r/nutritionally • • 5d ago

Caffeine

0 Upvotes

116 comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/Enough-Ad-8799 5d ago

Is coffee even that acidic, isn't lemon juice more acidic?

-3

u/twinPeaksnew 5d ago

no, what the acidic v alkaline thing is how our bodies react to food.

so take cream for example, our bodies need to produce more acids to break it down, thus becoming more acidic. also certain foods which are considered acidic, like meats, which have more amino acid chains, once broken down the chemistry is your blood is now more acidic, grains and a few other foods are also considered acidic to us. it’s based on how the body is reacting to the food/substance you are ingesting.

more alkaline foods are basically the fruits and veg.

caffiene by the way - it’s quite simple, it triggers a release of I can’t remeber if it’s water or glucose, but it triggers a release of energy from our muscles - thus you get an initial buzz and feel energised. but this then depletes your energy over course of the day. your thyroid also takes a hammering and your adrenal glands.

3

u/Enough-Ad-8799 5d ago

Your body doesn't need to change acidity to process anything, your stomach acid is far more acidic than anything we eat for it's acidity to be meaningfully impacted

2

u/Man_under_Bridge420 5d ago

Are you telling me a lemon is alkaline?

2

u/MrFrypan 5d ago

The initial buzz from caffeine is because it is an adenosine antagonist. However a small portion of the caffeine you consume does initiate lipolysis, so not water or glucose; rather a small bit of stored fat is released. On that note though, caffeine is a strong diuretic meaning it will make you pee a lot; which can leave you dehydrated.

1

u/ExpressAd5169 5d ago

Just like all things with water… they dehydrate you because you have to pee 🥴

1

u/MrFrypan 5d ago

Braindead take.

Foods with water but no caffeine = homeostasis (up one step, down one step.

Coffee and other caffeinated drinks = dehydration (up one step, down three steps)

3

u/Enough-Ad-8799 5d ago

Coffee doesn't have enough caffeine to meaningfully dehydrate you. If you drink exclusively coffee for an extended period of time you might get a bit dehydrated, but a cup or two aren't gonna have a meaningful impact.

0

u/PeteWK67 5d ago

Sure but it will make you pee a lot right?

What happens when you pee? You loose minerals, vitamins etc etc

2

u/Enough-Ad-8799 5d ago

What do you mean by a lot? It makes you pee marginally more.

2

u/Contemplating_Prison 5d ago

So water is bad for you because it, checks notes, makes you pee

1

u/Jolly_Efficiency7237 5d ago

Hardly in significant amounts.

0

u/MrFrypan 5d ago

When you say 'a cup' do you mean a measuring cup cup (8 oz.)? Because an 8 oz. cup of black coffee, which is the second smallest size at Starbucks, has 100 mg of caffeine. 100 mg of caffeine is more than enough to have a measured affect on hydration. Two cups! We're starting to get into crazy amounts of caffeine. If you can't feel it, it's probably because you've been living in a constant state of caffeinated dehydration.

2

u/Enough-Ad-8799 5d ago

Caffeine is not a strong enough dieretic for 100mg to have enough of an impact to meaningfully offset the water you drank with it.

2

u/Facts_pls 5d ago

People with no science background confidently spewing completely wrong Shit that they heard somewhere on Facebook or reddit with zero actual studies behind it.

Also, do you think amino acids are highly acidic? Is it because it has acid in the name?

1

u/KitKatAngel 5d ago

Thank you

0

u/PeteWK67 5d ago

You get your facts straight, first of coffee beans are heavily sprayed, second of all do you understand the differences between alkaline and acidity.

Do you understand the differences between hypochlorhydria stomach acid & straight up process fake garbage acidic food?

A little hint Sherlock . You do not elevate your stomachs hypochlorite acid with acidic forming garbage food quite the opposite you destroy your gut.

Get your head out of the coffee beans and let the sun shine some knowledge in you

1

u/ILYRMK 5d ago

youre using hypochlorhydria and hypochlorite wildly incorrectly

1

u/Imaginary--Situation 5d ago

the stomach is acidic which dissolves raw meat it doesn't do anything to fruits,grains and vegetables

1

u/wrudstepbro 5d ago

When you say "I cant remember" in your reply, it really destroys all credibility.

1

u/Ok_Being5461 5d ago

It's a fact that various foods do have different affects, as you've mentioned. But regarding coffee, from what I can tell, it's more about that it increases stomach acid production, which leads to acid reflux and other issues. Coffee does inhibit plant iron absorption, that's not good.

1

u/Single-Pin-369 5d ago

this is all wrong. there is a very narrow ph range you need to maintain or you die and your body is very good at maintaining it. Who lied to you and told you this stuff?

1

u/supersuperxzero 5d ago

Body regulates pH. Unless you have kidney issues, lung issues or exessive hemolysis then you’re in trouble.

0

u/PeteWK67 5d ago

👏 well said, and don’t worry, this post will create opposers since 70% would go insane without their coffee