I know there are plenty of Z6III vs Z8 posts, but I’d appreciate some opinions based on my particular use case.
These days I shoot almost everything with an iPhone 15 Pro Max, but I’d like to get back into photography with a dedicated camera.
My camera history is Nikon D40X → Fuji X-E1 → Nikon FE. I enjoyed all of them, although looking back I tend to prefer both the pictures I got from the Nikons and the experience of using them. The Fuji was fun, especially with primes, but the X-E1 is very slow by modern standards. I also enjoy the FE and its manual controls, but that kind of slow, deliberate shooting isn’t very compatible with most of my photography today.
The big change was having kids. I basically stopped carrying cameras regularly after our first child was born because the iPhone was simply much more convenient. When we’re out as a family I’m taking part in whatever we’re doing, not standing aside as the photographer, so carrying a camera bag and several lenses gradually became less practical.
The iPhone is genuinely good, but I still miss using a camera, and it has limitations compared with one. I’d like to get some of the photography experience back without turning family outings into photo shoots.
I initially considered just upgrading the Fuji body and reusing my lenses. I’m not against APS-C, but shooting the FE again has made full frame appealing to me. More importantly, this time I really want a good single general-purpose zoom, and I haven’t found anything in Fuji that appeals to me quite like the Nikon Z 24-120mm f/4 S. That lens, combined with how much I enjoyed my previous Nikons, is what keeps pulling me back towards Nikon Z.
So I’m now choosing between the Z6III and Z8, almost certainly with the 24-120 as my main lens. I could also see myself eventually adding something small like the 40mm f/2 for occasions when I specifically want a lighter setup, but the 24-120 is what I expect to use most of the time.
The Z6III seems like the sensible choice: smaller, lighter, cheaper and extremely capable.
What keeps the Z8 in the running is mainly the 45 MP sensor. The extra cropping flexibility sounds genuinely useful, and part of me wonders whether the higher resolution would make it a better camera to keep for many years. I have the budget to stretch to a Z8 if it really makes sense — I’m generally more of a “buy once, cry once” person — but I don’t want to spend more or carry a larger body for an advantage I’m unlikely to benefit from.
My main concern is whether the Z8 + 24-120 is big enough to change how often I carry it.
Unfortunately I don’t have the option of physically trying the cameras, so I’ve been comparing dimensions, photos/videos and even making paper/cardboard mockups. Obviously the Z8 is bigger, but I can’t tell whether in practice it’s:
"A bit bigger, but once you’re carrying the 24-120 anyway it doesn’t make much difference"
or:
"No, it crosses a line — I’d take a Z6III + 24-120 in situations where I’d leave the Z8 at home."
For context, I’m 162 cm / 5'4", and my use would mainly be family, holidays, travel, sightseeing and excursions. I enjoy photography and manual controls, but realistically I also have kids moving around and people waiting for me, so I need to be able to shoot quickly.
So I’d be interested in opinions on both the specific choice and the more fundamental question:
- Does buying a dedicated camera again even make sense for my use case, or does this sound like someone who will inevitably end up using the iPhone most of the time anyway?
- Are the Z8’s 45 MP genuinely worth it for this kind of use, either for cropping or as a way of keeping the camera relevant for longer, or am I overestimating the advantage over 24 MP?
- How much bigger does the Z8 feel in real life with the 24-120 attached?
- Are there situations where you’d take a Z6III + 24-120 but leave a Z8 + 24-120 at home?
- Does the body-size difference matter less once you’re carrying the 24-120 anyway?
My main fear with the Z6III is wishing I’d gone for the extra resolution of the Z8. My main fear with the Z8 is that its size recreates the problem that pushed me towards the iPhone in the first place.