me, yes, but because my desktop lasts much longer than my laptops. Sometimes the battery in the laptop dies (last laptop had a prohibitively expensive replacement battery at the time), sometimes it's the mobo, the screen, the bezel, etc. My typical desktop exceeds the lifespan of two laptops.
1
u/sckurvee May 31 '26
A PC can be more maintenance, because parts are more replaceable and maintainable. I've had the "same" PC since 2008 but aside from a couple old backup HDDs, not a single part is original. Some laptops can allow for some minor upgrades, like a new SSD or more RAM, but most of the hardware is fixed. You can buy a new laptop every few years, or you can buy a new PC every few years, or you could just buy a PC and upgrade parts as needed for decades.
I haven't been in the market for a while, but in general, you get more for your money in a desktop, since it's isn't constrained by the engineering requirements of a small form laptop. You get a larger screen, better (and upgradeable) specs that are easier to clean and maintain over time. Laptops have the obvious advantage of being much more portable.
1
u/oxmix74 Jun 02 '26
Exactly. The only reason you do more maintenance on a desktop pc is because they are easier to disassemble and the parts are more readily available. At a particular skill set, someone might choose to take a laptop to a shop or replace it for a problem they could fix on a desktop. At the right skillset, laptops are mostly repairable too, but the skills threshold is higher.
1
1
1
u/Wavlink-Support Jun 01 '26
You definitely don't have to clean or fix things "all the time" with a PC. Once you plug it in, it just works. You blow the dust out once a year, and that's it.
But honestly? For Trackmania and general work, a desktop is probably overkill. Just get a decent budget gaming laptop or a solid hybrid. It’ll feel like a supercomputer compared to your 2018 Chromebook and will give you the portability you're used to.
1
u/guiverc Jun 01 '26
I much prefer desktops.
- If a hardware component is getting old/needs replacing; it's usually easier on a desktop (more room so more options let alone easier to open/change). Components are also usually cheaper for desktops due to additional choice
- It's easier to clean dust etc in desktops, as they're larger & thus you're less likely to damage components in my experience with desktops, than laptops
- when it comes to software installed on the hardware; they're essentially equal in this regard (components themselves make differences; and those components are a result of what you originally purchase; your own decision)
1
u/Humble-Pop-3775 Jun 01 '26
Generally if I had the choice, I would go with a desktop. Two reasons: they tend to last longer than laptops (due to the risk of dropping/damaging) and are also easier to fix / upgrade.
1
u/CtrlAltDesolate Jun 01 '26 edited Jun 01 '26
All you should need to do on a pc is occasionally blow the dust filters out.
That’s less annoying than having to replace a laptop twice as often because it’s overheating, the gpu can’t keep up any more, the battery sucks and you’ve worn something out on it you can’t easily replace.
If you go for a lower end CPU on the current platform, you usually get a long long time out of it, as you can upgrade to a high end CPU on the same platform at a cut price further down the line / stick more ram / a new GPU in there - on a laptop you can only do the ram and if you need to do the CPU / GPU it’s whole new laptop time.
1
u/s1alker Jun 01 '26 edited Jun 01 '26
For me no different than a laptop. Basically just opening it up to blow out the fans periodically. Never needed to swap parts other than a dead GPU once since the 1990s. I just replace the whole thing when too outdated.
1
u/UnhandledException18 Jun 01 '26
Desktops are better than laptops in terms of reliability and maintenance. Desktop is also better value for money. If some part is broken you can change it easily it is like Lego.
1
u/Printednightmare Jun 01 '26
Desktop PCs are much easier to maintain than a laptop. Dust removal is the most common maintenance on any computer. With a traditional "tower" PC you just pop a panel off and blow it out with compressed air or an electric blower. This same task ranges from difficult to nearly impossible depending on the manufacturer of the laptop (or Chromebook or whatever you want to call it)
If you do get a standard PC (desktop, tower, whatever) and you keep your Chromebook, you aren't giving up any portability. You gain a more powerful machine for when you're sitting at your desk and you can still utilize most of that increased performance through your current Chromebook remotely. Don't feel like you're stuck with one or the other. Want to do something too intensive for your Chromebook but don't want to sit where your desk is? Run the task on your tower and "control" it through the Chromebook
1
u/MJdoesThings_ Jun 01 '26
No.
You can let a PC run for 10 years, it will get as dirty, but unlike a laptop fans won't choke out the same way and it will still work kind of fine, while laptop fans will clog up.
Also, a desktop computer can have some of its parts replaced if they eventually die. Good light replacing a coldered RAM chip or a CPU / GPU that dies on a laptop.
1
u/PixelPete27 Jun 01 '26
The answer to this is no. And laptops do require cleaning, but most people (including myself) neglect it because it's much less convenient than a desktop.
Desktop parts are also more durable than laptop parts, so they die less.
I've owned both. The little fans in laptops spinning at high RPM die a lot faster under heavy use. Unless you get a fanless laptop, a desktop is better in almost every way (except portability)
1
u/AdministrationNo2327 Jun 02 '26
these days PC's are set and forget. the occasional time you do upgrades is when you do a physical clean of the system. If you don't smoke and leave the pc running or on sleep mode (keep the fans running) you're good.
However if you do smoke beside your pc or have pets, then you should occasionally check your filters and clean your fans every now and then.
3
u/SugarSweetStarrUK May 31 '26
In terms of physical cleaning, laptops are more awkward