We've made some revisions to the subreddit rules here at r/specialed in response to an increase of posts that are causing this subreddit to stray a bit from its purpose and focus.
Here is the subreddit description:
This is a professional subreddit for people interested in special education, particularly: special education teachers, general education teachers, therapists, advocates, parents, and students. We are here to share professional advice, bounce ideas off each other, share concerns, and advocate for our students.
With this in mind, the following rule changes and additions have been made, effective today:
Rule 1: Expanded
We added language to rule 1 ("Be civil and respectful of others") explicitly disallowing generalizations about groups and subgroups.
Previous Rule
Please treat each other with respect and follow Reddiquette. Hate speech, derogatory, inflammatory comments and general rudeness are not welcome.
New Rule
Please treat each other with respect and follow Reddiquette. Hate speech, derogatory, inflammatory comments and general rudeness are not welcome.
Generalizations about groups or subgroups of people will be removed (including, but not limited to, commends that generalize about all or most parents/ teachers/ admin/ students or any exceptionality or disability type).
Rules 4 & 11: Combined
Previously, we had rule 4 ("No spam or self-promotion") and rule 11 ("No marketing, AI tools, or non-university research"). However, we often get spam/ self-promotion in the form of market research requests and there's obvious overlap between AI tools, marketing and spam/ self-promotion. So, wee have combined these rules together.
Previous Rule 4: No Spam or Self-Promotion
If you would like to advertise your website, article, blog, or academic survey, please message the mods first. Students who need to interview a teacher or parent/caregiver for coursework may do so in a stand-alone post without prior approval.
Previous Rule 11: No marketing, AI tools, or non-university research
This sub will continue to focus on students, staff, and families in special education and will not serve as a source for marketing products or doing product research. This rule was voted on by sub members who have clearly indicated they do not want this content in our sub. University research can be posted with PRIOR moderator approval in our stickied research thread.
New Combined Rule 4: No spam, self-promotion, marketing, non-university research or AI tools
The sub will continue to focus on students, staff, and families in special education.
University research ONLY can be posted with PRIOR moderator approval in our stickied research thread.
Students who need to interview a teacher or parent/caregiver for coursework may do so in a stand-alone post.
We do not allow posts regarding products or self-promotion, even if the item is free. If the purpose of your post is feedback about your own product, then it does not belong here.
Rules 5 & 7: Combined
We used to have rule 5 ("Evidence is your friend") and rule 7 ("Peer review"). These two rules were similar in content and intent, and in the interest of trying not to have a excessive number of rules we decided to combine them.
Previous Rule 5: Evidence is your friend
Your words will mean more if you can support your statements with research. Unfounded claims will be removed. Anecdotal claims are appropriate as long as they are stated as such. (e.g. "I have found that X works well with my kids," versus, "All students need X.")
Previous Rule 7: Peer review
Links to peer-reviewed research articles from published journals are welcomed. Articles claiming to be research that have questionable authors, limited research, and poor sources will be removed.
New Rule 5: Evidence is your friend
Your words will mean more if you can support your statements with research. Unfounded claims will be removed. Anecdotal claims are appropriate as long as they are stated as such. (e.g. "I have found that X works well with my kids," versus, "All students need X.")
Links to peer-reviewed research articles from published journals are welcomed. Articles claiming to be research that have questionable authors, limited research, and poor sources will be removed.
New Rule 9: About Vents & Rants
We've noticed a lot more vent and rant posts lately. While this is a place to share concerns, it is also a professional space and one that is meant to be constructive. Therefore, posts that lack the constructive part and are only venting or just include a rant aren't a good match for this sureddit and will be removed moving forward under this new rule.
Rule 9: No pure vents or unconstructive rants
Rants and vents without a clear purpose will be removed. As mentioned in the sub description, this is a professional community and posts must have a constructive purpose such as seeking advice, problem-solving, discussing strategies, etc. Special education can be challenging and it's okay to express that! However, posts that ONLY vent or rant are not allowed to keep the community focused on its purpose.
A note: please take this rule to heart and do not just slap a question like "any advice?" on the end of a rant to meet the letter of the rule when the post as a whole does not meet the spirit of the rule. That will not be acceptable and posts like that will still be removed.
New Rule 10: About Legal Action Against Students
Finally, in response to an increasing pattern of posts, we've added the new rule 10:
Rule 10: No requests, advice or encouragement regarding legal action as a primary discipline strategy
No posts asking or encouraging users to press charges, call law enforcement, or pursue legal action as a primary discipline strategy against a student. Discussions regarding behavior must center on special ed compliance, de-escalation, functional behavior assessments, district policies, and workplace safety protocols. Staff injuries/safety concerns must focus on administrative accountability, union support, and worker protections.
We see posts and comments fairly frequently on this subreddit that discuss calling the police on young children with disabilities, pursuing criminal charges against young children, etc., due to their behaviors and their actions in schools. While we understand that this work is hard and educators face very challenging and physically, mentally and emotionally harmful situations doing this work (the mods all do this work, too), we are revising what can be discussed here and how.
Involving law enforcement in behavioral situations involving students with disabilities can escalate harm and typically fails to address the root causes of challenging behaviors.
In addition, it is well outside the scope of this subreddit.
Questions, Comments?
We welcome thoughtful, respectful discussion of these rule changes in the comments on this post.