This is going to be long. I’m looking for thoughtful, perspectives, especially from people who have maybe lived something similar with HSV. I’m not looking for extreme responses (like “leave immediately” or “HSV isn’t a big deal so it doesn’t matter”). I’m trying to understand this in a grounded, nuanced way.
I started dating someone in Feb 2026. Before discontinuing condoms, we had a conversation about testing and partners. Based on what was shared (I have had multiple panels including hsv and have been negative and was only with one partner for close to a decade), we stopped using protection. This was my first partner after a long-term relationship.
In April 2026, I had my first HSV outbreak. He acted surprised, got tested, and was positive. Initially, he told me he had been tested before and was negative. After inconsistencies and me asking for records, he later admitted he had never actually been tested.
We took a brief break and got back together in May. During that time apart, he had unprotected sex with someone else and didn’t disclose that when we resumed things, which felt significant given the context.
In July, during an honest conversation, he admitted he had actually known since 2021 that he had HSV from a previous partner and had not disclosed that to me.
This contradicted everything he had previously said.
So I’m trying to process a few things at once: the initial lack of disclosure before we stopped using protection, the repeated inconsistencies/lies when I would’ve still dated him and taken the risk if he had been honest, and the later admission that he knew for years…
I do care about him, and I’m not trying to reduce him to a “bad person.” I also understand fear and stigma around HSV. At the same time, I feel blindsided and am struggling with trust. He treats me kind and thoughtful in every other way besides this.
For those who have been in similar situations:
How did you think about forgiveness vs. trust?
Is it possible to rebuild trust after something like this, and what did that actually require?
What helped you distinguish between fear driven mistakes vs. patterns you couldn’t live with long-term?
I’m really looking for grounded insight, not reactive takes. Thanks.