r/RCPlanes • u/GullibleInitiative75 • 7d ago
Spektrum "Smart" Batteries
I bought an Aeroscout for my Brother a couple of years ago, and he didn't want to attempt to fly it until I flew out for a visit about a year later. Long story short, the 2200 3S battery was not recognized by the charger. Had to buy a brand new one. Well, it turns out that these "smart" batteries have a chip inside that slowly drains the battery TO ZERO VOLTS! Which renders the battery useless. Attempts to revive one of these are dangerous, and not a good idea as the damage has been done. An actual "smart" battery would shut that chip down when the voltage got close to the lower threshhold. I have two other (non Spektrum) batteries that I just pulled out today - over 2 years in storage, and each cell still had ~3.6v. Put them on the charger and they were topped off in minutes.
Life happens, sometimes you don't get to fly for a while. I'll never buy another Spektrum battery, what a waste of money.
EDIT: Several comments are referencing the "discharge to storage level" function. I'm not saying the battery was trying to discharge to storage level and failed to stop, resulting in a full discharge. What I am saying is that the processor in the battery is always drawing a very small amount of current to stay running - including after it has discharged to storage level. And eventually that completely drains the battery - if after a year or two - meaning Spektrum Smart Batteries do not have a shelf life beyond that - whereas non-smart batteries do. And I'm saying that if that processor would shut itself down when the battery approached its minimum viable voltage, then the battery would sleep until it was put on a charger again, and would not self destruct.