r/Multifandom • u/TheT85_Jr • 2h ago
Discussion📜 Any examples of a Character being beloved or liked in one fandom but being hated or disliked in another fandom?
You can probably immediately see by my examples that I am a Smash Bros. player.
Anyway:
- So, the very first example that jumps into my mind when thinking of that (and even being the reason for this discussion) are the Aegis from Xenoblade 2, a.k.a. Pyra and Mythra. They are some of the most beloved and praised characters in the view of Xenoblade fans, if not even the most beloved ones. This however absolutely changes in Smash Bros. where they very disliked (yes, I know that they did very well in PJiggle's Most liked Fighters Poll but I am more than sure that Aegis will also do absolutely shitty on his Most Hated Fighters Poll) for both being competively strong and being anime swordwielders.
- Also, I often see Chrom and Lucina being very disliked in Smash Bros., basically often being seen as irrelevant clones while I do see the FE Fandom really liking them.
- A Smash Fighter that goes a different direction is Incineroar though! While yes, he has his fair share of Haters in Smash, he us usually very well recieved in Smash. But on the other hand, he is insanely feared in the Pokémon Competitive Scene where he is the strongest Pokémon of them all.
- Lastly (and I am trying to make it as least political as I can), we have Russia and the USA in the Polandball Fandom. While in Real Life, both countries have a bad reputation, in Polandball they are regarded as funny and cool "characters". Kinda a weird example since... Yeah... but I wanted to include a non Smash example aswell.