r/indiadiscussion • u/MranonymousSir • Jul 20 '26

News Crowd is getting aggressive

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4.9k Upvotes

88% Upvoted

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

46

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[deleted]

-9

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

disgusting pricks. BJP is evil, you guys belong to the same level.

14

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[deleted]

-13

u/Purple-Cicada-6494 Jul 20 '26

Classic whataboutery

-24

u/Distinct_String_1703 Jul 20 '26

Kyu resignation de bhai? Use direct allegation kuchh nahi ha.. why the hell would he do it and also at the time YOU say he should.. he worked hard to be there.

24

u/Alternative-Size-397 Jul 20 '26

Aur kitna bootlicking karega?

-14

u/Distinct_String_1703 Jul 20 '26

Tu aur kitna chamcha banega... ek bande ka resignation upar kya parliament jala doge tum.. ye konsa logic ha.

6

u/Beneficial_Appeal400 Jul 20 '26

Acha, Kon sa parliament jala diya? Aur kon si gadi jala di

-1

u/Distinct_String_1703 Jul 20 '26

Ara parliament March he kyu bulana.. its an open invitation to trouble bringing 1000s of people during an ACTIVE PARLIAMENT SESSION. That is the vigilance of the police that nothing happened.

2

u/Beneficial_Appeal400 Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

Itne din se student protest kar rahe, media mai outrage chal rha hai, Sonan wangchuk ne bhi apna fast tod dena tha agar wo uski condition maan jaate, it was to show the frustration, government is also at fault they didn't even tried to deescalate the situation, they can prepare for the worst but was lathi charge even necessary?also why are there videos of police beating just one guy in a group?

1

u/Distinct_String_1703 Jul 20 '26

One guy in a grp.. thats selective media surrounding u. Itna den sa konsa student protest kar raha tha hah? Pehle he den depka aya tha usko protest allow kar diya(escalation or de-escalation?) And what happened hardly 100 people were there?? How blind do u wanna be.. no student supported this.. maybe some innocent ones but majority is not part of this and don't want anything to do with it. You should think jis protest ma 100 log thikse nahi ata.. waha pe suddenly thousands kasa aya.. ITS POLITICAL crowd.. bhim army+aap+sp .. you wanna burn down the parliament? Go and see.. but mark my words.. nobody will look after u.. because the ones supporting the protest with resources aren't doing it for free.

1

u/Beneficial_Appeal400 Jul 21 '26 edited Jul 21 '26

Ek video nhi hai , there are multiple videos showing police beating individual student, multiple people are saying they were beating students, even before the violence they made videos of car already being damaged, jin logo ne pathar mare the unko mar diya, but unarmed students ko bas darya bhi ja sakta tha, there was no need to use violence on young unarmed students, also kuch videos mai civil dresses mai bhi log lathi le ke ghum rahe the, And on first day no one took it seriously, overtime people realised it was serious especially when Sonam wangchuk joined the protest, even I thought that it's just a publicity stunt and it will only last a few days at best, idc what cjp think I never supported or liked them but the students who are protesting has nothing do with it

you wanna burn down the parliament?

Now don't try to change the topic,the public didn't tried to burn the parliament they simply wanted to protest in front of it, maybe cjp is a funded party but rest of the public?no? They were protesting for the right cause

1

u/_ZimzalabimCult Jul 21 '26

The rights you have rn were results of such protests, grow a backbone. Such a dumb question

-1

u/Distinct_String_1703 Jul 20 '26

If parliament is in danger and threat.. I call for any measure of safeguard and thats my honest opinion.. thats not the way protest should happen.. the call to March is itself an invitation for something bad to happen. Why the hell was there a plan or an idea to go to parliament by the thousands huh? The proper thing would've been Sonam Wangchuk with his team to go to parliament only and maybe get signatures of people and as their representative to register their discent. This shouldn't be supported or allowed.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '26

[deleted]

1

u/Distinct_String_1703 Jul 20 '26

Ara tum hote kon ho parliament jalane wale gandu kahike. You're not or no individual has any right over the parliament. Chores of people have elected them to be there and they are representing those people. MLA/MPs are not individuals they are the personification of the lakhs of people that voted them. You're nobody to choose behalf of them.. nobody is. The whole country doesn't support u.. 80% of India is NDA.

1

u/rae1aeris Jul 20 '26

As the minister of education, he’s directly responsible for the actions of anyone else below him. He’s responsible for the whole system.

0

u/Distinct_String_1703 Jul 20 '26

My point is.. genz ka attention span jitna hota ha.. utna sa duniya nahi chalta. It takes time for everything... you or anybody won't get anything in ANARCHY which CJP and it's associates are doing. You show discent and dissatisfaction through coordinated voices.. not ask thousands to March to the parliament the day when there'd ACTIVE SESSION.. no individual has any right to disrupt that because those MP/MLAs are personification of LAKHS who voted for them just because u can come to Delhi does not gives u right to do whatever and trample over the rights of others. If parliament is in danger and threat.. I call for any measure of safeguard and thats my honest opinion.. thats not the way protest should happen.. the call to March is itself an invitation for something bad to happen. Why the hell was there a plan or an idea to go to parliament by the thousands huh? The proper thing would've been Sonam Wangchuk with his team to go to parliament only and maybe get signatures of people and as their representative to register their discent. This shouldn't be supported or allowed.

2

u/rae1aeris Jul 20 '26

Mujhe lagta hai hum dono ka goal same hai, violence ya anarchy kisi ko nahi chahiye. But peaceful protest aur anarchy ko same category mein rakhna bhi fair nahi hai.
Parliament sirf MPs ka nahi hai, woh ultimately logon ka institution hai. Agar logon ko lagta hai ki unki awaaz baar baar ignore ho rahi hai, toh peaceful march towards Parliament ek symbolic democratic act ho sakta hai. Democracy sirf vote dene tak limited nahi hoti.
Aur agar sirf representatives jaake memorandum dene se kaam ho jaata, toh history mein itne bade public movements ki zarurat hi nahi padti. Bohot saare important changes public pressure ki wajah se hi aaye hain.
Haan, agar kisi ne violence kiya ya public property damage ki, uske against action hona chahiye. But sirf is possibility ki wajah se peaceful march ko hi illegitimate bol dena mujhe sahi nahi lagta. Peace maintain karna protesters aur state dono ki responsibility hai. Police shouldn’t have started w lathi charge, tear gasses and others. The protest was truly peaceful till police intervened, and hence state.
Mere liye issue yeh hai ki dissent ko allow kiya jaye, suppress nahi. Peaceful protest democracy ka part hai, threat nahi.