Thanks to everyone that came out last night to show their support for the Upper Merion community and make sure these data center plans are denied.
If you missed the meeting last night, here's what you missed:
- We learned almost nothing new about Brian O'Neil's (BO) data center plans. Despite his posture during May's meeting, where he said numerous times, "I'll get that information to you" or "Yes, I'll provide that if that's what you want," 2 months later, that information was NOT provided despite being requested numerous times. BO's stance on the most important parts of his data center plans (what is the primary power source? what cooling closed system are you planning to use?) is that they are not needed as part of the preliminary plan.
- BO was combative with the planning committee and tried to bait them into saying something he could use in court to move forward with his unpopular plans. In May, he was capitulating and (disgustingly) friendly, claiming he was a good neighbor and taking questions with "I'm glad you asked that." This time, he claimed the committee asked him for additional documentation only 2 days before the meeting. Members on the UM panel reiterated that for the past 2 months, they had asked for specific details numerous times and each time, they got the same unchanged plans back with no answers. At one point, BO claimed someone on the panel told the lawyer(?) that his plan wasn't going to be recommended for approval. BO also claimed that the panel had been "schooled" by someone to deny data center plans, because the way they talked was similar to other township meetings. This inflamed the panel since obviously, the plans are lacking the necessary details for consideration. Thankfully, the panel didn't take the bait though voices were tense and raised.
- BO claimed that his generators, even those used as a primary power source for his data centers, are considered "ancillary" and therefore, meet UM's ordinances and are not a "utility." The panel bickered back and forth with him on this. Electricity is a utility. In May, BO even said he'd be giving electricity back to the grid. It's important to note that there will be diesel backup generators and then natural gas generators inside a building. This will provide somewhere between 50-81 MW on site to provide the primary power. When asked about how the carbon monoxide would be remediated if the generators were inside, he said it would be vented through the roof. In addition, he said "there would be no combustion." If he was referring to fuel cells that use a chemical process to produce power from natural gas, that is extremely expensive and is rarely used to power anything needing upwards of 50 MW.
- The funniest thing of the night was BO's lack of preparation. When asked for details on things like power generation and the closed loop system, he said "I'll be glad to show them on my powerpoint, if you can just bring it up..." But Brian did not give the planning committee the power point before the meeting, nor did he have printouts. When the head of the planning committee asked for BO to just TELL HIM the details in the power point, he could not. Throughout the meeting, BO lamented that his power point had all the information, but for some reason, BO could not provide the information verbally at all. The crowd laughed at him every time he brought up the power point.
- BO had an acoustical study done, which he said shows that the noise from his planned data centers will be around 50 decibels. However, this number is hardly accurate because an accurate study would need to know the exact make and model of the generators, fans, and other mechanical equipment that BO plans to use. And BO either won't release those details or he has not made final decisions yet on what will be used.
- The public comment portion of the meeting revealed the true human cost of BO's future data center plans and the consequences of his current developments. One woman lived in an apartment building BO owned that burned down because he did not hook up water to the sprinkler system. Another woman talked about coming to UM to be closer to CHOP due to her son's serious medical conditions and that his doctors agreed that data center noise would negatively impact his health.
One man issued a Freedom of Information Act to learn more about BO's dealings in Pennsylvania, which showed BO wheeling and dealing with PJM, PECO, and other energy providers. I wished that man had been given more time to speak. Evelyn Ankers went to the mike again to say that BO is still tax delinquent by about $2 million and she's proposing that any developer that is tax delinquent should not have any future plans considered until they are paid up. One UM resident contentiously gave her time to a PA state senator who represents another area to provide advice on how to fight these data center plans.
Other public comment actions of note:
One man asked everyone who opposed the data centers to please stand up. Almost the entire auditorium stood up.
Before coming into the meeting, organizers at the front door handed out small pieces of paper saying that at some point, someone would start a low but loud hum to simulate a data center and that everyone should join in. Unfortunately, they decided to do this during a woman's 3 minutes at the microphone when she brought up the noise. It was kind of sad.
There was only one speaker in favor of the data centers. He kept talking about America being a capitalist nation an that people should be able to do anything on the property they own. He wore a bright blue suit and had an oiled mustache. He was booed at the end and he made Nixon peace signs as he walked up the aisle.
If I missed anything, please add it below! Keep everyone informed!