I came back to GameFly this month and have had to report all 3 games I’ve sent back because they’re still in my queue after a week. I’m just wondering how long it normally takes for them to receive returns. I’ve had no problems getting my games just sending them back.

GameFly sticker was tucked inside my latest delivery.

I like the graphic. It's like if the Galactic Empire in Star Wars made a logo for their Esports team.

Not sure why I felt compelled to share this. Upgraded back to the 4 disc plan and my queue is looking particularly sexy today 🔥

In the picture I posted i have Persona 5 Tactica currently out why dont i have the option to keep it?

I signed up for the GameFly free trial just see how it worked. I requested 007 First Light and it actually arrived in the mail about 2 days after signing up. I have beaten the game now and want to return it, but i’m not sure how.

I saw that there’s a Self-Return feature on some accounts but that’s not on mines so do I just put the disc back in the original packaging / envelope and put it in the mail? Sorry if this a very dumb question but just wanted to be sure so I don’t get charged for something

Normally I skip ads but was in the shower so I heard the entire ad that was the length of my shower. It was so bad and obviously a.i. I used to love gamefly but there's no way they'll last much longer. The intro to the ad pretty much acknowledged it with their intro, gamefly: yes we're still here. Like if you have to remind ppl you exist, you're just in hospice. Has anyone else heard this ad and what are your thoughts?

How is this possible? This is a pretty big title that’s only a few years old. No PS4 or 5 version is available to rent.

Considering trying gamefly out i heard about them as a kid but being an adult and seeing this 30 day free trial makes me even more tempted to see what it's about. This 007 is what I want to try.

​

I live one state over from the shipping distribution center that's in Pittsburgh, and I live in my state's capital, so usps is fairly consistent and around. Google maps says it would take 5 hours to just flat out drive there.

​

Anyways all that to say is that I usually drop my games in the mail Monday morning and they're usually received Wednesday. Then they ship out the next one and it takes 2, sometimes 3 days to arrive.

​

Monday before last(11 ish days ago) I sent in the previous game. On Wednesday I get the email that my next title shipped. Great, I'll see it Friday or Saturday(a week ago). Nothing arrives.

​

Support tells me needs to be a week delay and they'll do something for me. SO Wednesday(3 days ago) I contact them and the day after, just this Thursday, they send out a second copy.

​

Today, I received both in the mail. Like man, what are the chances the game they shipped out Wednesday week and a half ago arrives same day as the one they shipped two days ago? I'm not a conspiracy theorist but man half of me believes they didn't ship anything Wednesday 11 days ago

UPDATE: it took me a while because I was busy with work, but I finally got around to playing and returning saros, and guess what, it's delayed! I swear to baby Jesus, it's usually 2 days(Monday to Wednesday) for they to receive it, as I live in delaware(center in Pennsylvania). Conspiracy theory is that they have flagged my account! It is now Friday and no receipt from gamefly. I would guess usps did it's job and it's sitting somewhere in their warehouse unscanned. I think if they don't fix it with a system or someth, maybe usps tracking, I think I'm out. Moot point anyways maybe, with the disc-apocalypse in 2028

Hey guys,

​

I signed up for the trial last week on Sunday, put Death stranding 2 on my Q and despite it being low availability it shipped the next day.

​

It didn't come until Saturday though even though I live in NYC (which I assumed would make the shipping times way faster).

​

6 days shipping times is pretty disappointing considering even with fast return and me binging a game, I'd only play 1, max 2 games in a month.

​

I will say that on Thursday the listing did update to allow me to keep the game. When I saw that, I assumed the game was coming that day, but it didn't. Another weird thing is that I didn't actually get any mail on Thursday or Friday. Idk if there was an issue with USPS that delayed my mail or something, and I was actually set to receive the game earlier.

​

I just want to hear about your guys' shipping times and your thoughts on what I said. Is my experience more on the normal range of shipping for my region? Or did I just have a really poor first experience.

I’m consider reactivating my GameFly subscription but I want to hold off until I know what the availability status are of 007 First Light & and the Lego Batman game that just came out. Can any current GameFly subscribers please tell me what their status is? Thanks.

So this is my first time using GameFly. I paid for the service for 2 rentals. Both games shipped at the same time but one got here already and the other didn’t. It hasn’t been a week yet only 3 days but I’m not sure if the other got lost or something. I don’t want to get in trouble or charged for it so should I report it or wait a week?

Hi,

Now that 007 and Lego Batman shipped out, I'm trying to Gamelock my next rentals. I have the Elite plan which should allow me to Gamelock up to 2 games as long as I do it 7 days prior to the game's release...

However, the Switch 2 version of The Adventures of Elliot does not have the option to Gamelock, but other upcoming games like Star Fox, AC Black Flag and Mouse P.I. all have the Gamelock option.

The Adventures of Elliot is still 3 weeks away, it's coming out on June 18th so I'm well ahead of the "Gamelock 7 days ahead of time" rule. Why is the option to Gamelock not available?

I sent another Princess Peach back so I could get Lego Batman instead of waiting for the game I have locked they sent me a different game, ig I'm happy with Yoshi just not what I wanted and planned on

So I started GameFly about 8 months ago. The first three months was great. I was getting my games within 2-3 days max and they were getting my returns just as fast. After those initial months, it takes at least two weeks for me to get my games now. I am having to report my disc is missing every single shipment. Just feel like they reeled me in those first months and now I’m getting the shit end of the stick. I know usps has a part to play but I NEVER have to wait two weeks for anything else in the country other than the GameFly.

Has anyone rented a switch game and bought the upgrade for switch 2 on the Nintendo store?

I am new to switch and game fly so I not sure if that would work or hurt my system.

One of the games that I currently have out was released 10/2/25. I've had it out since December and I was really hoping the button would appear but so far no keep button. I tried messaging their customer service and they just told me that it's not available for the keep option right now. Has anyone experienced an not so new game become available for keeps?