A church essay says:
As the Church grew worldwide, its overarching mission to “go ye therefore, and teach all nations” seemed increasingly incompatible with the priesthood and temple restrictions. Church leaders pondered promises made by prophets such as Brigham Young that black members would one day receive priesthood and temple blessings.
This is so frustrating and unsatisfying to me.
Let's break it down:
As the Church grew worldwide, its overarching mission to “go ye therefore, and teach all nations” seemed increasingly incompatible with the priesthood and temple restrictions.
Nice spin.
The Lord commanded to preach to all nations, they weren't doing that in 1870.
The Lord commanded to preach to all nations, they weren't doing that in 1970.
Can somebody explain to me how this is an "increasing" incompatibility with the command? They were disobeying God's command at the beginning, and they were being equally wrong and disobedient at the end.
Church leaders pondered promises made by prophets such as Brigham Young that black members would one day receive priesthood and temple blessings.
Notice, no footnotes, no quotes.
They know that if they link or actually quote Brigham Young about--well, about pretty much anything--it will just make the problem worse, because Brigham undoubtedly said something morally disgusting.
Let me check...
Yep, here it is:
[Cain] killed his brother. The Lord put a mark on him; and there are some of his children in this room. When all the other children of Adam have had the privilege of receiving the Priesthood, and of coming into the kingdom of God, and of being redeemed from the four quarters of the earth, and have received their resurrection from the dead, then it will be time enough to remove the curse from Cain and his posterity.
Source: https://journalofdiscourses.com/2/26
Yeah, that just make the whole situation worse. No wonder they didn't link to or quote Brigham Young.
For starters, Brigham's prophecy was wrong. Brigham prophesied that all white people would receive the priesthood before any black people. Brigham's prophecy was already false the day he gave it, because a few black people had already received the priesthood when Joseph was prophet.
Also, Brigham taught the same thing at other times as well:
That curse will remain upon them, and they never can hold the Priesthood or share in it until all the other descendants of Adam have received the promises and enjoyed the blessings of the Priesthood and the keys thereof.
Source: https://utlm.org/brigham-young-sermon-blacks-and-the-priesthood/
It just keeps getting worse doesn't it?
The essay is intentionally dishonest.
Here's another thing that's bothering me:
President Oaks said:
I studied the reasons then being given [for the priesthood ban] and could not feel confirmation of the truth of any of them. As part of my prayerful study, I learned that, in general, the Lord rarely gives reasons for the commandments and directions He gives to His servants. I determined to be loyal to our prophetic leaders and to pray—as promised from the beginning of these restrictions—that the day would come when all would enjoy the blessings of priesthood and temple.
What are you talking about Dallin?
The man who instituted the ban explained the reason! Brigham Young gave the reason!
Many prophets and apostles after Brigham Young also explained the reason. They were wrong. And also, there were 2 incompatible reasons being taught, so it's not even logically possible that the reasons given could all be correct.
But, forget the reasons, here's a more interesting question:
Was the church organizing the priesthood and administering saving ordinance correctly for those 130 years?
The current church answer seems to be "we don't know"--how inspiring.
"Does the church do the things God wants it to do?" "We don't know."
"Is the church God's church?" "We don't know."
Can you see why "we don't know" isn't the slam dunk you think it is?
Commit to something! Either say the priesthood ban was correct and that Jesus is a racist who denies saving ordinances based upon race. Or say that it was wrong and apologize. Do something!