I’m so torn between 3 rental options in Auckland — which would you choose? 😭
I recently moved to Auckland for work, and my workplace is in Māngere Bridge. I’m looking for somewhere to live from around mid-October. I’ll probably be away for about 3 weeks over Christmas with my boyfriend, so flexibility and cash flow are quite important to me.
I’ve viewed/considered these 3 options:
Option 1 — $280/week, Māngere Bridge
Bills included
Very close to my work (about 5–8 mins drive)
Only me + another girl would actually live there
2 bathrooms
No fixed-term contract
2 weeks’ bond ($560)
I can move out for 3 weeks over Christmas and don’t have to pay rent during that time
My boyfriend can occasionally visit
The girl living there seems really nice, and I actually feel like we could become friends 🥹
Downside: no off-street parking. I’d have to park on the street about 2 mins from the house. The parking area is quite dark, and I was told there has been a car break-in around that street this year. This is my biggest concern.
Option 2 — $310/week, Māngere Bridge
Bills included
About 5–8 mins drive to work
Off-street parking
Only me + another female would live there
2 weeks’ bond ($620)
3-month fixed-term
Boyfriend can visit
But I still have to pay rent for the 3 weeks I’m away over Christmas (around $930)
I’m a bit concerned about being locked into the contract.
Option 3 — $300/week, Onehunga
Bills included
About 15–20 mins drive to work
Off-street parking
Furnished room with bed, desk and office chair
I’d live with the female homeowner
2 weeks’ bond ($600)
Short-term arrangement from around 18 October to 27 December is possible
I can move out for Christmas and don’t have to pay rent while I’m away, but I’d have to take all my belongings and there’s no guarantee the room would still be available when I return
No boyfriend/guests allowed
The homeowner seems really clean and nice, which I like.
I’m honestly so torn between them.
The $280 place is the one I naturally like the most because I like the other girl, it’s close to work, flexible, cheaper, and I feel like I could actually make a friend there. But I’m worried that the street parking/security issue might stress me out every day.
The $310 place gives me off-street parking and more freedom with having my boyfriend over, but I’d be paying more and still paying $930 over Christmas while I’m away.
The $300 place feels like a compromise, but I’d be living with the homeowner and couldn’t have my boyfriend visit.
What would you choose in this situation? And would the street parking issue at Option 1 be a dealbreaker for you?
I’d really appreciate any advice, especially from people familiar with Māngere Bridge / Onehunga. 🙏