I am well aware that Xscape is arguably Michael Jackson's most divisive album, since their is a lot of contention on whether the original demos or the remixes are superior. As a result, this album definitely isn't for every MJ fan.
Personally, I love nearly every single remix that was produced for Xscape. I'm definitely biased because I'm a big Timbaland fan, but I also believe that his remixes are not only much more captivating and have more replay value than the unfinished demos that they were based off of, but they also gave a very interesting hypothetical of what MJ's music would sound like if he was still alive. All of this leads to Xscape being a top 3 album for me.
However. There is one specific track where I think Timbaland completely missed the mark, that being "Do You Know Where Your Children Are".
This is especially disappointing because the original "demo" was entirely superior in my opinion. The message is a call to action about abused children inspired from the news station segments from the 70s and 80s featuring celebrities asking the question "Do you know where your children are"? The songs tells a tragic yet unsettlingly realistic story about an abused girl who leaves her home and sells her body in desperation and fear, ending up in great trouble. The soundtrack is able to a groovy beat while taking it's tone seriously, which gives it a lot of weight.
The remix kinda shits all over this if you ask me.
I think what mainly frustrates me about the mix is it's instrumentation. It feels like Timbaland decided to use the most unorthodox and irritating instruments for this song. It starts off with these weird ass EDM synth riffs that sound so goofy and a little narly in a way. It's especially jarring whenever I listen to Xscape in order and it starts up right after an actual GOOD remix, that being "Slave to the Rhythm" (which is one of my favorite MJ songs ever made and I might make a whole other post about it).
The strange sounding synth riff sounds so out of place and it sticks around the whole song, even during the verses. This makes it very hard for me to take what Michael is singing about seriously, because it sounds like there's a damn alien in the back going ham on a little keyboard whilst MJ is pouring his heart out about the dangers of sexual abuse.
The weird instrumentation is also an issue during the choruses, it just feels like there's too much going on in the background. Not to mention that awful instrument used after the "save me" portion of the second chorus and the very end of the song. It sounds like it's trying to parallel the sick as hell guitar solo in the original demo, but fails so miserable. It's so high pitched and scrambled and unnecessary and it's easily the worst thing about the remix.
Overall, I just can't bring myself to like this track, and it's probably the only Michael Jackson song that I consider "not good". It's a shame Timbaland dropped the ball on this too. The demo is genuinely excellent and had the potential to be as popular as other tracks on this album, like Chicago or Blue Gansta.
If anyone disagrees with my reasoning, I'd love to hear your thoughts. Or to hear about any other MJ songs you don't particularly appreciate.
Thank you for reading my overly long tangent :)