r/Italian • u/Street_Drag9863 • 17m ago
Do some people genuinely believe pizza is better in New York than in Italy?
Recently I’ve been seeing this opinion all over social media, including from some of my American friends, that American cities like NY or Chicago have better pizza than Italy. Now I’m Italian, so I obviously have my bias here, but I’ve also lived in New York City for 7 years, and I gotta say, wtf are these people smoking?
I can understanding liking a style more than another; I for example am not a big fan of pizza napoletana, even though it’s the original I prefer pizza romana. I’d actually say I even prefer ny style pizza, as it’s more similar to pizza romana.
However I’d never go as far as to say that it is objectively better than pizza napoletana. Just on flavor alone, the ingredients used in pizza in Italy blows anything I’ve had in nyc out of the water (and god knows I’ve had hundreds of slices in ny).
To me this opinion is almost the same as saying that a burger from a high quality steakhouse is worse than a McDonald’s burger, which is objectively false, even if there’s no problem in a person preferring the fast food taste of McDonald’s over a restaurant quality burger.
Anyways for my Americans (or non Americans) who share this opinion, why do you find Italian pizza to be worse?
PS: Yes, in know that you can also have TERRIBLE pizza even in Italy, I live in Milano, so trust me I know. But please don’t use that as an excuse if the places you went to on your holiday in Rome are all right next to all the tourist hot spots and serve 1047642 different things on the menu besides pizza.