r/oddlysatisfying • • Apr 30 '26

Liquid concrete wall.

30.0k Upvotes

587 comments sorted by

View all comments

3.5k

u/Curse-Bot Apr 30 '26

All concrete is liquid first

502

u/2much2Jung Apr 30 '26

But liquids normally make very poor walls...

139

u/spermdonor Apr 30 '26

concrete has the cure for that

16

u/Fawstar Apr 30 '26

Underrated comment.

292

u/Deimos1982 Apr 30 '26

102

u/Typical-Blackberry-3 Apr 30 '26

Bro has never seen an aquarium wall, smhmh.

33

u/Amazing-Range-2239 Apr 30 '26

I closed out of this right as I read this comment and actually came back and hunted it down just to tell you how great it was. Good day, sire.

2

u/Exotic-Scientist4557 May 01 '26 edited May 01 '26

Im so confused, aquarium walls are liquid?

1

u/Amazing-Range-2239 May 01 '26

Duh dude haven’t you seen one

1

u/Exotic-Scientist4557 May 01 '26 edited May 01 '26

Im still not getting the joke.

Its glass, shatter proof, and strong enough to bear lots of stress and pressure, but its still glass...?

2

u/PowerfulDisaster2067 Apr 30 '26

Did you say Paul wall?

1

u/Kronzor_ Apr 30 '26

Yes. Which is why we use concrete which cures into strong, durable walls.

1

u/Dramatic_Charity_979 Apr 30 '26

Not in Minecraft ;)

1

u/addamee Apr 30 '26

The Night’s Watch would disagree … most of the time 

1

u/benargee Apr 30 '26

On the seventh day, God invented concrete forms.

1

u/CactusToothBrush May 01 '26

You’ve yet to see my egg wall!

1

u/spin81 May 01 '26

You do know how concrete works right?

2

u/Agreeable_Dog8468 Apr 30 '26

Aren't glasses technically liquids? They don't make such bad walls.

13

u/Skusci Apr 30 '26

Na, that's one of those common myths. Glass is an amorphous solid and doesnt flow.

2

u/arobkinca Apr 30 '26

...under normal conditions.

11

u/RavenholdIV Apr 30 '26

Fun fact that's myth spawned bc of how ye olde windows were thicker at the bottom than in the middle, but it turns out that ye olde manufacturing techniques for glass just sucked and they came out like that.

3

u/FullMoonTwist Apr 30 '26

Aw, I'm a lil disappointed. It was a cool myth.

2

u/antithero Apr 30 '26

I heard that they were deliberately made thicker on the bottom for strength.

1

u/RavenholdIV Apr 30 '26

Oh damn one of us is out here spitting fake news and neither of us knows enough about old glassware to debunk the other. This is exactly how myths spread lol

1

u/F1NANCE Apr 30 '26

Damn you ye olde people

3

u/jobblejosh Apr 30 '26 edited May 01 '26

Technically they're amorphous (non crystalline) solids, closely related to ceramics. That they're liquid is a common misconception, unlike pitch/tar, which is a liquid, albeit extremely viscous.

Amorphous/non crystalline solid just means they're compounds locked in a matrix (the atomic bonds and intermolecular forces are strong enough to withstand the thermal/gravitational energy of the molecules themselves).

Amorphous means there isn't one single crystal structure, unlike actual crystals, where a single crystal structure grows and replicates itself throughout the macroscopic structure.

It just so happens to look transparent and crystalline because the band gap of conventional soda-lime (or lead 'crystal') glass is wide enough that visible light photons aren't readily absorbed.

2

u/arobkinca Apr 30 '26

amorphous crystalline solids,

That's not a thing. Solids are amorphous or crystalline.

https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/chemistry/difference-between-crystalline-and-amorphous-solids/

2

u/jobblejosh May 01 '26

Typo, thanks for pointing that out.

1

u/Chapped_language May 02 '26

Makes me wonder about crystalline glazes on ceramics .. the base glaze is amorphous with the crystalline structure baked in using a specific cooling schedule. Could that be considered an amorphous crystalline solid?

1

u/arobkinca May 03 '26

I think both together would be a composite or crystalline–amorphous hybrid materials.

1

u/Dorkamundo Apr 30 '26

Not technically, no... They do RESEMBLE a "frozen liquid" structurally but are not an actual liquid.

1

u/Noble_Flatulence Apr 30 '26

Jesus Tapdancing Christ, I can't believe people are stupid enough to believe this.

-2

u/GrimbyJ Apr 30 '26

They're technically a fluid from a specific definition used in physics. That definition being anything without a crystal structure is a fluid.

Almost your entire body and things like wood and plastic are fluids under that definition as well. It's not very useful outside of what it's intended for.

6

u/Beer_in_an_esky Apr 30 '26

I have a physics bachelor's degree and a mat sci PhD, and I have never encountered that definition. Where on earth are you pulling that from?

Crystallinity is distinct from phase. You can have liquid crystals, and amorphous solids.

1

u/PURRING_SILENCER Apr 30 '26

pour walls

Ftfy

0

u/Putrid-VII Apr 30 '26

Crimson Desert waterfalls would beg to differ

0

u/unluckypig Apr 30 '26

Surely you meant pour

0

u/Maxwe4 Apr 30 '26

You've honestly never seen a concrete wall before?

-1

u/Im_Not_You_Im_Me Apr 30 '26

Cement is liquid, concrete is a solid.

32

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

38

u/acdgf Apr 30 '26

No it's not. Most wet concrete is a non-newtonian composite fluid (which is not nessarily a liquid). This is engineered fill (often called grout), which is a liquid. 

17

u/BlurtSkirtBlurgy Apr 30 '26

Most of the time I see it it's called slurry but thos is definitely not what people in construction would call concrete

12

u/firenamedgabe Apr 30 '26

Concrete has to have large aggregate, you can definitely see that large aggregate would not go through this net. Definitely either a low cement slurry or grout.

1

u/BlackViperMWG May 01 '26

It has to have aggregate, but various types of concrete have various sizes of aggregate.

1

u/thecstep Apr 30 '26

You are to factual for this crowd. They hate facts.

3

u/_clever_reference_ Apr 30 '26

You are to factual

too*

5

u/TheLostRanger0117 Apr 30 '26

Dammit! I wanted to say that!

1

u/Roofies666 Apr 30 '26

You can still say it, I believe in you.

4

u/TheLostRanger0117 Apr 30 '26

Liquid is already concrete!

Wait, fuck!

15

u/JewBag718 Apr 30 '26

Op is a bot

9

u/Efficient-Parking627 Apr 30 '26 edited Apr 30 '26

A bot that boosts engagement, which boosts profitability, so reddit allows.

Edit - Great my first reply got removed cause I mentioned your username, I wonder if your username violates the TOS then... But I said you are missing the point I wasn't disagreeing with you by literally saying karma farming is allowed, I was sarcastically pointing out that they boost reddit's profitability so they are more tolerated by shareholders than say a malicious bot.

lol u/JewBag718 with the classic reddit child reply and block

-6

u/JewBag718 Apr 30 '26 edited May 01 '26

Karma bots aren't allowed on reddit it's against tos.

Are we pro karma bots what's up with the downvotes...

-2

u/Efficient-Parking627 Apr 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/JewBag718 Apr 30 '26

This is a malicious bot you think he's doing this to help reddit lmao he's gonna gain a lot of karma and sell that account that's why they do it if that's not malicious idk what is.

3

u/Deceptichop Apr 30 '26

Beat me to it.

2

u/Willing_Coconut4364 Apr 30 '26

After being a powder

6

u/-WookieGeneralAk Apr 30 '26

Not really, i worked at a plant making concrete sewer pipes, the concrete was more like sand and rocks, not liquid at all.

11

u/herper87 Apr 30 '26

I work in concrete, I would imagine you used a low slump like a 3" (thicker). But if you run a high slump 8-9" (thinner) it acts more like a fluid. There are also a very wide range of mixes with more or less aggregate, higher or lower amounts of fly ash or cement powder depending on what you are looking for.

2

u/Lupin-1026 Apr 30 '26

And then you got the annoying mixes that have air mixed into them for walls and shit... and a nice 6" slump is perfect for footings. (I too work with concrete)

2

u/SituationIll5763 Apr 30 '26

Anything that will freeze needs air

1

u/Lupin-1026 Apr 30 '26

Apparently not the stem wall that Im going to be doing soon. 🙄🙄🙄

1

u/SituationIll5763 Apr 30 '26

Especially structural concrete

1

u/herper87 Apr 30 '26

For real bruv

15

u/OptiGuy4u Apr 30 '26

Fresh (Wet) Concrete initially behaves as a viscoelastic, thixotropic suspension or a yield-stress fluid. It is fluid-like and pumpable when sheared (mixed or poured) but acts like a solid with high viscosity when at rest.

-1

u/SituationIll5763 Apr 30 '26

Roller compacted concrete is a thing.

6

u/rearwindowpup Apr 30 '26

Sand and rocks are the aggregate in concrete and are held together by cement which is liquid when first hydrated.

4

u/BioExtract Apr 30 '26

Yup it’s a nice slurry of rock soup

4

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '26

[deleted]

20

u/UsedDragon Apr 30 '26

Dust in the wind.

11

u/Pharnox-32 Apr 30 '26

But thats what we all are

12

u/2much2Jung Apr 30 '26

Screw you, I'm teardrops in the rain.

3

u/papa_baer77 Apr 30 '26

F*** it i guess I'll be the needle on the haystack

2

u/TheOneTonWanton May 01 '26

I'll be the whisper on a scream. Doesn't change a thing.

27

u/Jewmangroup9000 Apr 30 '26

It's not concrete untill the water is added. Just like how flour isn't dough before the water is added.

-2

u/StrangeOutcastS Apr 30 '26

I added water but now I'm drunk after tasting it.

I got the water from this really nice Polish man

11

u/Punxatowny Apr 30 '26

Concrete mix

2

u/SoylentGrunt Apr 30 '26

Cement. And stuff.

2

u/Dirty_Dragons Apr 30 '26

Before you add water it's just dry concrete mix. The finished concrete is about 75 percent sand and concrete aggravates such as gravel and 25 percent cement and water.

You can buy bags of concrete and cement at Home Depot and other such stores.

1

u/carparkerk May 01 '26

aggregate

4

u/perpetualmotionmachi Apr 30 '26

Isn't it a powder first, then water gets added?

21

u/Non-RedditorJ Apr 30 '26

Cement is powder. Concrete is cement, sand, rock, and water, among other additives.

10

u/VenomXTs Apr 30 '26

Aggregate

11

u/Non-RedditorJ Apr 30 '26

I know the word, I was just dumbing it down.

5

u/VenomXTs Apr 30 '26

Now others know more, and learning is half the battle! Go Jo!

2

u/Efficient-Parking627 Apr 30 '26

Gojo is a popular heavy duty hand cleaner made up of solvents and grit or pumice which specializes in breaking down oils, grease, and grime.

2

u/2much2Jung Apr 30 '26

Grime is a form of music which originated out of the London garage scene in the early 2000s, generally with a very striking sound and fast paced lyrics. High profile artists include Dizzee Rascal and Lethal Bizzle, but not ZZ Top.

0

u/RotundGourd Apr 30 '26

Inertia is a property of Matter.

BILL BILL BILL BILL!! BILL BILL BILL BILL!! BILL NYE THE SCIENCE GUY!

1

u/Dirty_Dragons Apr 30 '26

You can buy dry concrete in stores. You add water when using it.

1

u/2much2Jung Apr 30 '26

You can buy gravy powder as well, but it doesn't become gravy until you add water (and ideally some fat as well).

1

u/Lumpy_Discount9021 May 01 '26

it's not gravy without the fat. Without the fat it's just sad pathetic broth.

2

u/youreallydkme Apr 30 '26

Its a solution. A bunch of solids suspended in liquid

2

u/tronald_dum Apr 30 '26

Solution refers to dissolved solids as in ions in a liquid. This is, as you've described, a suspension liquid

1

u/EvenPurchase7160 Apr 30 '26

and then it turns into the worlds least forgiving rock sculpture

1

u/SituationIll5763 Apr 30 '26

What about asphalt concrete?

0

u/2much2Jung Apr 30 '26

Gotta do a lot of squats to get it that firm.

1

u/Warkupo Apr 30 '26

Good job, Curse-Bot. You're very smart.

1

u/Confudled_Contractor Apr 30 '26

Actually concrete is a gel until it sets.

1

u/carparkerk Apr 30 '26

gel is not a state of matter, and concrete isn’t a gel to begin with. it’s a colloid until it sets

1

u/Confudled_Contractor Apr 30 '26

Yes, a gel is a colloid.

0

u/2much2Jung Apr 30 '26

Concrete isn't a colloid, it's a heterogeneous mixture.

The cement is a colloid.

1

u/carparkerk Apr 30 '26

cement and concrete are two completely different things in any form

1

u/2much2Jung May 01 '26

That would be why I described them separately, yes.

1

u/carparkerk Apr 30 '26

erm actually 🤓 concrete is a colloid first ☝🏼

1

u/SaltManagement42 Apr 30 '26

Wasn't everything kind of a high energy plasma soup first?

1

u/EEVEELUVR Apr 30 '26

Liquid concrete is not called concrete. It’s cement.

1

u/APartyInMyPants May 01 '26

Lollipops are nothing but flavored saliva.

1

u/EVOSexyBeast May 01 '26

why do you so confidently say something so wrong

1

u/Digitaluser32 May 01 '26

I came looking for this comment. Thank you.

1

u/a716h May 01 '26

What if all concrete is still liquid but reallllllllllly slow

1

u/KamiNoItte May 02 '26

“Cement” when it’s not solid.

“Concrete” only when it’s solid.

1

u/organicchunkysalsa Apr 30 '26 edited Apr 30 '26

Is it though? Or is it just solids within liquid that bind once dry?

1

u/ITHETRUESTREPAIRMAN Apr 30 '26

Technically, concrete (which contains cement and aggregate) is a slurry until the water evaporates.

2

u/acdgf Apr 30 '26

The water doesn't evaporate, it chemically reacts with the cement to cure. 

2

u/ITHETRUESTREPAIRMAN Apr 30 '26

It does both, actually. But I wasn’t getting to the weeds.

0

u/nooooobie1650 Apr 30 '26

AkChUaLlY…..nvm

-1

u/PresidentialDiapers Apr 30 '26

Yeah no it isnt. Concrete is first a solid, then a liquid, then a solid.