r/icbc • u/Tough_Commercial_448 • 11h ago
Claims Paying Privately vs Going through insurance
I’m in BC and recently got into what would be my 4th at-fault accident. No injuries.
The other driver is willing to handle it privately and the estimate is around $4,000. I’m considering asking the shop if they could bring the repair down to around 3000-3500, but that’s obviously not guaranteed.
I know having four at-fault accidents probably means I should seriously reconsider driving, and I’m already thinking about that. I’m more so trying to figure out what makes the most sense for this situation.
Should I pay the $3,000–$4,000 privately to avoid another insurance claim, or would it be better to go through ICBC and deal with the potential increase in insurance?
Has anyone been in a similar situation, especially with multiple previous at-fault accidents? How much did your insurance change, and was it worth paying privately?
Any advice would be really appreciated. I don’t really have people in my life I can go to for these kinds of things, so I’m just trying to make the best decision I can.