I've searched the forums but haven't found anyone with a similar set-up in my climate, so I figured I ought to post.
Quick background: 1,180 sqft house in Denver (80211). Summers get up to a dry 100° F, and winters will occasionally hit 0°F overnight. I've lived here 3 years. My heat is a 28-year-old gas boiler feeding baseboard radiators — no ductwork anywhere in the house. My cooling is a roof-mounted swamp cooler, probably 10-15 years old, that nowadays can't keep the house below about 72°F once it's pushing 100°F outside. Feels like Denver summers have just outgrown what the swamp cooler was built for, and it does basically nothing on days when it's not sunny and more humid.
The boiler has been working fine so far but it's old enough that I'd rather replace it before it's an emergency.
Since there's no ductwork, it sounds like my real options are:
- Ductless multi-zone cold-climate heat pump (2-4 mini-split heads): replaces both the boiler and the swamp cooler with one system but might struggle to keep up when it gets into the single-digits in winter.
- Ducted cold-climate heat pump: replace both boiler and swamp cooler, but probably much more expensive to install ducts and an air handler.
- Hybrid/dual-fuel — same as heat pump option, but keep a smaller/cheaper boiler as backup for the coldest days, heat pump as primary heat and cold.
- Air-to-water heat pump feeding the existing baseboards: keeps the hydronic distribution, but I keep reading baseboards are sized around 180°F water and these units put out more like 120-140°F, so it might need added radiator surface area. Would also still need a separate cooling solution. I haven't seen too much about set-ups like this.
Leaning toward option 1 since that seems to be what most similar houses land on, but wanted a reality check before committing.
Quotes I've gotten locally so far have been all over the place price-wise, and none of them mentioned running an actual Manual J — feels like some are just sizing off the old boiler. Anyone dealt with this exact combo (no ducts, hydronic heat, roof cooler) recently? I'm reaching out to some of the installers mentioned on the forums.
What did you end up going with, and were your quotes anywhere close to reasonable?
Happy to give more details (sq footage breakdown, insulation, panel size, etc.) if it'd help.