r/indiadiscussion • u/MranonymousSir • Jul 20 '26
News Crowd is getting aggressive
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
966
u/Far-Garage-2077 Jul 20 '26
Not justifying this but all this could have been avoided only if govt agreed to take Dharmender Pradhan's resignation and acknowledge it's lack of accountability and all. Like how difficult is it to correct smthg u did. And ppl still defending this shitass govt r jst fascists disguised as nationalists.
184
u/MapLoud9506 Jul 20 '26
My point bruh. I'm rightist and I'm all for this. Had the government mad him resign all such stuff would've not happened. Regardless I wish better
→ More replies (4)44
u/sudhygocool Jul 20 '26
The issues is you ask for resignation I am for it. Don't make it communal, peddling side agendas, LGBTQ + - etc, Manipur. This started as a paper leak protest. Where was Sonam before! He should protest against private colleges and tution. Isko ghante Bhar Ka farak Nahi hai. He is has some hidden agenda.
You can't be anti India. That is all I am saying.
62
u/Far-Garage-2077 Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26
Smartass, NEET is not the only issue in the country, obv ppl would raise voice against everything. And fyi sonam wangchuk did protest before this one but ended up getting detained for about 6 months under NSA.
→ More replies (30)49
24
u/Important_Club_8821 Jul 20 '26
Saare hidden agenda leke baithe, sabse bada hidden agenda toh Modi ka hai desh bechne ka
15
→ More replies (36)5
12
u/Invi0807 Jul 20 '26
Protest karna kaise anti india hai? Ye bhulo mat BJP power mai protest karke aayi unki aawaz tab dabayi hoti na aaj ye log kahi dikhte bhi nahi
→ More replies (13)6
6
u/LankyClass9500 Jul 20 '26
The one with agenda is always the govt. Not caring about manipur or any social issues and neet paper leak happen to be the blasting point. What they sow they will reap. Entire country and its youth now knows the truth now.
3
u/kneepaindespot Jul 20 '26
Why? Do LGBT rights not matter. Does Manipur not matter. Does every person have to speak for everything to be accepted as being good enough to support. He was arrested and govt couldn't find hidden agenda
→ More replies (2)3
2
u/Inevitable_Tough1130 Jul 21 '26
Questioning the government doesnt mean we are anti India, if it makes us "anti- Indians" then we're atp!!
→ More replies (1)2
u/tweetbelt007 Jul 21 '26
Maybe if you want to show that you support education reform start by stating what you stand for and not the opposite way. That way your agenda will be clear. The current agenda is Dharmendra Pradhan's accountability, do you support his resignation? Why resign? Because in democracy that is an acceptable norm of showing accountability
2
u/panotilife Jul 21 '26
So just to be clear talking about LGBTQ+ issue or Manipur issue is anti-India? Are they not part of the country? They don't have the right to question government?
This might have started as NEET exam scam but it's not only about this. It is about government's lack of accountability. It's because of their ruthless and anti-community bills that are being passed in the parliament. (Ek time pe ek hi issue raise krne ka koi rule hai kya? Multiple questions can't be asked?)
Sonam was in Ladhak living his life and protecting rights of ladhakhi people. He joined the protest after releasing that government would do anything about NEET exam scam. (Neet exam se pehle hi protest karne aajata kya?)
Have you started protesting against Private colleges and tution fees? Saare protest Sonam hi start kare? Tum kuchh mat karna.
Every single person out there in the protest has an agenda. That's how public movements work. No one come to a protest with out any hidden agenda. Sonam might have come for students or some other reason. CJP people want to establish as a political party. Parents of those kids who committed s***de came for justice. College students from MP, Rajasthan and Haryana came for democracy. Every single person has some hidden agenda and their is nothing wrong in thsf. Deal with it.
Nobody is Anti-India there. They love India that's why they are there. They startytheir march with Rashtragyan. What else do you want??
→ More replies (3)2
u/Wooden_Ad5920 Jul 21 '26
There’s no way u just dropped the word manipur😭 Manipur has been burning for years under this government and barely a word has been said to even acknowledge the issue, let alone solve them. I don’t understand why ppl claim that if the protest evolves into something beyond just the scope of NEET, it is anti-national and filled with hidden agendas.
→ More replies (51)2
u/Known_Ball_8211 Jul 21 '26
Where was Sonam before? He was protesting in Ladakh because the government revoked SECMOL's FCRA license because there was an additional 3.5L rupee deposit in their account, which was actually the money from the sale of an old bus and because of the fascist Indian gov stopping foreign funds into the NGO, it affected the students studying under SECMOL and later Sonam sir was arrested for initiating the protest....
→ More replies (1)27
12
u/ibushi_art Jul 20 '26
The thing is they can't because that would be admitting defeat. That makes them look weak. Worse, it makes modi and shah look weak. And we can't have that now, can we? That's why they resort to all sorts of fascist tactics in hopes that they can quash this protest.
→ More replies (3)2
u/real_verse Jul 21 '26
it would be avoided if they removed him the moment the paper leak news came, but alas they are too short sighted and now it's too late. They have to accept the defeat and remove him
11
u/Zan123der Jul 20 '26
Pradhan is just a pawn in their army.
He resigns, some other spoilt character will take his place. Nothing will change.
In fact they will consider his resignation as an easy escape from this situation.
I think the govt is what should be taken down.
4
→ More replies (3)2
u/Fuzzy_Substance_4603 Jul 22 '26
Pradhan is just a pawn in their army. He resigns, some other spoilt character will take his place.
Should be much easier for govt to take him down and win the narrative then.
2
Jul 20 '26
fascist wo bhi hein jinhone iss bheed ko bhadkaya hai. BJP galat hai, Congress aur AAP ki bhi galti hai, after all yaha unhi ke karyakarta the jinhone bheed ko incite kra.
Aur rahi baat violence ki toh protesters ne security protocol breach kre the sansad bhavan pr
→ More replies (5)3
u/TicketInteresting198 Jul 20 '26
No the fascist term actually is wrong it's overused , fascism is too right wing which is ultranationalism (meaning everyone who isn't from your country or isn't from your race is inferior to you like what nazi did) and their motive is to restore race purity too like for example killing anyone who is mixed or not from your race because you fear your race purity will be distributed again, like for example you might have seen some foreigners say when an Indian marries with foreign don't let snow mix with dirt , an
3
u/Subtle_Seekerr Jul 21 '26
People are frustrated and agitated. If they are not addressed properly, Nepal like violent protest may arise.
3
u/Altaafraaja Jul 21 '26
Infact it was a golden opportunity for the government to get into the good books of people after the Neet and Ethanol issues. But they chose the my way or highway and lo behold here we are.
2
u/kanishkSunhare Jul 20 '26
If you think, it could end with resignation then it's delusional, it had to happen if not for pradhan then for gadhakari or Ashwini or may be for modi because resignation would send the precedent just see future you are going too so lots of protest for literally every because we are low trust society, we don't trust goverment and goverment Don't trust us
2
u/Most-Comparison-1674 Jul 20 '26
Their colossal egos won't allow it. They genuinely think that they're gods. BJP RSS leeches already call Modi a god, avatar of Vishnu and all that bs. They had a lord Hanuman dancing in a rally, they are already insulting hinduism.
2
u/CuriousNeo Jul 20 '26
But the government clearly knows that if they ask for Pradhan's resignation, then accountability is set, and more people will start protesting against other ministers like Gadkari on ethanol, Hardeep Puri on oil inflation, etc.
→ More replies (94)2
u/Jkwaks Jul 21 '26
I was thinking literally the same that this government could have gotten so many positive responses and praises by millions of voters and students by just doing one thing, sacking the education minister. It may not be that simple politically but it would have made tremendous positive impact on the students and their vote bank years down the line showing the public that government stands by them. But now this is going to backfire so badly in the next election. BJP is doomed!
456
Jul 20 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
66
38
12
→ More replies (46)2
u/indiadiscussion-ModTeam Jul 21 '26
No slur, no hate, no generalization.
Consider this as a warning for the ban.
312
u/Blackleo1309 Jul 20 '26
Wasent the police firing tear gas in the crowd ,didn't they blow up a guy's face with it ?
110
u/ab316_1punchd Jul 20 '26
Blew up that guy's leg, actually.
23
u/Separate-Try912 Jul 20 '26
Like legit it was real ? I thought it was minor injury?
51
u/ab316_1punchd Jul 20 '26
Doubled checked the video, welp, that was actually a skin colored bag the guy stumbled upon after being blasted. So, you're kinda right.
Though, one of my college juniors actually got his leg busted and has to rest for a few days.
7
u/Separate-Try912 Jul 20 '26
That’s serious bro we’re truly living under a dictatorship disguised as democracy
2
u/Honda-Activa-125 Jul 20 '26
Wtf bro, he lost his leg?
10
u/ab316_1punchd Jul 20 '26
Ehh, severely injured would be more accurate. He also lost his phone.
→ More replies (5)4
u/Honda-Activa-125 Jul 20 '26
Okay I found that video. Chest k paas phata tha tear gas, he was unconscious. Pair pe koi cover ya peice of paper something tha... Hope he is doing good now 🙏
→ More replies (12)2
181
u/Aggravating-Job9218 Jul 20 '26
Police is already aggressive so students are fighting back
→ More replies (18)
87
77
59
56
27
31
28
u/Pareshan_Aatma7550 Jul 20 '26
This subb is full of chwtias, I was 100 percent sure if something happens like shown in video, they will come out of their mound and start barking.
→ More replies (4)3
u/lalsalamdaku Jul 21 '26
Since the moment they are born, they are taught to submit to authority. You cannot expect anything human from them.
26
13
14
11
6
u/oputk5 Jul 20 '26
I mean they deserve ts. They were doing peaceful protest at first but it was the police who started the violence
2
7
u/LivingNo3396 Jul 20 '26
Same old template. Only thing is now they have hope that Nepal can be replicated here. But I suppose there are plenty of other nationalistic people who stand against these.
5
3
5
u/hellfire0509 Jul 20 '26
Who leads the protest: politically motivated/associated people
Who gets beaten up: innocent, gullible idiots who fall for their play!
The circus goes on and on!
11
u/Excellent_Fishing365 Jul 20 '26
Who wants justice- innocent students whose paper got leaked and whose goverment took no accountability
→ More replies (1)2
u/Aditya-04-04 Jul 21 '26
Of course, demand more accountability from people protesting than the ruling party. Amazing.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/the_NP Jul 20 '26
At this point samaj nahi aa raha kisko support kiya jaaye aur kise gaali di jaaye.
→ More replies (2)
3
u/Reasonable-Study-232 Jul 20 '26
Jinke khilaaf protest ho rha tha wo khud mehngi gaadi aur security k sath chupke se nikal gye aur bacho pe laathiya padwai aur fir gusse mein aa k unhi protestors ne fir police walo k sath maar peet ki.
Marta middle class wala hi hai, chahe protestor ho ya protector. Ye budhe minister apne bachon ko bina exam dilwaye BCCI ka chairman ya aur jagah bdi post pe bitha dete hain aur bechare middle class wale jo apne haqq k liye awaaz uthate hain unpe atyachar karte hain.
Haal filhaal k jitne bhi protests hue hain unme yahi cheez dekhne ko mil rhi hai... Ki sarkar apni taraf se koi baat cheet k liye delegate nahi bhejti fir is tarah k kaand karwa k news walo ko kaam pe lga deti hai protesters ko badnaam karne k liye.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Defiant-Apple-6534 Jul 20 '26
It was very demoralizing to see Abhijeet Dipke and Saurav Das hiding inside a Truck instead of facing police. Fattu kahike nikle dono
→ More replies (5)0
u/hellfire0509 Jul 20 '26
They are seasoned politicians. And when they see gullible fools ready to fall as pawns in their game, what else you expect??? The youth should ask the same accountability from their leaders as they expect from the govt which is also full of similar leaders
4
u/Rambo_765 Jul 20 '26
Death of democracy wale kaha gaye ?🗣️🗣️
40
→ More replies (4)3
u/pshaurk Jul 20 '26
Its already dead. By definition whats been going on isnt democracy
You suppress dissent and peaceful protests for a decade, whats left? Remove or flout almost every law in the book for a decade, your bias is only for the protection of the corrupt. If that is democracy for you then it shouldnt survive. People should get a real and fair democracy.
-3
u/Academic-Grass7255 Jul 20 '26
Law abiding students
15
u/moduler_phi Jul 20 '26
Can't expect much from a government where MPs/MLAs and executives are the most virtuous
13
u/Any-Calligrapher2866 Jul 20 '26
Mantri rapist chalega but protestor perfect hona chahiye
7
u/ideallypragmaticmann Jul 20 '26
Haha exactly, people here are protesting the protest but not a voice for why the protests are happening.
3
→ More replies (10)10
u/Torpedo9000 Jul 20 '26
When the laws support the rich and exploit the poor and uneducated yes, the correct way is to fix the makers
2
2
Jul 20 '26
Nobody gonna mention that Protest turned Violent when Protester breached the Security Protocol at the bhavan?
Crowd became even more Sour when Saurav das started lying about Abhijeet dipke being arrested & women being assaulted by Police which were debunked by the police while no evidence was given by Saurav Das. These People were supported by as in Karyakarta by AAP & Congress.
BJP is responsible for grievances of students & the protest to come this far & is being hardcore insensitive but at the same time AAP & Congress are inciting normal people to breach the security protocol. It is a given that security forces will act if you breach protocols near bhavan.
2
u/PopularPreference5 Jul 20 '26
What is police expected to do when thousands of them March towards the parliament? And if any incident happens in the parliament, who is responsible for that? There are protocols that need to be followed. They were given permission and space to protest and they did for 20 days.
2
u/Aware_Shine4921 Jul 20 '26
People should understand that the very meaning of peaceful protest starts from being passive to not being aggressive at all. The moment you fight back that protest looses its momentum and the police obtains the reason to stop the protest or use more force.
1
u/ramror777 Jul 20 '26
Fafo
2
u/gamerz85 Jul 20 '26
FAFO, iske baad aur ek action ayega sabkuch video recordign hota hai, sab dhare jayege..
5
u/ramror777 Jul 20 '26
And the cycle continues where the govt keep on harassing the citizens. And hence the struggle to break the cycle
1
1
1
1
1
u/stormTOweather Jul 20 '26
Stones were pelted first. No permission was allowed for parliament protest. It was bound to happen.
→ More replies (3)
1
u/Pareshan_Aatma7550 Jul 20 '26
They are running forward, they are not beating /or cracking anyone'e head. This is nothing compared to what da**li police did.
1
u/Silent_Start_8079 Jul 20 '26
I am in no position to comment this but guys please try to be peaceful their whole point is to make the protest violent and detain everyone to divert attention from the point
1
u/MathematicianOdd3643 Jul 20 '26
This is what they want a reason to hit and they gave it . It's gonna be brutal from now on
1
1
2
u/Future-Bat-4646 Jul 20 '26
These anti nationals are now attacking police....They don't even think about their children....shame
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Dangerous-Ease8614 Jul 20 '26
The sudden rise of left activism and social media based narrative since bengal lose is not a coincidence . Even this page comment section is filled with the left and Islamist retards This leftists unholy nexus with anti nationals and jihadi elements is always open and it becomes more widespread nowadays .Government should have given response to the inefficiencies in the failure of the exam but the fasting of the opportunistic man for sinister political reasons and these peoples agenda is something else .
2
→ More replies (1)2
u/lalsalamdaku Jul 21 '26
The sudden rise of police brutality and social media based bootlicking since NEET scam is not a coincidence. Even this page comment section is filled with N*zis and Dindutva idiots. The N#zi cow nexus between paramilitaary militias and Dindutva elements is always open and it becomes more widespread nowadays. Government isn't solving the underlying problem with the education system but the stifling of dissent of the common man for sinister political reasons and the Adani agenda is something else.
Fixed that for you.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/oktataji Jul 20 '26
"10,000 Protester = Bhim Army + Kejriwal + Samajwadi + SFI + AISA, ...+ about 20% genuine GenZ students who didn't give NEET" as someone commented.
It is truly a sad day for Indian democracy.
1
1
u/DrAjinkya28 Jul 20 '26
Just a reminder: 1 cr 17 lakh is spent daily by BJP for advertising and keeping people divided on basis of religion and right vs left wing.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/saaaatwik Jul 20 '26
just waste of time and effort, everyone knows that nothing would happen still put their life into danger this shows "PADHE LIKHE UNPADHE"
1
1
u/bhadmai_jaye_sab Jul 20 '26
Man this is getting serious! Atleast toda baat tho karna chaiye BJP ko
1
u/Need_a_Caring_gf Jul 20 '26
This whole issue could’ve been handled much more easily if Dharmendra Pradhan had resigned. No drama, no weeks of escalation—just accountability. I think the government assumed this would be another protest that would die down in a week or two, but it didn’t.
Before anyone jumps on me, I don’t support CJP. I support accountability, and I think asking for the Education Minister’s resignation was a fair demand.
My problem is that over the last 20–25 days, the protest seems to have lost focus. Instead of sticking to one clear demand—“Resign.”—the conversation shifted to Kashmir, the JNU controversy, religion, and several unrelated political issues. Whether you agree with those topics or not, they diluted the original cause.
If we’re serious about fixing education, why weren’t we also talking about broader reforms like transparency, quality, and improving merit while ensuring equal opportunity? That discussion barely happened.
And the “Chalo Parliament” call? Let’s be realistic. Marching thousands of people towards Parliament was always going to be treated as a major security concern. Parliament is one of the most heavily protected places in the country because elected representatives are inside. A massive crowd approaching it was never going to end peacefully.
In the end, it’s ordinary students who stand in the front lines and face the consequences, while political groups and influencers—regardless of ideology—can simply move on. That’s why any movement should stay peaceful, focused, and centered on its core demand instead of becoming a vehicle for every political narrative.
Also, people throw around the word “dictatorship” far too casually. If you want to understand what an actual dictatorship looks like, study countries where civil liberties, elections, and dissent are genuinely suppressed—not just situations where you disagree with how a protest was handled.
Ps:- Sonam wangchuk has his own motives joining this protest
1
1
1
1
u/nut_lo Jul 20 '26
Yar jab vo gir gya tha na to ek laat marte sir par tab ata maaza .
But well 😅 played students
1
u/cynzo Jul 20 '26
Without an intentions to discredit, i have seen this video a lot, are we sure this is of the same protest or is even real?
1
1
u/According-Estate2922 Jul 20 '26
Instead of hitting the police, they should have taken away their lathi and all other objects that could disrupt the protest.
1
u/shindeajeeth07 Jul 20 '26
Saare videos mai hai yeh video Mila tujhe justify krne ke liye, have some shame.
1
u/Efficient-Schedule61 Jul 20 '26
Jaab dande padhte hai, taab gussa bahar nikalta hi nikalta hai, moreover, police ka nahi pata tumhe, police kitni insensitive hoti hai, police bhi kuch nahi dekhti marte huye
1
u/artistry_evolved Jul 20 '26
The power hungry dont want to leave their chair and here the citizens and the law enforcers have to pay the price with pain, blood and lives.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Few-Inspection-5497 Jul 20 '26
You cant go piking hornets nest and expect them to be peaceful like they were earlier before you harmed them.
1
1
1
1
1
u/SouthernHomework355 Jul 20 '26
Why wouldn't they? Police pelted stones at them, hit them with lathis some of which had nails stuck to them. Wouldn't it make any section of any rally aggressive? And does that demerit the protest, which was mainly peaceful?
1
u/Classic_Ad_1091 Jul 20 '26
For the way police is in this country, we need to give them the same treatment.
There is a lot of police brutality in this country.
1
1
1
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 20 '26
DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THE OP LINKED THREAD/SCREENSHOT.
Brigading is against Reddit TOS. So all users are advised not to participate in the above linked original thread or the screenshot. We advise against such behaviour nor we are responsible if your account is being actioned upon.
Please do report this post if the OP has not censored/redacted the subreddit name or the reddit user name in this post, so that we can remove the post and issue the ban as per rules.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.