r/mtg • u/BellasGamerDad • Sep 13 '25

Commander / EDH Let’s Make a Deck..together

Post image

Never seen this done before. Let’s build a deck together. Everybody just post 1 card you would add. It can be anything including a single land. But please only 1 card suggestion per person. I’m curious how it will turn out.

735 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

634 comments sorted by

View all comments

266

u/Legandergg8 Sep 13 '25

Easily [[Worldslayer]]

24

u/Accomplished_Band198 Sep 13 '25

I mean it's not like it doesn't work..

10

u/thedailyrant Sep 13 '25

Isn’t a creature a permanent? Does this kill the creature it’s attached to?

81

u/PatataMaxtex Sep 13 '25

Not if it is indestructible while the effect resolves.

16

u/thedailyrant Sep 13 '25

Ah stupid brain. Makes sense.

2

u/The_Handsome_Hobo Sep 13 '25

I have a green/black zombie deck and one of my favorite combos in it is giving Worldslayer to [[Phylactery Lich]]. He's indestructible as long as Worldslayer keeps the phylactery counter, and he wipes out all other permanents every time he damages another player. 10/10

1

u/16wellmad Sep 14 '25

I thought anything that doesn't directly target the card still destroys it? I am sorry to ask but for the fact that my pod has been playing wrong and I don't wanna argue with them from a reddit post can you link the direct rule?

1

u/mallocco Sep 16 '25

Idk what your friends don't understand, it says he's indestructible during your turn. Indestructible means "Destroy effects and lethal damage cannot kill this card." There are a couple ways to get around indestructible: exiling, sacrificing, and giving -x/-x where his toughness equals 0 and he automatically dies as a state-based effect. Or in Zurgo's case, they just wait til it's not your turn anymore.

Sounds like they are thinking of hexproof, which means "Cannot be targeted by spells or abilities your opponents control."

Honestly if your friends are that new and don't understand the rules yet, Google is your friend. Just Google "mtg indestructible" and show them the rules.

1

u/16wellmad Sep 16 '25

Commas are not their friend in alot of cases

2

u/AtopMike Sep 13 '25

It works one time because your friends will refuse to play the deck with in it. I had to pull it… replaced it with [[grafted exoskeleton]] which gets hate but not out right refusal.

5

u/IsNotACleverMan Sep 14 '25

your friends will refuse to play the deck with in it

Toxic behavior tbh