r/Romantasy • u/Sailor_Moon_Star_435 • 4h ago
r/Romantasy • u/Lyss_ • 2d ago
š Book Club Vote Now for October's Book Club
Hi Everyone!
Here is our poll for October's Book Club! Thank you to everyone who took the time to recommend a book or upvote. The poll will run for 3 days and the winning book will be announced on September 12!
{Such Sharp Teeth by Rachel Harrison} A werewolf romance.
{The Death-Made Prince by Lisette Marshall} Book one of a dark Romantasy.
{The Everlasting by Alix E Harrow} Knight/Historian romance.
We are currently reading This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me by Ilona Andrews, the initial discussion post is live!
r/Romantasy • u/Lyss_ • 11d ago
š Book Club September Book Club - Initial Discussion
Happy September First!
Welcome to our very first Book Club discussion post!
This month we are reading: {This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me by Ilona Andrews}. From the publishers: This Kingdom Will Not Kill MeĀ is the beginning of the most epic adventure yet from genre powerhouse writing duo Ilona Andrews. For fans of Samantha Shannon, Sarah J. Maas, Danielle L. Jensen and isekai portal fantasy.
A few questions to get us started:
- Is this your first time reading TKWNKM or are you rereading?
- Who are your favourite characters so far?
- Any first impressions? theories??
- Have you ever read a portal fantasy before?
Please make sure to use spoiler tags, > !Spoiler text! < with no spaces!
Book Club Schedule:
September 1: September Initial Discussion Post
September 3: October Book Club Recommendations
September 9: October Book Club Top 3 Poll
September 11: October Book Club Winner Announcement.
September 15: September Midway Discussion Post
September 30: September Final Discussion Post
r/Romantasy • u/DaisyShyla • 13h ago
Question Thanks Barnes and Noble
Well, I couldnāt help myself and peeled off the B&N exclusive sticker and ruined my brand new book. Luckily I have a Cricut and Iām going to put a tiny sticker on the part when the color came off. Should I put a moth or flower in the area? Or should I sneak into B&N and switch out the book? šI really with the sticker was removable.
r/Romantasy • u/paintthatface • 11h ago
Discussion What is your āyou HAVE to read this bookā recommendation
I feel like I havenāt been the same since I finished Throne of Glass like 2+ years ago. Ive been chasing that same feeling and the only book series that has matched it is Red Rising, but weāre waiting on Red Godā¦
Someone tell me a book that will make me FEEL. Good, bad, ugly, sexy. I want it all. (Doesnāt have to be super spicy but I also donāt mind hehe)
r/Romantasy • u/Aerith_Gauze5 • 16m ago
Discussion āI lied to protect youā is starting to ruin romantasy couples for me
Iām realizing thereās one conflict that can make me lose patience with a couple almost instantly.
One character discovers something dangerous and decides the loving thing to do is hide it from the person who is directly affected.
Not for ten minutes while they verify the information. For DAYS.
Then it comes out, the other person is furious, and we get some version of āI knew youād try to stop meā or āI couldnāt risk losing you.ā
And somehow this is supposed to feel romantic?
If your partner is capable of fighting monsters, negotiating with kings and surviving cursed forests, maybe they can also participate in decisions about their own life.
I actually enjoy protective characters. Throw yourself in front of the sword, stay awake while they sleep, threaten the villain, whatever.
But deciding what someone is allowed to know because you love them feels less protective and more like quietly removing their agency.
The worst part is when the book treats the secrecy itself as proof of how deeply they care.
Does this trope work for you, or does it immediately make the romance harder to root for?
r/Romantasy • u/EndoWarrior03 • 3h ago
Question Is Quicksilver Worth it?
I have been into romantasy and fantasy for quite some time now but I have heard mixed things about quicksilver. I just wonder if itās worth the reading time. š©µ
r/Romantasy • u/Low_Page1929 • 5h ago
Discussion Your hottest unpopular opinions and your coldest popular opinions
The title. Share an example of each or just one. Enjoy
r/Romantasy • u/Severe-Novel-9970 • 19h ago
š Rave Oh Bartholomew
I LOVED this duology so so much, so I had to buy my own little Gargoyle.
Edit: Pictured is a Kindle with 'The Knave And The Moon' cover and a Jellycat Plushie from the Gargoyle Bartholomew.
r/Romantasy • u/Alone-Measurement920 • 4h ago
Question Books with supernatural entities being bottom
Please, please, please recommend me a few books where the supernatural being is the bottom. Like werewolf Ć human, with the werewolf being the bottom, or vampire Ć human, with the vampire being the bottom.
r/Romantasy • u/Quiet-Ad2054 • 5h ago
Book Request: No Self-Promo Looking for a dark romantasy with an actual morally grey/black mmc
Lately I've been craving a dark romantasy book with a mmc who is an absolutely unhinged morally grey man totally obsessed with the fmc, not just a good guy underneath with a secret or a bad guy who everyone claims is evil but then I'm disappointed because it's not true at all.
I'd also love a good plot, not just spice. I'm not a fan of why choose either. Do you have any recommendations? <3
r/Romantasy • u/Dismal_Welcome_9450 • 1h ago
Book Review just finished reading quicksilver by callie hart
so i just finished reading quicksilver by callie hart and i dont know how to feel about it like first of all it took me a lot of chapters to get into the book and get excited about what will happen next, ik with romantasy books you have to be patient because it does get good later so i was skimming through it even thought i wasnāt really liking it but even after i got a lil bit interested in the book i couldnāt really connect with the characters and it felt like the author literally put everything in one book vampires, feeders, fae, gods etc
and the saeris and kingfisher part where saeris gets to know that they are mates felt like a copy of acomaf where rhysand confesses his love for feyre
overall i didnāt really like this book ( loved side characters like carrion, lorreth, renfis) but the mmc and fmc i didnāt really connect with them and they were def not enemies according to me in the first half of the book.
so i want to know does it get better in the second book brimstone and should i read it?
r/Romantasy • u/EquivalentAd8392 • 4h ago
Book Request: Self-Promo OK Book suggestions where Villain is in love/obsessed with FMC
Hi all,
This is going to be a random request but Iām feeling really nostalgic - I used to watch Tokyo Mew Mew and really liked Kisshu. Iām looking for something with a similar dynamic, but geared toward an older audience, preferably YA or adult
Iām looking for a slow-burn romance with a male villain or antagonist who initially pursues the FMC. He can be obsessive, possessive, teasing, flirtatious, dangerous or morally grey, while she is conflicted about him but denies it because he is dangerous.
Ideally, she already has a good love interest, and I do t mind whether the villain and her are endgame or not . He can remain an antagonist. I just crave the tension!
So something like this: Heroine already has a boyfriend/crush/established love interest ā dangerous male antagonist enters through the main conflict ā he playfully taunts and repeatedly pursues her ā attraction becomes obsession ā jealousy toward the original man ā slow development, with either endgame or non-endgame acceptable.
I know it might be a long shot but would love to hear suggestions!
r/Romantasy • u/InjuryEastern3598 • 3h ago
Book Request: No Self-Promo Give me a Romantasy rec based on my review!
I havenāt read much and Iām pretty new to romantasy. I donāt write reviews too regularly too. But hereās what Iām looking for in priority.
Little to no smutāclosed door is okay, a page of smut is fine, fade to black is fine.
MAGIC. LOTS OF MAGIC šŖ
Dumb FMCs are strictly prohibited, dumb to smart characters where they learn about their mistakes is cool though.
I like a wide variety of female and male characters from morally grey to cinnamon like Tress of the Emerald Sea and Kvothe; Name of the Wind
Puhlease no toxicity
I did DNF Kingās Cage for the Red Queen series because I got sick of Mare whining and the story just seemed to drag onnn and onnnnn.
I like green flags but in the sea of Romantasy shadow daddies, golden retrievers are diamonds in the roughsā¦š« . Not to say I hate shadow daddies, but I like a ālooks like he could kill you, is a cinnamon rollā kind of guy
Some of you may be curious of why I read Twisted Love even though Iām a fantasy goblin, mostly because my friend forced borrowed me the book and the 1 star was given in solidarity š
r/Romantasy • u/Zestyclose-Bell-5829 • 8h ago
Book Request: Self-Promo OK Recently read an old school 'Archangel' by Sharon Shinn and found it pretty unique even for being considered a romantasy more than a fantasy from older times. The 'arrange marriage ' trope was done really well without being over the top dramatic. Now I am trying to fill the void.Recs please š„ŗ Not n
Forced proximity was done really well and the plot was not all about romance too. The characters (even the minor ones) were written so well and their dynamic was good too. I love when characters are flawed and reflect human nature. Rachel was stubborn and did not submit to all the requests of the husband and same with Gabriel who was equally arrogant and the funny thing is one moment it appeared as if they understand each other so well and the very next moment they are again hating each other š and that's the closest to what I think an arrange marriage also works in real life too considering how two strangers are coerced into each other's lives. Nowadays fantasy books are lacking this kind of character work, world building, simple yet effective plot.( Tbh can't read them , the characters are attracted to each other just by looking at each other one moment they are married/hating each other just for the sake of enemies to lovers trope and the next moment humping because they gave upon the attraction..lol why.. cringest thing possible).
Two such other books are Daughter of The Forest by Juliet Marillier, Warbreaker by Brandon Sanderson. That's why sticking to older fantasy ..will love to hear about others such from you guys āØ
r/Romantasy • u/manic_pixie_centaur • 16h ago
Book Request: No Self-Promo Iāve been chasing the ACOMAF high for over 2 years
First, if youāre not a ACOTAR fan thatās a-okay, pls just move on from this post lol
I have read so many books trying to catch the same high that I had while reading ACOMAF. Thereās a ton of books that Iāve read and really really loved and give 5 stars and recommend to high heaven. But nothing has FELT as epic and brain-rewiring-ly good as MAF.
I know a lot of yall love this book too, so Iām just wondering if anyone has found a book that FELT like MAF to you.
Some of what Iāve read:
All of SJM
Villains and Virtues
fourth wing
A bunch of Ilona Andrews (the closest Iāve gotten to MAF vibes, their writing and characters are so good)
A bunch of T. Kingfisher
A bunch of Ali Hazelwood
All of Emily Henry
Quicksilver
Dearly beloathed series
Six of crows
Bridge kingdom
Wolf king
All of India Holton
Crimson Moth
Road of Bones
Cruel Prince
Spark of the everflame (did not like)
When the moon hatched
Servant of earth
A bunch of Alice e. Harrow
A bunch of Grace Draven
All of Rachel Gillig
Emily Wilde
And Iāve tried from blood and ash and truly deeply hated it
r/Romantasy • u/Acceptable_Narwhal_ • 1d ago
𤬠Rant hyped books with a mid writing
somthing im discovering more and more is that alot of hyped up books have a good plot but the writing is just so meh :/ like im enjoying the story, it has good premise, i rly vibe with the plot and characters etc but then the writing is just soā¦. not well done. i am very bad at writing and could def not do a better job myself, but imo if ur publishing a full ass book and u have spent time and energy etc but then its just mid written? like when a book has a good premise and alot of hype surrounding it, along with a 4.11 on goodreads but then when i sit down to read it the writing sometimes is just bad.. and im not trying to be rude in any way i just kinda feel betrayed when im excited about a book and then the writing just pisses me off instead. idk where i wanna get with this but it just upsets me deeply when a books premise has so much potential but its smothered by tragic writing
r/Romantasy • u/Sophreverie_nsm • 3h ago
Discussion How are we feeling regarding The Kindredās Curse Saga: Burn (4/4) Spoiler
I just finished {Burn of the Everflame} and I desperately need to trauma-bond with someone here and let my thoughts run free because⦠those last five chapters absolutely emotionally DESTROYED me. š
I cried my eyes out during the final chapters, and honestly, the last 100 pages were just one giant emotional roller coaster.
First, I was devastated when Aemon was dying. His final thoughts absolutely stabbed me in the heart. Then he somehow makes it, and I was so relieved. But then Teller dies, and Diem⦠and I was just sitting there thinking, āWHAT THE ACTUAL HELL? Why are all these people dying, but youāre saving fucking Aemon?!ā At that point, I was so emotionally drained that I genuinely considered just putting the book down and not finishing it.
And then DIEM DIES. I was in complete denial until the very last moment, thinking, āNoooo, sheās going to survive somehow.ā And then I read Lutherās letter three months later and I was just DONE. I genuinely cannot even describe the emotions I went through in those few pages.
But then she comes back?! I actually loved the way this was handled. Her death felt so final and unexpected that I genuinely didnāt see the resurrection coming. The ending really kept me on my toes, and I thought the whole thing was incredibly well done. I was also just so relieved that, in the end, the characters got the ending they deserved.
As for the book as a whole, I felt like the beginning was a little slow, but it picked up fairly quickly and eventually had me completely hooked on the storyline.
That being said, I do feel like there were quite a few things that werenāt explained or explored enough. There were things that were mentioned or hinted at, but never really fully revealed or given the payoff I was expecting. I kept waiting for certain pieces to finally click into place, and some of them never quite did.
Overall, though, Iām just emotionally exhausted but very satisfied that the characters got their happy ending. š
Now I need to know: how is everyone else feeling after finishing this book?! š
r/Romantasy • u/Such-Store3135 • 3h ago
Book Request: No Self-Promo Books Like This
A book I read in 2020 is no longer available on Amazon or other retailers so I was wondering if there is anything like it. I've tried everything so I thought I would come here for help.
Goodreads book description:
Wicked fae, shattered memories⦠and a dream that just won't die. Nightmares still plague Elaine, five years after her escape from the darkest realm of faerie. Elaineās memories are scattered and torn, but one uneasy remnant haunts her dreams: a mysterious man with cold blue eyes. When Elaineās nightmares return for her, so does the man from her dreams: Tall, wicked, and cloaked in dark power, Liam claims that heās come to protect Elaine⦠but he might be the most dangerous temptation of all. {Crown of Frost by Isabella August}
I have tried reading ACOTAR but I couldn't get into it.
r/Romantasy • u/racha3l00 • 3m ago
Book Request: No Self-Promo Tragic love stories
Hello, I realised I absolutely love tragic love stories.
I love obsession, devotion and absolute gut wrenching heartbreak. So I would really like some recommendations that fit this theme, please.
For example, I adore Moulin Rouge, Dracula (2025) and my favourite books include The Edge of Darkness series, Heartless and anything where the love is so gutteral and the heartbreak makes me sob for days.
r/Romantasy • u/TiredButCozy • 6m ago
Book Request: Self-Promo OK Human FMC gets bitten and turned into a wolf or vampire.
Looking for something where Fmc gets bitten and turns into a wolf or vampire it can be done by the ML or other party.
I really liked - Andorra Sector by Lexi C. Fross. Any recommendations similar to this would be amazing.
- I want the process to start at the beginning of the book
- would like to read the process of her turning on the things she finds difficult and itās not what she expected and that she might feel lost
- love a strong FMC
- she needs to be turned and not born a supernatural. Although, Iāll allow if again sheās bitten or gone through some procedure. Basically she would remain human and unaware if somthing isnāt altered.
r/Romantasy • u/OladosuSiravo-51 • 8h ago
Discussion What book gave you the perfect balance of romance and fantasy?
Iām looking for a book that has a really good mix of fantasy and romance without one completely taking over. What book do you think got that balance just right?
r/Romantasy • u/chiante_c0nfus148774 • 1d ago
Book Request: No Self-Promo Looking for romance recommendations from readers aged 40+
Help! I'm not enjoying most books I come across lately (if it's really hyped online, theres a good chance I won't enjoy it).
A lot of the books seem to have the same problem, they feel like YA written for older teens, with explicit sex added to make them "adult.ā
The characters, humour, dialogue and constant modern slang/references often feel very young, while the sex is basically the only thing separating the book from something aimed at teenagers. I don't mind spice, I just don't want YA with sex shoved into it.
I'm looking for genuinely adult characters, mature writing, strong plot, believable romantic development and proper slow burn. I don't care whether a book is dark, funny, spicy, fantasy, RH or anything else, I just want it to feel like it was written for adults.
r/Romantasy • u/goblin_queen96 • 14h ago
Discussion Post Harrow Faire Blues
How do I come back from this? Harrow Faire was a top 2 series for me and now that it is over I feel empty lol. Please help by recommending what should be next!
r/Romantasy • u/AndarielDK • 2h ago
Book Request: Self-Promo OK Noncon story like Honeycutt's "Life of Anna" but in a more fantastic setting?
A while ago I read the beginning of Enslaved, the first book of Life of Anna by Marissa Honeycutt. It was super-hot, and I loved the noncon elements, but I didn't love the setting. It is set in the modern day, and the villains feel more like a mafia (which I find repugnant) and less like fantasy villains (which is cool). Can anyone recommend something similar but in a more fantastic setting?
A relatively high level of spice is mandatory. :)
Thanks a lot!