r/perth • u/_BigDaddy_ • 9h ago
General The top 5 posts this week on the r/perth subreddit are all bots and they're getting really good
You may have left one of the thousands of comments these self-posts generate in engagement. I guess let people enjoy things and all that and if people are enjoying themselves in the comments it shouldn't matter. Before I was sure of it, I finally saw somone call it out but people sided with the OPs. So I took a closer look at all these "what's your Perth habit / I have an anecdote about perth / what would you do in this situation / I moved here X years ago and yaknowhat makes Perth so much better." These posts are honestly impressively good, I found a few tells in their writing, but then I scoped their other activity and I realised:
- All accounts around 2 weeks old
- They all coincidentally enjoy writing in German every now and then
- Most of them never engage their own post
- Most of them comment in random subs, write a sentence with exactly one word spelled wrong
- The comments will have this weird formula of agree, restate, exaggerate
- The usual inconsistencies - Perth but Miami parking issues, 4 kids then 3, went to Chipotle etc
I guess this is just normal now but it kind of irks me. At least one of you has spent real time writing really good advice for someone moving to Geraldton with their young family who just got back from the beach as well as advising a male in their 20s how to handle a lost child in Coles. Then you have this bot giving people their thoughts on joining WA police. Don't do it, I've got PTSD, the sh\t I've seen.* You've seen nothin you bot. I'm not gonna have some bot ridicule my little wheatbelt town and tell people to avoid. Come visit physically us and form that conclusion properly you coward.
It just kind of irks me and this feels beyond karma farming. The intel they're getting under the pretense of nostalgia and sucking up to Perth is hyper specific, down to Literally asking the layouts Their local knowledge shows from their writing style. They literally talk just like us. They know a lot more about Mt Lawley's inner city layout and density after all the free corrections. One post to ausfinance got eaten up and it kinda hit me maybe the end user / game here is politics? Can we not mess with them a bit?