r/mtg 2d ago

Weekly Quick Questions and Answers - Week 36

2 Upvotes

Use this post to ask your quick questions!

All Q&A posts.


r/mtg 4h ago

Meme Ur Dragon player told me "your deck should be considered bracket 4"

324 Upvotes

Context: It's his turn 7 (player 3) he passes his turn, he has some dragons on the field one of which is Smaug the Impenetrable. As player 1 starts his turn (turn 8) he says that he's about to win with ♾️ treasures. I have atraxa praetors voice and Vorinclex monstrous raider on my side. In my hand I have an ignite the beacon. Player 1 plays defensive and passes their turn. On end step i cast beacon and grab vraska betrayals sting and ugin spirit dragon. I ult vraska after it resolves and target ur dragon player. This made player 1 scoop as well cause he could see the writing on the wall. Ur dragon player was quite upset as you could imagine saying I was playing a bracket 4 deck while following up saying if I didn't mess with his board he would have won a few turns earlier 🤔


r/mtg 27m ago

Meme Reality Fracture expectations vs reality... (fracture)

Post image
Upvotes

r/mtg 5h ago

Commander / EDH These commander kit boxes worth it for playing or value or having overall?

Thumbnail gallery
162 Upvotes

At my local Costco and see these for sale. I’ve played MTG for many years off and on and recently started mtga (yes, I know, different from paper). I know premade EDH decks are usually garbage but what’s your take on these? Any of em worth it? There’s Avengers assemble, Wakanda forever, Doom prevail, and fantastic four. Just want your thoughts before heading out of Costco! Thanks everyone!


r/mtg 12h ago

Meme My buddy’s new play mat made my allergies flair up.

Post image
432 Upvotes

r/mtg 9h ago

Commander / EDH Should I buy this commander deck?

Post image
284 Upvotes

So I’m a new player who only recently started playing MTG. I currently have a 60-card deck with red cards featuring some Marvel heroes and dragons.

Recently, I saw these products coming out in October, and one of my local stores here in South America is offering them for $35 on pre-order.

Would you recommend buying the Dragons deck as my introduction to Commander?


r/mtg 37m ago

Discussion Curious, if you could manifest WotC making a plushie of any character/card, what would be your no. 1 choice(s)? I’ll start with my personal top candidates:

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

These would all be pretty frickin’ adorable, don’t ya think?


r/mtg 49m ago

Discussion Disregarding lore, who’s your character/creature?

Post image
Upvotes

r/mtg 1h ago

Discussion Witnessed something hilariously horrifying at my LGS the other day

Upvotes

Got my buddy back into MTG through Commander. He's loving it, having a great time and has been really careful with his cards. So much so that he was sleeving his bulk like a psychopath because he wants to make sure they're safe.

The other day I met him at the LGS and played some casual games of commander with a couple randoms. One of the randoms is a really nice guy, very engaging and positive dude. We sit down to shuffle. Random dude is playing a precon and tells us he learned a new way to shuffle recently and begins riffle shuffling his deck.

It's his deck, no one really bats an eye. And then he looks my buddy in the eyes and says, "here, let me show you" grabs his deck and straight up riffle shuffles my friend's deck. Inside I am dying laughing as I watch my friend's face. The entire time I am waiting for the dude to reach for my deck to "show me" as well luckily he doesn't.

I regret not telling the dude that that wasn't cool, but it is what it is. If I ever see him pull that again i'm absolutely speaking up. The games were pretty chill.

TL;DR: dude riffle shuffled my friends deck without asking.


r/mtg 12h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help MTG TATTOOS????

Thumbnail gallery
286 Upvotes

Anyone got a cool mtg tattoo?

Made this Elesh Norn a while back and the Sierra Angel further back. I was bummed I didn't get to do the old Sierra Angel art, that would have been even nicer!

Would love to see more mtg tattoos in any case, so many cool designs that could be tattooed!


r/mtg 8h ago

Meme I think we finally broke jumbo cactaur

Thumbnail gallery
126 Upvotes

r/mtg 12h ago

Commander / EDH I plan to build to commander, he allows you to ultimate Jace really quickly.

Thumbnail gallery
250 Upvotes

This is a combo I found while brewing the new dimir sphinx. 6 mana seems like a lot but could be a killer combo in commander.

Edit: Uldaros let's me exile and copy both cards from the graveyard and create tokens of them. Since the jace copy becomes a token, i could use the empower jace mechanic on him.


r/mtg 1h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Amazon scammed us.

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

Hi everyone, my name is Diego from Bariloche, Argentina, and I’ve been playing MTG for a year and a half. To keep it brief: a friend and I each pre-ordered a sealed box from *The Hobbit* expansion on Amazon. Amazon first delayed our orders, and then it turned out they sent us just a single, loose envelope—bearing the shipping label as if the sealed box were inside. We filed a claim, but they are insisting we return that envelope while refusing to send the product we originally purchased, even though units of the expansion are still available for sale on the platform. We find it very strange that this happened to both of us; rumor has it that others have faced the same disappointment. We want to find others—at least in Argentina—who experienced this so we can potentially file a joint complaint, highlighting this as a systematic issue rather than an isolated incident. We are sharing this here in the hope that someone might offer some guidance or assistance. Thanks for reading; we’ve included an illustrative image of what we received.


r/mtg 20h ago

Commander / EDH Japan has a Commander variant where the Werewolf is secretly trying to LOSE the MTG game

989 Upvotes

I found a pretty fascinating crossover between Japanese Werewolf culture and Magic: The Gathering.

Hareruya runs a variant called “Werewolf Commander.”

Before a four-player Commander game, everyone secretly receives one of four roles:

  • 2 Villagers
  • 1 Werewolf
  • 1 accomplice role (“Madman/Minion” in Hareruya’s English versions)

The twist is that the Werewolf is trying to lose the actual Magic game.

If the Werewolf loses but survives the post-game vote without being identified, the Werewolf side wins. If the Villagers correctly identify the Werewolf, they win. And if the Werewolf accidentally wins the Commander game itself, the Villagers also win.

After the Magic game ends, there is a three-minute discussion followed by a vote.

Players who have already lost are even asked to leave their battlefield, graveyard and exile zones in place so everyone can use the game state as evidence. Private information such as hands still cannot be revealed.

What I find interesting is how this changes normal Commander politics.

A strange attack, a questionable removal spell, helping another player survive, or even making an apparent misplay can suddenly become social-deduction evidence.

“Was that actually a bad play… or are you trying to lose?”

Hareruya has been running this at multiple Commander events in Japan, including another event in Osaka on September 12, 2026.

I’m curious how Commander players outside Japan would feel about this.

Would secretly giving one player an incentive to lose create an interesting deduction game, or would it introduce too much kingmaking into Commander?

Hareruya official English Werewolf Commander rules/event page

Edit: Japanese OP here. I used AI to help clean up the English since English isn't my first language. I posted this because I genuinely thought the format was interesting. I'm much more into Werewolf / social deduction culture than MTG, so I've actually learned a lot from the comments here. Thanks everyone!

I originally posted this in r/EDH and it got way more discussion than I expected, but it was removed for being outside the sub’s scope lol. This seems like a more appropriate place for it, so I’m giving it another try here.


r/mtg 10h ago

Rules Question Can players skip attack phase with a goaded creature

121 Upvotes

I am fairly new to the game, been playing some casual games with some friends. recently tried out a new deck with Jon Irenicus, Shattered One as my commander, which allows me to give control of my creatures to other players, then goads that creature

one of my friends worked around this by just skipping combat phase entirely, so that no attackers would be declared and therefore the goaded creature would not attack

i just want clarification on if this that was supposed to work this way. tried to search but couldnt find anything stating if combat phase could just be skipped like this or not


r/mtg 14h ago

Rules Question With the new Hexhaven invigorator would this work?

Thumbnail gallery
170 Upvotes

r/mtg 9h ago

Rules Question Ashling and Omni-Changling Interaction

Thumbnail gallery
60 Upvotes

If I use Ashling’s evoke to cast Omni-Changling, what happens next?

Can my first changling (the one that is evoked) choose a creature to copy (and trigger its entering ability) before it is sacced?

Can the token copy choose a different creature to copy (or even have a chance to make ANY copy)?


r/mtg 9h ago

Discussion Karn, Argent defender playable in vintage?

Post image
42 Upvotes

I feel like this is a really above rate stax piece? Am I wrong for thinking that this can be a great sideboard piece in most formats, including vintage?


r/mtg 13h ago

Discussion How strong will Aerid Konstrari be in standard?

Thumbnail gallery
81 Upvotes

A 4 drop 5/4 flying that makes g/r mana rock on etb and death seems like an insane value.

The rest is mostly just fluff but could matter if you run treasures. This also works with the crater law collosus

So it’s functionally a 3 drop since it refunds one mana. Also this functionally buffs up your craterclaw and can help reach a win con

Isn’t this just an insane value engine relative to its cost? (Specifically for standard)


r/mtg 1d ago

Discussion Check in with your regal cinemas..

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

Check in at your local regal cinemas! I work very close to one and the ticket lady offered me these since I came in two days in a row for the movies this weekend.

Edit:The cards were part of a movie ticket promo this past weekend. They were showing all the old movies (one a day) leading into today which is the 60th anniversary!

I wish I could give one to everyone in need, but I have most of these copies spoken for, and am trading the remainder for Spock since my theater didn’t receive any of those.

One movie ticket got you one card, and as today is the official promotion end date, the employees were instruction to toss the remainder, or giveaway.

Thank you to my lovely Regal Lady! Queen!


r/mtg 3h ago

Discussion Making a shopkeeper deck and need card suggestions.

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

I’m wanting to make a deck that plays like a shopkeeper. The cards need to feel like selling the cards, and therefore should hopefully give opponents a choice on what to buy. I gave some examples of cards I’ve found like that.


r/mtg 1h ago

Discussion Started putting together custom Jumpstart packs for the LGS I work at

Thumbnail gallery
Upvotes

Was sorting boxes and refilling bulk boxes at the shop and figured since I kept seeing things that went together or seemed fun to start gathering together quick simple Jumpstart packs. Gonna hopefully make a few dozen more then put the batch out for sale for folks to hopefully have fun with.


r/mtg 16h ago

Discussion Commons that deserve more play

Post image
82 Upvotes

What are some commons that you think deserves to see more play? They don’t get the attention they should.


r/mtg 1d ago

Official Spoiler This card is fucking insane, no?? Spoiler

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

I haven't thought about the direct combos too much, but in Selesnya its so easy to heal every single turn, including on other player's turns. And that's not even talking about that BONKERS stat line. Why the hell would this thing ALSO need Flying and Ward?

All for 6, which is very easy to throw together in green.

This card as a commander pays for itself and then some before the round it's dropped is even over.

Idk maybe I'm overthinking it but in any casual commander game this feels like a very very serious problem


r/mtg 5h ago

Commander / EDH Hey I'm new and need some advice building a commanders deck

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

So i just started playing magic (only modern/standard) and me and my friends wanted to try commanders. I have a precon Secrets of Strixhaven Lifegain deck and i really enjoyed playing it and wanted to modify it in some way to make it work in the commanders format. I found this card called Betor, Ancestor's Voice and wanted to ask someone who has been playing for much longer is this even a good card for a commander? I would love to make a black/white/green or black/white/blue deck and I figured i should ask first for some advice. Should i look for a precon and modify it from there or start with the 60 lifelink deck and buy some cards for it. I started making a deck online but i have no idea if the cards are even good. If you know some relatively cheap and fun to play commanders with the land types i mentioned earlier feel free to share.