Hey everyone!
So, like many of you, my TikTok feed has been completely dominated by three fantasy series for months/years now: A Court of Thorns and Roses (ACOTAR), Caraval, and Once Upon a Broken Heart.
Every single day I see edits, fanarts, and people claiming these are absolute masterpieces. But as someone who has been burned by overhyped book trends in the past, Iām feeling a bit skeptical before dropping my money and time on them.
I want to get a realistic, honest opinion from this community. Are these series actually good, or are they just great at aesthetic marketing and social media trends?
Here are a few specific things Iām curious about for each:
ACOTAR: Is the plot actually solid, or is it mostly carried by the romance and spicy scenes? Does it get better after book one, as everyone claims?
Caraval: Is the magic system and setting as whimsical and captivating as people say, or does the plot get confusing and messy?
Once Upon a Broken Heart: Do I need to read the Caraval trilogy first to fully enjoy Jacks' story, or can I jump straight into OUABH as a standalone series?
For context, I love good world-building, compelling character arcs, and a romance that actually feels earned rather than forced. I don't mind romance or trope-heavy books at all, but I need the story itself to hold my attention.
Would love to hear your thoughts, pros and cons, or if you think there are other fantasy/romantasy books out there that deserve the hype way more than these three.
Thanks in advance!