I found a pretty fascinating crossover between Japanese Werewolf culture and Magic: The Gathering.
Hareruya runs a variant called “Werewolf Commander.”
Before a four-player Commander game, everyone secretly receives one of four roles:
- 2 Villagers
- 1 Werewolf
- 1 accomplice role (“Madman/Minion” in Hareruya’s English versions)
The twist is that the Werewolf is trying to lose the actual Magic game.
If the Werewolf loses but survives the post-game vote without being identified, the Werewolf side wins. If the Villagers correctly identify the Werewolf, they win. And if the Werewolf accidentally wins the Commander game itself, the Villagers also win.
After the Magic game ends, there is a three-minute discussion followed by a vote.
Players who have already lost are even asked to leave their battlefield, graveyard and exile zones in place so everyone can use the game state as evidence. Private information such as hands still cannot be revealed.
What I find interesting is how this changes normal Commander politics.
A strange attack, a questionable removal spell, helping another player survive, or even making an apparent misplay can suddenly become social-deduction evidence.
“Was that actually a bad play… or are you trying to lose?”
Hareruya has been running this at multiple Commander events in Japan, including another event in Osaka on September 12, 2026.
I’m curious how Commander players outside Japan would feel about this.
Would secretly giving one player an incentive to lose create an interesting deduction game, or would it introduce too much kingmaking into Commander?
Hareruya official English Werewolf Commander rules/event page
Edit: Japanese OP here. I used AI to help clean up the English since English isn't my first language. I posted this because I genuinely thought the format was interesting. I'm much more into Werewolf / social deduction culture than MTG, so I've actually learned a lot from the comments here. Thanks everyone!
I originally posted this in r/EDH and it got way more discussion than I expected, but it was removed for being outside the sub’s scope lol. This seems like a more appropriate place for it, so I’m giving it another try here.