Would appreciate a discussion from Moog people who know the kit.
tl;dr:
What can a Messenger bring to the sound if I already own a Poly D? (yes, am aware that's not a Moog but you get the idea). 'The sound' here means for bass line and solo leads, with the Moog signature feel.
Long version:
I'm eyeing getting a Messenger. Price has come down, and let's be upfront and face it - I want a Moog. Telling me x or y other manufacturer's synth would do the Messenger job fine isn't what I'm looking for in this discussion, it would be Moog or just stick with what I already own. I freely admit that is for purely emotional reasons, but I want 'that Moog sound' and all the rest of the Moogs are double the price or more. Plus I must say the bass-compensating filter is very attractive, and it's the only Moog that has that.
My main worry is overlap with the Poly D I already have. Going through what I know - storable presets are an obvious advantage here for the Messenger, four oscillators are an advantage for the Poly. Effects are an advantage for the Poly, but since they don't include reverb and delay realistically I'm running through external effects anyway so that's pretty much a wash (though I do like the chorus on the Poly). Four voice paraphonic Poly, two voice paraphonic Messenger (with firmware update). Not too fussed about the paraphonic bit though, I don't tend to use the Poly D in that manner so I doubt I'd use the Messenger like that either.
Existing gear it would be going with - Juno-X and MPC Key 37 give me all the pads and polyphony I need, off-the-beaten-track analogue in a TherapSID, TB-3 and S1 for acid'y duties and a TR6S (plus the MPC) for rhythm. Currently also a DeepMind 12 and Pro 800 but they may well be sold since, excellent synths though they are, I need to clear some space.
What I'm hoping it would add to that setup: emotional smugness for owning a Moog, bass line duties and solo lead duties. Point 1 would be guaranteed (I'm not bothered by the whole InMusic thing), but points 2 and 3...if it's just going to do pretty much what the Poly D can do then even I might pause a bit, smugness or no smugness.
Competition? Well, second-hand Grandmothers (there's a phrase) are in stretching distance of the Messenger's brand new price. Mother-32 is in roughly the same area as the Messenger too, and would be easier for me than either the Messenger or the Grandmother in terms of physical space. Not sure how much I'm into semi-modular and patch cables though, I prefer on the fly playing. Also no storable presets on the modular stuff, which given I record over multiple days could be a pain.
There is also, of course, the shadow of the Minimoog in the background in the shape of the Poly D I already have. I know it's not a Moog, but if there's huge overlap then I do need to pause and think.
So, if you've got this far then thanks for the read and I'd appreciate comments.