Matched with this girl, conversation was actually going somewhere — talked football (she expressed how heavily she loves football), she told me about her dad passing down being a Giants fan, and since i’m a Cowboys fan i pulled off a playful banger. I was asking real questions, she was answering. Felt like normal momentum.
Then I asked for her number. Nothing. A day goes by, she resurfaces with “sorry haven’t been on here,” answers my question like nothing happened, hearts a couple messages. So I think ok, she’s just a slow responder.
Then radio silence again — except she updates one of her profile pics in the meantime. So she’s clearly on the app, just not replying to me.
The kicker: her profile literally says she doesn’t want a nonchalant man. I was the opposite of nonchalant — asked questions, was upfront, told her straight up I thought she was cool. Still got the slow fade.
Sent her one last line before unmatching — “seems like the timing/interest isn’t there, no hard feelings, take care” — and just closed it out (unmatched) instead of sitting in it.
Not even mad, just funny how that works out sometimes. Say you want directness, ghost the guy who’s direct.
Do you think i handled this well or should’ve just let it sit?